GTA

All Springer/NP/PCP Air Gun Discussion General => PCP/CO2/HPA Air Gun Gates "The Darkside" => Topic started by: shorty on October 29, 2016, 08:50:56 AM

Title: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 29, 2016, 08:50:56 AM
There's been a bunch of us guys regulating the 25 Mrod lately with some unbelievable shot count and power levels never thought to be achieved. The posts to follow our progress is challenging to follow since they are beginning to spread throughout the forum.

It would be great for all of you that have regulated or in the progress of regulating your 25 Mrod to post your strings here in one place so that we can have a historical shot count/fps/fpe post for us guys that have regulated our guns and to help each other improve them even more.
And,
Use this post for guys that are planning on regulating for them to see what they can expect from a 25 cal regulated Mrod.

Just a simple chart of the shot count with fps or fpe or listed out along with reg pressure setting. Starting and end fill pressure. A general listing of the guns mods.

Like this:
Huma (with gauge port) regulator set at 1900/1950psi
Hogged out valve with .196 porting through and through.
Custom hammer spring and poppet spring.
Stock air tube and stock hammer.
Start pressure 3000 end pressure 1900psi for both strings.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Finchlake on October 29, 2016, 03:39:36 PM
I'm looking forward to following this thread. I have 2, .25 Marauders and this is the next Mod I want  to try.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on October 29, 2016, 04:33:20 PM
If I could make a suggestion, including the plenum volume would be a useful piece of information.... It affects the efficiency, and also the remaining reservoir volume.... This allows easier comparisons.... JMO....

One other comment regarding the 40 FPE string above.... The velocity increase at the end of the string is indicative of shooting past the regulator setpoint.... Either the regulator is set higher than you think, or the pressure when you stopped shooting is lower.... The setpoint was reached not later than shot 36.... The proof is in the velocities....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 29, 2016, 04:56:54 PM
Bob,
I noticed the same thing in the 40fpe tune. When I chopped it in excel I caught all the data when converting it from FPS to FPE. I agree to with plenum size. I was just to impatient to take measurements before dropping in the reg. There has been rumor of 22/24CC's with a hogged out valve using this gauge style Huma regulator which puts the high pressure side just at or close to 190cc.


Raw data on 40 FPE tune:
Shot   FPS   FPE
1   719   39.0
2   725   39.6
3   722   39.3
4   718   38.9
5   719   39.0
6   723   39.4
7   720   39.1
8   717   38.8
9   719   39.0
10   724   39.5
11   728   40.0
12   719   39.0
13   725   39.6
14   727   39.9
15   720   39.1
16   726   39.7
17   734   40.6
18   736   40.8
19   718   38.9
20   725   39.6
21   731   40.3
22   724   39.5
23   726   39.7
24   721   39.2
25   719   39.0
26   724   39.5
27   734   40.6
28   733   40.5
29   736   40.8
30   733   40.5
31   733   40.5
32   729   40.1
33   717   38.8
34   734   40.6
35   728   40.0
36   734   40.6
37   740   41.3
38   744   41.7
39   755   43.0
40   765   44.1

I know how you like to look at the knee (and so do I now) so here's the knee in the chart. From the knee, 50 fpe is the max I would want to run with any kind of efficiency and around 44 to 46 fpe would be ideal to get the additional shots off regulation. I was using the 33.95 grain JSB's

As soon as I get some 25.39's I plan on a backyard tune of around 35-38fpe for a minimum of 50 shots on regulation. Just got to get them on order first.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: 3BI5 on October 29, 2016, 05:52:15 PM
Here's some of my late season 2015 setup strings with 25.39gr JSB's.
The gun is .25 synrod with reservoir extension, total air capacity 215cc+73cc or something like that.
Huma reg with hogged out marauder gauge port, hogged out stock valve, total plenum volume about 22-23cc. Transfer port .187. First gen WAR NBH with 10 or 12lbs hammer spring.
Regulator set pressure 2000psi.

