Looks good ! Personally, I would not replace the pump cup . If you are concerned with " only " shooting at 630fps,,, be advised that is 97% of what an average new/rebuilt ones will usually do, in my experience . As long as it shoots 600+, I wouldn't bother it. Since you just got it,, the fps may go up a little after more pumping, oiling, & shooting, too. Also, due to its age, having to cock it first is no big deal. I have owned Sheridans for 60 years & always cock them first. It has " character. " This is all I would do with it ; SHOOT DAT THANG !
Very cool Christmas presents Mike. Other than the crack things are looking good and that is probably an easy repair or replacement. You consider making one?
I don’t know what has scratched that but I would polish it out, clean everything up, lather the cup with ND30wt oil , & put it back together. Unfortunately , that is a bad split in the forearm. Glue & clamp it back together. I would only opt for screws, if it split again. If the glue did not hold, rather than using screws, I would use these. Drill a small undersize hole, try to get some glue in the hole, cut the head off this paneling nail, tap it in& counter-sink . I would put a couple on each side.Just a small dab of caulk, filler hides it.
Yes on simple epoxy repair and hope it holds. It just may. I surfed for years Mike and have shaped and glassed a few. I aged out and had to give it up. My timing was just gone. Don't get upset but I can't help but think if it splits again to cut it full length and square it up then glass in a hardwood stringer. That would probably do it and look good too. Redwood stringer maybe?
I don't know why you wouldn't want to replace the pump cup once you have it out. You already have the adjustable pump arm so you can take up the slack from the slightly-shorter replacement pump cups.
That looks like a nice tight joint Mike. Good save!
It looks like your labor has sure paid off. I've waited to reply thinking you may post up after you stretch out the target some more. Hopefully I'll be able to give my Sheridan a good workout soon to check its shot placement on paper.