I already did lower the reg back to original. I had turned it up 1/4 turn and I'm sure it was too much. I'm probably going to have to turn it down even more but want to test it first. Duy's valve really woke this rifle up and I can see the settings you used Stephen won't work with his valve.
Well, I used your latest settings of 1/4 turn CC on the reg and a shim stack of .100 and when I went to pressurize my Liberty back up the only way to get it to hold air was cocking the rifle. When I shot the rifle the vel. kept raising as the pressure fell and got the most power at around 2500 psi. I'm almost thinking I need to put the rifle back to stock and go from there. Don't really know as this is the first PCP I've tried to tune.
I'll measure the thickness of the stock washer and the McMaster ones. I turned the reg down a quarter of a turn from original but it is just to hot right now to do any testing. I also have to be real careful when I use my compressor as I only have 1 more burst disks left until the end of July, beginning of August.
Mine has a vent hole.
Personally I won't change a thing with the regulator on my Liberty because I'm content for it the way it is.I'm not sure if Stephen ever tried any other washers in his but I seem to remember him smoothing the originals out but I could be wrong.