1. string is low tune, 819fps/37fpe avg, 3200-1200psi (red string)
2. string is 870fps/43fpe avg, 3200-1620psi
3. string is 895fps/45fpe avg, 3200-1800psi (red string)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on October 29, 2016, 07:42:02 PM
shorty, if the plenum is 25 cc, you won't have 190 cc of reservoir left, because the regulator itself takes up some of the tube volume.... A stock MRod is 215 cc, and the reservoir is 14.5 cc per inch of length, so if the regulator takes up 1" of length, that is another 14.5 cc you have to deduct from the reservoir.... Of course if you remove the gauge block, you gain back that lost volume....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on October 29, 2016, 09:57:52 PM
Bob,

I don't believe that the 215cc in a Gen II includes the gauge block.   There are 15.5" between gauge block and fill assy.  With an ID of 1.050", puts it slightly over the 215cc.  The airtube reservoir portion on Gen II is about 5/8" longer than Gen I.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 29, 2016, 10:31:40 PM
So,
Are we all on the same page of 190cc of volume with the Huma gauge port assembly regulator ? I really enjoy seeing those efficiency numbers hovering around 1.7 with a 25 Mrod at 38/42 fpe .

FuzzyGrub took these measurements on his:
Main Body
L: 3.035"
D: 1.050"

Top/adj
L: 0.625"
D: 0.520"

Bob,
Can you look at he numbers and re-check for me?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on October 30, 2016, 12:00:11 AM
John, you are correct, the Gen 1 reservoir volume is 215 cc from the front of the gauge block to the fill plug.... What I meant was that I don't see how the reservoir could be 190 cc if the plenum is about 25 cc and the gauge block is still in place, because the regulator itself has to displace some of the reservoir volume....

shorty, I assume those are the measurements on the regulator?.... The "main body" volume is 43 cc, and the "top/adj" volume is just over 2 cc.... That will reduce the 215 cc reservoir to just 170 cc unless you are removing the MRod gauge block, which increases the reservoir volume of course.... It is 1.46" long, so that increases the reservoir 21 cc if you remove it (plus any space between it and the valve).... I assume the plenum volume is within the 43 cc main body?....

My question would be.... are you removing the gauge block?.... If so, yes your reservoir is just over 190 cc....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on October 30, 2016, 05:15:02 AM
Yes, the Huma they are using replaces the gauge block:

http://www.huma-air.com/Benjamin-Marauder-pressure-regulator-with-pressure-gauge-connection (http://www.huma-air.com/Benjamin-Marauder-pressure-regulator-with-pressure-gauge-connection)

It has a "donut" on the inside where the gauge screws in, so a liquid measurement for plenum volume would be the best way to measure.  But, here is what I can measure:  Plenum H: 2.475" X ID 0.695 - (Donut (H: 0.530" X D: 0.695") - Donut Hole (H: 0.530" X D: 0.225"))
= 0.7589cu in or 12.44cc + what is in the valve, so it is way undersized to BobR recommendations.

PS: I'll re-measure and re-calculate tonight

See my air res calculations on #36 and #38: http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=115601.20 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=115601.20)

I got 188cc.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 30, 2016, 08:21:29 AM
Goody on the 190cc reservoir.

Now let's see some more 25 cal Regulated Mrod tunes. 3BI5's string looks awesomely long with that reservoir.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on October 30, 2016, 10:11:12 AM
Bob what would be the optimum plenum for a .30 caliber Marauder
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on October 30, 2016, 04:40:18 PM
I like to use 1 cc per FPE if you have an external reservoir (bottle) where the volume is unaffected by the plenum size.... When you are using an internal regulator, inside an existing reservoir tube, going that large will reduce your reservoir volume too much.... You can go down to 1/2 cc per FPE and the only downside is that you have to run about 10% higher setpoint to compensate for the pressure loss during the shot cycle from having a smaller plenum.... If you go smaller than 1/2 cc per FPE, you will either lose power, or efficiency, or both, or you will have to crank the setpoint up so high your shot count will suffer....

There are exceptions to every rule, and the more efficient the setup, the more tolerant it will be of a small plenum volume.... My regulated .30 cal XS60C uses a plenum that is over 100 cc.... and it reaches 100 FPE at 2200 psi setpoint with 14 shots (2 clips) from a 22 CI tank.... If you have any more questions about plenum size, best to start another thread, rather than hijack shorty's.... To answer your question, I would not build a regulated .30 cal MRod using just the stock reservoir, I think you would be disappointed in either the power or shot count....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on October 30, 2016, 04:44:51 PM
Now let's see some more 25 cal Regulated Mrod tunes.

