I am not sure of what your goals are, but with the bstaley 0-ring mod and a 0.110" transfer port, you can get 16FPE ave over 24 shots, with a low ES 20-25. PS: I haven't ran with those settings or that weight pellet, but offhand looks like a "normal" prod spread.
The bstaley mod is just 3-4 o-rings. Lots of info out there. If you need links, let me know.You can drill out your transfer port, or buy one from Marmit Militia for less than $9. Pellets: Might want to ask the previous owner which were best. CPHP were not that good for mine. H&N FTT 5.53 worked well.
Try adjusting your throw before removing an oring. Go 6.5 - 7 on preload. I use 1 brass washer plus three o-rings, which gives a stack height near 3 1/2 orings. With 2 orings, it will only provide only a little buffer if the valve stem is near the max stroke. Did you do a tissue test to make sure the poly port is not leaking?