GTA
Airguns by Make and Model => Benjamin Airguns => Topic started by: RCO on June 21, 2015, 01:11:56 PM
-
I'd like to know if the Benjamin Phoenix NP2 Air Rifle has the same power plant as the other NP2 22 cal.
What PFE are you guys really getting from the NP2 that claim 26 FPE ?
-
Using CPHP 14.3 or JSB 18.1, I get almost 22 FPE. I do believe all the NP2s use the same power plant. Just different compression tubes (some with rails, some with grooves) and stocks.
-
I know the Phoenix has the 11mm scope mount but was wondering if that was the only difference. If the rest of the power plant is the same it would fit my hunting needs.
-
At Pyramyd the Trail NP2 is only $10 more. It has a rail instead of grooves. Much better.
https://www.pyramydair.com/search-results-ext?keyword=np2&sid=1375A617A415&N=0&Ntk=primary&q=np2&cx=002970863286801882398:jlcminxfwdw&cof=FORID:11;NB:1&saSearch (https://www.pyramydair.com/search-results-ext?keyword=np2&sid=1375A617A415&N=0&Ntk=primary&q=np2&cx=002970863286801882398:jlcminxfwdw&cof=FORID:11;NB:1&saSearch)
-
With CPHP my NP2 gives about 22 fpe before and after tune.
-
I'm getting 16.75 average fpe with 14.3 premier domes out of my .22 cal. np2 trail.
-
Rod, Did you replace the ram and seal?
-
Ken $10 more for a 177 but $50 more if a 22.
-
Rod, 21 or 22 FPE is bad enough for an advertised 26 FPS. If I could get on doing 22 FPE it would be OK. feel for you and don't know why it wasn't returned.
-
Rob, at Academy they are $209, if in stock. Me and a friend bought ours there.
-
Ken we don't have any, the closest is 300 miles.
-
Found this - http://www.cabelas.com/product/CROSMAN-BENJAMIN-TRAIL-NP/1861659.uts (http://www.cabelas.com/product/CROSMAN-BENJAMIN-TRAIL-NP/1861659.uts)
-
By the the time I chronied the gun, I had taken it down and changed the original piston seal. At this time, I realized it was not shooting as hard as the average NP2. I contacted Crosman again and they sent me a new gas spring but I was informed this would void the warranty if I did the work myself.
Thinking that after changing out the gas spring and replacing the factury piston seal with a JM seal of the same size and going over the gun with a fine tooth comb, it would surely pick up at lease 50 fps. It only picked up 15 fps on average.
I have not made up my mind if I want to stay with the NP2 platform. If
-
If I decide to give it another go, I would purchase the cheaper black model and change it out with my bedded camo stock.
Just because this gun doesn't shoot as hard as the average NP2, does not mean it a bad gun. I have a friend would not have any problem shooting it as is, for the right price. Don't under estimate what a 16 fpe can do to small game inside fourty yards.
It's a ways off to next hunting season, so I'm in no hurry at this time. Who knows what might come out by then🔫
-
I'd go with the N-Forcer Gas Piston should I find an issue with my NP2.
As it is it shoots the JSB 13.43 like laser rounds.
-
Where did you get the N-Forcer ram?
-
Hmmm..now you have my attention....N-Forcer???
Hey Rob, hope were not getting to off track, but if you have followed any of my post you would know how much work I have put into my NP2 to get it up to 20 fpe.
-
http://www.n-forcer.com (http://www.n-forcer.com)
-
Jeff you have my attention. What N Forcer spring would be needed, What FPE? How much?
I have guns shooting 18+ FPE. I was looking for a higher FPE for bigger game. The NP2 looked interesting at first when I saw the 26FPE, but then I saw that's not what they produce. Capello's test showed 19FPE.
I had a XS28 that did 24FPE but I want a gas piston. The Octane seems to be doing 25FPE but I have a few concerns. Trigger needs work and what about parts? Then there is the non removable silenair, so how can the crown be worked on?
-
I spoke with Paul, from N-Forcer briefly to get a feel on how hard it would be to do business with them. I was pleasantly surprised by his willingness to answer my questions. Not knowing what size or pressure rating I needed, I was ill prepared to make the call.
He informed me that he had one ready to ship to an airgunner, but he didn't know what gun it was going in.
Paul, informed me that no one ever made a reorder, so he did not know if the piston worked or not.
The piston most commonly sold was the MF 19 / 125 or 100 stroke. Charged to 2400 psi.
The selling price is $46.95 plus shipping.
-
A good source of info on Gas pistons.
http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=20192.0 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=20192.0)
The 19/125 is the one used in the NPXL and is used in the Hatsan 125/135 conversions. (Walther Talon included as it's a 125)
A search for N-Forcer brings up a lot of info on conversions here at GTA.
;)
Now I don't recall if anyone has posted an image of the NP2 Gas Piston along side say the NPXL piston.