I should have something in about a week.  I decided to put the 25 cal top on my reg'ed 22 first.  The reg was set at 2200 (initial).  This is an Audrius reg with semi-hogged out gauge block.  I need to add some weight to Scott's LW hammer.  Also a zero pre-load double spring.  After that, will put in the Huma and see what that does.   
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on October 30, 2016, 04:49:26 PM
No hijack intended and I have another .25 Marauder to play with Just wondered what the optimum Plenum was
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 30, 2016, 05:14:35 PM
I think all these things are really important to put out there.

I also think a little different than Bob in regards to plenum sizing but, we all tune differently with different results.

For me, when calculating plenum size, I use 2 times the barrel and all the porting volume after the valve as a plenum size. I also calculate the plenum size based on PRESSURIZED volume vs atmospheric pressure volume since the plenum is under pressure.

I do agree that a larger plenum is optimal (for power) but, with the limitations of an in tube regulator dictates along with your efficiency, your shot count.

Now,
For versatility, I have been pondering about a regulator by-pass valve for 60+ fpe for our 25 cal marauder using this Huma regulator. This may also be used in a 30 cal conversion were you can shoot 20 regulated shots at 60 fpe or hit the by-pass valve and blow 80+ fpe for one mag.

I have the idea my head but I am not confident of my skills messing with HPA tubing and hardware. The thought process would be to T-off at the fill into the gauge port assembly with some type of valve in between. Not a bad idea if you can fit it in the stock to hide.



Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: fsa46 on October 31, 2016, 07:23:00 AM
I was hoping this thread would take off. I'll bet I'm not the only one that's disappointed  it hasn't.  :(
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: cclingma on October 31, 2016, 08:27:46 AM
I'm watching closely too.

40 shots at 40fpe.  The 4040 tune.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: mobilemail on October 31, 2016, 08:51:53 AM
I'm watching because I'm not only interested in the 4040, but I'm also thinking what this could do to transform a .22 mrod. 6030 (60 shots @ 30fpe regged)?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: anti-squirrel on October 31, 2016, 10:12:46 AM
I dunno.. I'm learning a lot by doing what I used to do these last 3 years (prior to joining)... reading and thinking.  I still take everything with a bit of a grain of salt- not as a Doubting Thomas but as a guy who doesn't have the money to play at these levels, and has to shoot these tuned guns vicariously :)  Results on the Chronograph always speak loudest, though putting all that power and efficiency into pellets means nothing if accuracy isn't a partner.

Shorty and Bob- thanks- great insight as always. 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on October 31, 2016, 10:21:05 AM
 ;) Frank sometimes threads will go right off the chart others just live forever kind of like a 1/4 mile drag race and others are more like the Paris to Dakar race, there are threads on here that keep getting resurrected because new members will discover them and pose a question that has not addressed but the GTA will always be a wealth of information for any member that wants to learn about all things AG related. Also there are certain aspects of this thread that are always going to be pertinent for any PCP AG that a member plans to mod or tune themselves whether it is a.25 Marauder or a .25 Air Arms S510  .25 that needs to be regulated
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on October 31, 2016, 10:32:42 AM
I'm "working" on mine at the moment. Been waiting to test the tune out but only been raining every day this last 3 weeks. Starting today for the next 10 days looks like we only have 1 chance of rain so hopefully I can get my 40fpe 40 shot tune done  :o
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: WiseGuy on October 31, 2016, 11:01:40 AM
Also interested in the 4040 tune with the regulator.  Question, is there a US supplier of the Huma Regs?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on October 31, 2016, 12:40:20 PM
I'm watching because I'm not only interested in the 4040, but I'm also thinking what this could do to transform a .22 mrod. 6030 (60 shots @ 30fpe regged)?

I'm with you on the 22.  I've reached a 60/29.6/4%, 50/33/4%, 46/34.2/4%, 40/30/2% and a 30/30/1.36% unregulated, but am about to rebuild to go further.  Just trying to keep up but if I can't, a regulator maybe in my future if these experts can show significantly better numbers regulated in this journey.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on October 31, 2016, 01:04:57 PM
Regulators are perfect when you are tuning a PCP for low to medium powered tunes (relative to what the gun is capable of).... not so much for high power tunes.... The reduced pressure makes it difficult to even get to high power, and finding space for a large enough plenum makes the task even harder.... shorty's 40 FPE tune is an interesting one.... It shows graphically what happens when you reduce the hammer strike on a regulated PCP that is set up for more power (ie higher setpoint pressure) than you want/need.... You get two immediate effects.... First, you get great efficiency, because you are using tiny sips of air at a higher pressure than you need to do the job.... Second, below the setpoint, the velocity increases.... If shorty continued shooting until the power dropped back to just under 40 FPE where it started, he might even get 50 shots.... It would be interesting to see how high the velocity went before peaking, the graph shows no sign of turning back down at 40 shots....

