mellon's pin for the Sheridan will fit the Benjamin, also. you could call david at alchemy, and ask him to make you one. I think his would look much nicer.
After, I buy a rifle be it new or vintage. When I remove those roll pins I never put them back in. I go to the hardware store and go to the drawer section. Get the 1" x 3/16" steel dowel pins and 4 c-clips. Boom, dunzo!! Problem solved and you don't have to worry about making that hole slightly bigger every time you bash those roll pins in and out. I think it looks better also, but that my opinion. Lastly, those roll pins are a haven/magnet for gunk, lint, and other pieces of matter. Which I feel eventually makes their way into the air tube when you oil that location.
Rob, that a good idea. How do you groove it? Dremel with thin cut-off wheel?And I will chamfer the one end if I go the roll pin route. I made sure to support both sides, so there was minimal pressure on the tube.I plan on getting a cheap punch or punch set for the re-install. Thanks for all the ideas.