Or if exact dimensions/stroke have been posted on the NP2 Gas Piston.
Rod sent me some information in a PM. Maybe We need to shake him down for better info since he has one laying around?
:)
-
I'd like to know if the Benjamin Phoenix NP2 Air Rifle has the same power plant as the other NP2 22 cal.
What PFE are you guys really getting from the NP2 that claim 26 FPE ?
Yes, same power design. The only differences is the scope groove and a slightly different stock. Why the .22 Trail NP2 is $50 more than the .22 Phoenix at most major on-line suppliers is a "dang" good question !
Mostly all manufacturers inflate their lead FPS...probably because they use the lightest lead pellets possible. Is that being deceptive ? Ya, and it would be nice if they listed the pellet that they used to make things easier for us consumers. The .22 NP2 in either version should get between 825 and 850 FPS with the common 14.33 grain pellet with around (give or take) 23 FPE which is a little above average for this type of a rifle and good enough for small game at the right distance.
-
"Now I don't recall if anyone has posted an image of the NP2 Gas Piston along side say the NPXL piston.
Or if exact dimensions/stroke have been posted on the NP2 Gas Piston.
Rod sent me some information in a PM. Maybe We need to shake him down for better info since he has one laying around?"
:)
I'm thinking on giving Paul at N-Forcer another call and ask if I can ship my spare Crosman Gas Piston to him and have him match it for me with one theirs. Before, I do that I want to try and educate myself a bit or maybe learn from someone else's mistake. I want to make sure I ask the right questions and can answer his without wasting to much of his time. One of my first questions I want to try and answer before calling would be, "What would be the best psi to charge it at?".
Oh and Jay I would be thrilled to get 23 fpe with this upgrade. I just want to keep it safe. As a couple of the guys have already posted, the easiest and most practical way to achieve this would be to simply buy another gun of the same model. I have it in my head to bring this gun to where I want it and will try every avenue before going that route.
-
Rod if buying a new one would get you 23FPS is questionable from what guys are posting. In Cabello's video he gets 19. If I knew I could get 21-22 like some guys I would order.
-
Ya Rob, that's one reason I would lean towards a used gun from a trusted seller. Most probably a member of the GTA.
My gun seems to be picking up as it breaks in. After I tuned and installed the new seal and gas piston it was averaging about 715 fps with Premeir Domes. When I chronied it after 1000 shots it had picked up to 725 fps with the same pellets.
Now as I'm approaching 2000 shots, besides the gun settling down, it feels like it shooting harder, but I won't know until I chrony it again.
-
I wasn't in on the initial post on your problem but did you do the JB paste job on your barrel? Did you push a pellet thought the bore to look for tight spots?
-
I did not do the JB Paste Job, but I did push a pellet through. Looking down the barrel, everything looked clean to me. I did run a small bit of cleaning solvent through it a couple of times. I made sure everything was out before shooting the gun
-
I'm going to run another pellet through the barrel again just to double check
-
This is why Im not eager to purchase the one in my local area for $150...
-
This is why Im not eager to purchase the one in my local area for $150...
Buying retail does have the advantage of warranty return
-
This is why Im not eager to purchase the one in my local area for $150...
Buying retail does have the advantage of warranty return
yes, it does. you pay more and also receive a little more too
-
As I have said repeatedly - the NP@ is a whole lot of gun for less then 200$ .
@ 25 yards it shoots clean thru a 1 gallon metal paint can filled with water .
If you want more ; go for a more expensive and/or bigger caliber gun .
Far more killing's been done with a .22 caliber bullet then all the other calibers combined .......
shot placement has been proven time and time again to mean more then caliber size .
The NP2 is one of the most powerful sub $200 .22 pellet guns available ; you want a hunting pellet rifle ?
Then I recommend you shell out $500+
and get the FPE you seek
-
As I have said repeatedly - the NP@ is a whole lot of gun for less then 200$ .
@ 25 yards it shoots clean thru a 1 gallon metal paint can filled with water .
If you want more ; go for a more expensive and/or bigger caliber gun .
Far more killing's been done with a .22 caliber bullet then all the other calibers combined .......
shot placement has been proven time and time again to mean more then caliber size .
The NP2 is one of the most powerful sub $200 .22 pellet guns available ; you want a hunting pellet rifle ?
Then I recommend you shell out $500+
and get the FPE you seek
I remember the time i was still a babe and seeking raw power. ::) but now i know id take accuracy over power any day. Shot placement is key
-
No doubt the NP2 a great gun for the money. I enjoy mine. I also like tinkering with it and posting my results. I have a stronger PCP that is pushing 40 fpe that is a nail driver, but I keep getting drawn back to my NP2. At this time it's my favorite pellet gun.
-
The NP2's are my favorite as well ! I love my 1400's ........but the NP2 is something special