There is nothing wrong with tuning a regulated PCP this way, and if you want the flexibility of being able to crank the power up, it's a great way to dial down the power.... For some uses, it would be problematic, such as a sub 20 FPE tune for FT.... If the velocity above the setpoint was just under what was allowed, the gun would be shooting too hot at the end of the string.... That would make the string a maximum of 36 shots.... A better solution in that case would be to reduce the setpoint pressure and hammer strike, to tune to the knee of the curve instead of the downslope, where the tune is now.... Then you could watch the pressure guage and know you weren't over the 20 FPE mark, rather than trusting on counting shots....  If the upturn in velocity at the end of the string is unimportant, however.... it's a great tune, and gives you the ability to dial the power back up if required.... something you couldn't do if you used a lower setpoint pressure....

Bob

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 31, 2016, 04:53:31 PM
I know I said 25 cal marauder but, take a look at this mobilemail.
http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=103892.0 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=103892.0)
Gen2 .22cal
Fill 2250 and end pressure 1250
Huma with gauge port set at 1550
Same mods as my 25 except .168" porting.

42 shots on regulation with just a 2250 fill. I shot a few off regulation. This gun is now tuned for 24/25fpe (14.3 grain) for 93 shots on regulation and an additional 10 to 20 off all under 2% ES from a full 3000 psi fill.

Bob make a solid point about tuning to the knee for the consistent shots off regulation. It's all how you set up the reg set point and hammer spring strength. Running a knee chart tells the tail of where the gun likes to be tuned to get the additional shots off regulation.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 31, 2016, 05:01:54 PM
Almost forgot,
Dairyboy, hurry up. :D. I can't wait to see your numbers.

And

I know there are other guys out there with 25 cal regulated Mrod's. Please post up some numbers and the mods that you have done to get were your at.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on October 31, 2016, 05:18:59 PM
Link to what I have done to my .25:

http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=109935.0 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=109935.0)

Couple strings to share:

40 shots:

(http://i1172.photobucket.com/albums/r563/mkdive/Airguns/Armada%20Huma%20SSG%2019g%20hammer%203200fill%2040%20shot%2043fpe%20%202.07es%2010.15.16_zpst51y6bdo.jpg) (http://s1172.photobucket.com/user/mkdive/media/Airguns/Armada%20Huma%20SSG%2019g%20hammer%203200fill%2040%20shot%2043fpe%20%202.07es%2010.15.16_zpst51y6bdo.jpg.html)

56 shots (falling off reg):

(http://i1172.photobucket.com/albums/r563/mkdive/Airguns/Armada%20Huma%20SSG%2019g%20hammer%203200fill%2056%20shot%2043fpe%20%209.07es%2010.15.16_zpsb43mcje3.jpg) (http://s1172.photobucket.com/user/mkdive/media/Airguns/Armada%20Huma%20SSG%2019g%20hammer%203200fill%2056%20shot%2043fpe%20%209.07es%2010.15.16_zpsb43mcje3.jpg.html)


Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on October 31, 2016, 05:24:26 PM
Almost forgot,
Dairyboy, hurry up. :D. I can't wait to see your numbers.

Lol I had about 30min to work on it today and had horrible consistency and accuracy! Was shooting 860 then some would drop to 800 and some to 780 then back up and every time was 10secs or so between the shots. Have no clue what's causing the problems as the hammer is running super smooth but will hafta tear it down again and figure out what the problem is now.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 31, 2016, 05:39:33 PM
Just thought about it.

Bob's comment about lowering the reg set point. It is valid although, what PB guns did is run a smaller transfer sleeve than I did which reduces the power slightly. It does something else though as well. It moves that magical point of getting shots off regulation at the power level your looking for.

So don't think you have to pull the gun apart and re-adjust the reg set-point to run in YOU'RE sweet spot. This is supper critical because the thought process a while back was to open the porting as much as you can to get power and efficiency at lower pressure when installing a regulator.

In my case with .196" porting, a quick change to .168" porting should mimic PBguns shot string but, not allow me to hit over 50 fpe on regulation. This is something that should not be missed.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on October 31, 2016, 05:49:11 PM
Just thought about it.

Bob's comment about lowering the reg set point. It is valid although, what PB guns did is run a smaller transfer sleeve than I did which reduces the power slightly. It does something else though as well. It moves that magical point of getting shots off regulation at the power level your looking for.

So don't think you have to pull the gun apart and re-adjust the reg set-point to run in YOU'RE sweet spot. This is supper critical because the thought process a while back was to open the porting as much as you can to get power and efficiency at lower pressure when installing a regulator.

In my case with .196" porting, a quick change to .168" porting should mimic PBguns shot string but, not allow me to hit over 50 fpe on regulation. This is something that should not be missed.

I agree with shorty.

Half of me is thinking "if I change the reg setpoint down to 1800psi (130bar)" I could take that 40 shots on regulation and extend it.
The other half of me (which I'm currently siding with) thinks that will change more than just shot count.

I'm not sure I want to loose this tune yet.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on October 31, 2016, 06:31:36 PM
My problem is I've never had the gun unregulated. I have no idea what numbers or strings I can get from it. So I think what I need to do is unregulate it and then tune it from there and find out where I need to do my set point from.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 31, 2016, 06:40:12 PM
Dillion,
I am not sure if you have that SSG in there or not but, try and run a knee curve.

Adjust the SSG or hammer spring to get 30 fpe or so and then turn up the power 1/4-1/2 hammer spring turns to see when it flattens and drops off when on regulation. keep note of where the adjustments so that you can re-adjust to just before the peak of the curve.

This will get you your max FPE with a few shots off regulation.

After all that, you can make a sound decision on where to go. Piece of cake with my spring but maybe a little bit more work with an SSG.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on October 31, 2016, 08:58:34 PM
Hey guys, hope you don't mind me jumping in here and hopefully I'll be able to contribute more soon. I have the newer huma regulator design with the gauge port made into it ordered and on the way, should be here this weekend. I get what the pleume space is and why it's needed, I don't understand how to measure for it and to determine how much you need to achieve the proper power, any help would be appreciated.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Motorhead on October 31, 2016, 09:44:10 PM
Question, is there a US supplier of the Huma Regs?

TRENIER OUTDOORS .....  http://trenieroutdoors.com/gear/huma-airgun-regulators/ (http://trenieroutdoors.com/gear/huma-airgun-regulators/)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 31, 2016, 10:19:35 PM
CJ,
The reg your getting is the same as PBguns and mine. You can't do much to increase the plenum unless you open it up and bore it out. Nothing I wanted to do and wouldn't recommend. Heck, is was 120 bucks. It better have worked.

I have been collecting some data on your comments for power though using this newer style Huma 25 cal with gauge port regulator. Here's a table based on my 25 cal,my spreadsheet, along with some of the data coming out from the rest of the guys in regards to this particular regulator and pressure settings for .187" and .161" porting. These are just my numbers and take as a grain of salt but, they seem pretty close to the max powers at those pressures.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on October 31, 2016, 10:34:53 PM
Makes perfect sense, and 100% inline with theory.... If you plot out those numbers you get straight lines, just as you should.... Maximum FPE should be proportional to pressure, if you have constant port diameter, caliber, and bullet weight.... At 2400 psi you should get 50% more FPE than at 1600 psi....

PS shorty, the 26 FPE at 1600 is incorrect....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 31, 2016, 10:37:31 PM
Almost forgot and it's important.

If you plan on regulating,plan on working the stock valve by opening up the exit port on the valve and match all porting to the barrel or purchase a drop in valve.

I also highly recommend an SSG or short stiff spring. I think these are the key to these numbers.

If those 2 things are not done, you most likely will be disappointed. Check out the stock porting numbers under regulation.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on October 31, 2016, 10:58:31 PM
Thanks Bob. Fat finger all fixed
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on October 31, 2016, 11:48:18 PM
That's pretty interesting how that small of a difference in port size can make that big of a difference. And also no I don't plan on boring it out either. That requires to much detailed work for the tools I have available, also I have not modified anything on my rifle yet, everything is still completely stock other than the SSG built in now, and I did it in a way so that all original components could stay in place without damaging anything, if I ever wanted to strip it back down and put it back to stock it'd be a simple process. What graphing charts do y'all use so I can try and get them too
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on November 01, 2016, 12:32:40 AM
You hear shorty and I using the terms "plateau", "knee" and "downslope", so for those who don't know what we mean, I'll explain.... For a given pressure, as you increase hammer strike (usually preload) you tend to get more velocity.... However, that doesn't keep on forever, eventually no matter how hard you hit the valve you won't get any more power.... If you plot out velocity vs. preload, you get a curve like this....

(http://i378.photobucket.com/albums/oo221/rsterne/QB%20on%20HPA/QB79NinjaDelrin1200_zps999456be.jpg) (http://s378.photobucket.com/user/rsterne/media/QB%20on%20HPA/QB79NinjaDelrin1200_zps999456be.jpg.html)

Note that past about 4 turns of preload the velocity "plateaus", ie it doesn't keep increasing, but the efficiency keeps dropping and the gun becomes an "air-hog".... When the preload is less than at 5 turns, the velocity is decreasing, ie it is on a "downslope", and the less preload the lower the velocity.... Between 4 and 5 turns is what we call the "knee" of the curve.... In that region you are getting nearly all of the velocity possible, but you will notice that the efficiency is still increasing.... It makes sense that is a good place to tune the gun, and it is.... There is another set of characteristics that tie in with this, shown in the graph below.... This doesn't represent any particular PCP, it's "generic", and the FPE/CI numbers I will use below are "invented" to fit the description....

(http://i378.photobucket.com/albums/oo221/rsterne/Important/RegulatedvsHammerStrike_zpsc71d1304.jpg) (http://s378.photobucket.com/user/rsterne/media/Important/RegulatedvsHammerStrike_zpsc71d1304.jpg.html)

The PCP represented is regulated at 1500 psi.... It shows what typically happens to the velocity as the pressure decreases from a full tank (3000 psi) down to, and beyond, the 1500 psi setpoint.... What isn't shown is the shot count.... On the plateau (blue line) you might only be getting 0.8 FPE/CI, and get, let's say 20 shots.... When tuned on the knee (orange line) the efficiency will be much higher, maybe 1.2 FPE/CI, plus you can shoot a bit below the setpoint, so you might get 32-36 shots.... If you tune on the downslope (the grey line), your efficiency might be 1.6 FPE/CI, and you might get 50 shots above 1500 psi (at much lower FPE), but then the velocity will start increasing, just as if the gun wasn't regulated (because it isn't any more).... Think of it as an unregulated PCP tuned for 1200 psi, but where the top part of the curve is constant velocity (because of the constant pressure delivered by the regulator)....

I hope this helps you understand the terminology, and also what happens when you tune for different parts of the envelope.... I hope shorty didn't mind the diversion, just trying to help....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 01, 2016, 05:22:29 PM
Don't mind one bit Bob. I kind of thought at first you were looking for reg sizing to calculate efficiency because it's pretty un heard of for 1.7+ efficiency on a 25 PCP. :D

Anyway,
Not sure if we are gonna get anymore regulated 25 cal marauder shot tunes or not but, I want to lay this out there if this or any other posts of regulating your 25 cal Mrod has you on the fence.

Cost:
My gun was was 399 with the gander mountain sale a couple months ago.The reg cost 120. I did the work myself and yes I do have a lathe. BUT, from what we have learned, I think this might work too.
Gen 2 marauder or Armada, 5 dollar drill bit at .161"/.165" (to drill out the exit port and barrel - or aftermarket valve 100/150 bucks), a matching transfer port sleeve, a short stiff spring or SSG (homemade or bought 70 bucks or so) and the Huma reg for 120.

For a 4040 tune (I really like that term) a reg set point between 1900/2100 psi.

1 or 2 hrs of work depending on if you make the stuff yourself or purchase all drop in parts.

Not sure what a tuner such as Motorhead would charge (and this should be discussed only between you and him or who-ever) but, from this and a few other posts, it seems like you should expect nothing less than a 4040 tune from one of the pros when getting your 25 cal Mrod regulated.

I gotta tell you though,
There's nothing like a 4040 tune or a 24/50 tune using this 25 Mrod. I truly hated filling after every 16 to 28 shots to keep it under 4% ES. Too me, this is how a PCP should respond. It was worth the 120 bucks to get 50%+ more shots with a low ES. Let's face it, 35 FPE to 50 FPE is a great power level for the available pellet weights in 25 cal.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 01, 2016, 05:30:01 PM
I'll be sure to let you know how mine turns out once the reg makes it in and I have some time to work it over, hopefully this weekend maybe.
Also I want to point out I got my Huma reg from the Netherlands and it only cost me $109 shipped, not much of a difference, but might be cheaper or more depending on where you have it shipped to.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 01, 2016, 05:47:16 PM
Sounds good. Can't wait to hear.

Hey Dairyboy,
Did you get it squared away yet? :D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 01, 2016, 07:20:08 PM
Lol getting there should have the hammer situation figured out tonight and hopefully run a string tomorrow. Dang responsibilities keep getting in the way of my toys :P
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 03, 2016, 04:30:19 PM
Okay guys, maybe you can clarify this for me. With the newer huma reg that has the gauge block built in there doesn't seem to be much wiggle room for pleume, without drilling it out and modifying it anyway, and I don't plan on it. But with this design is the gauge assembly itself enough to hold the regulator where it needs to be or will I need to plan on pinning it?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on November 03, 2016, 05:08:19 PM
Okay guys, maybe you can clarify this for me. With the newer huma reg that has the gauge block built in there doesn't seem to be much wiggle room for pleume, without drilling it out and modifying it anyway, and I don't plan on it. But with this design is the gauge assembly itself enough to hold the regulator where it needs to be or will I need to plan on pinning it?

If you are meaning that you will use the other style huma, to get a larger plenum, that seals against the gauge block, you do not need to pin it.  The gauge block is butted up against the valve.  With that style, you will want to hog out the gauge block or buy one like Tim Hill's. 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 03, 2016, 05:34:53 PM
No, I bought the newer one. I should remove the original gauge block completely and this reg has the gauge port made in.

(http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f326/CJ_Leisenring/Mobile%20Uploads/20161103_153159_zpsrwgqkwic.png) (http://s50.photobucket.com/user/CJ_Leisenring/media/Mobile%20Uploads/20161103_153159_zpsrwgqkwic.png.html)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on November 03, 2016, 06:15:21 PM
No, I bought the newer one. I should remove the original gauge block completely and this reg has the gauge port made in.

(http://i50.photobucket.com/albums/f326/CJ_Leisenring/Mobile%20Uploads/20161103_153159_zpsrwgqkwic.png) (http://s50.photobucket.com/user/CJ_Leisenring/media/Mobile%20Uploads/20161103_153159_zpsrwgqkwic.png.html)

That just butts up against the valve.  No pins needed.   
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 03, 2016, 06:37:58 PM
Awesome, thanks, I didn't know if there was any gap anywhere
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 04, 2016, 02:25:13 PM
Yo Dillion,
Where's that 25 cal regulated shot string. Just busting chops!!!!! ;)

I have been waiting for it so that I can post this pic. For holloween we went to the agriculture center cause they had something going on there and this old school carrige was there.
All I could think about was you. Do you run Moooo cows or meat cows?  ;D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on November 04, 2016, 02:58:42 PM
So we have some excellent examples using an aftermarket performance valve, and a heavily modified oem using a lathe.  So, I'm working on the DIY version.  ie valve mods that can be done by most DIYers with a drill press.  So I modified my stock valve today.  See changes below:

Mrod 25 cal Valve
Part                  Original   Modified   % Increase
Inlet Diameter   0.2500   0.2813   
Inlet Area   0.0491   0.0621   26.5625
         
Valve Body Diameter   0.4219   0.5000   
Valve Body Area           0.1398   0.1963   40.4664
         
Stem Diameter           0.1250   0.1250   
Stem Area                   0.0123   0.0123   0.0000
         
Pocket Diameter           0.2000   0.2250   
Pocket Area           0.0314   0.0398   
Pocket Area - Stem   0.0191   0.0275   43.5897
         
Exhaust Diameter   0.1400   0.1650   
Exhaust Area           0.0154   0.0214   38.9031
         
TP Diameter           0.1400   0.1600   
TP Area                   0.0154   0.0201   30.6122
         
Barrel Port Diameter   0.1400   0.1600   
Barrel Port Area           0.0154   0.0201   30.6122



Now, I consider the pocket, exhaust, TP, and barrel port the key flow mods.  The rest just add some slight plenum increase.         

Of note: Normally, I'd go with more inlet cap mod and a light conical spring, with a LW hammer.  I only have the oem hammer for now, so will wait on the spring associated mods.

I have to finish the DIY SGG and re-assemble, but should have results sometime this weekend.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 04, 2016, 06:17:12 PM
Yo Dillion,
Where's that 25 cal regulated shot string. Just busting chops!!!!! ;)

I have been waiting for it so that I can post this pic. For holloween we went to the agriculture center cause they had something going on there and this old school carrige was there.
All I could think about was you. Do you run Moooo cows or meat cows?  ;D

Lol should be ready for testing tomorrow during my lunch break! Been working last 12 days straight and won't get a day off until next Sunday. Normally do all my tuning on Sundays which are my normal day offs but since I haven't had one been tough finding time for any of it.

That is a really cool Dairy cart there. I guess we would raise what you call moo cows.  ;D

(https://s21.postimg.org/5vg1vryer/IMG_20161104_140739261_HDR.jpg) (https://postimg.org/image/5vg1vryer/)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 06, 2016, 10:55:34 AM
So today I finally decided to pull the whole gun apart and figure out why I can't figure it out. So this regulator is the first kind without a pressure gauge. I have a hogged out one I will be installing. Also the regulator was set at 2400psi...way too high for what I wanted. So now backed it down to 1900ish goin back together and hopefully will work this time
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on November 06, 2016, 01:23:30 PM
My first string showed that I was at the power I want (865fps) but not the shot count.  Only got about 16 shots before going off reg.   Reg is set at 2.2Kpsi.   Turned out I was way up on the plateu, some adjustment and shortening the 3" spring by 1/4" got me closer to the knee, at 850fps.   I'm at 26 shots before going off reg, then it is a steady decline. 

Shot   FPS   3.2K Fill   25.4g Kings
1   852      
2   853      
3   855      
4   857      
5   854      
6   853      
7   855      
8   857      
9   855      
10   853      
11   851      
12   853      
13   854      
14   854      
15   855      
16   852      
17   850      
18   852      
19   850      
20   850      
21   849      
22   849      
23   851      
24   853      
25   853      
26   850      
27   847      
28   846      
29   843      
30   838      
31   836      
32   835      


Still a far cry from PBguns results.  I need to go to a lighter hammer, and will open exhaust and TP some more to 0.170". 

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 06, 2016, 01:54:28 PM
Finally got the gun back together and only had time for a few shots. Gauge is showing 1950~ psi and with a Hill valve and a light valve spring and a hill gauge port .162 TP, .187 barrel port and 22" TJs with Rocker1 LW hammer (28grams) on a WAR SSG with not much spring tension I'm getting 875fps avg that was only about 8 shots for what I had time to test and couldn't run full string. The shot cycle is super short and snappy I'm very happy with it
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on November 06, 2016, 03:40:32 PM
My first string showed that I was at the power I want (865fps) but not the shot count.  Only got about 16 shots before going off reg.   Reg is set at 2.2Kpsi.   Turned out I was way up on the plateu, some adjustment and shortening the 3" spring by 1/4" got me closer to the knee, at 850fps.   I'm at 26 shots before going off reg, then it is a steady decline. 

Shot   FPS   3.2K Fill   25.4g Kings
1   852      
2   853      
3   855      
4   857      
5   854      
6   853      
7   855      
8   857      
9   855      
10   853      
11   851      
12   853      
13   854      
14   854      
15   855      
16   852      
17   850      
18   852      
19   850      
20   850      
21   849      
22   849      
23   851      
24   853      
25   853      
26   850      
27   847      
28   846      
29   843      
30   838      
31   836      
32   835      


Still a far cry from PBguns results.  I need to go to a lighter hammer, and will open exhaust and TP some more to 0.170". 



I think you'r headed straight towards the tune your after! Nice to see it come together.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 08, 2016, 02:37:59 PM
48 shots from 865-830 fps. 40 shots on regulation around 853fps avg with 25.39 JSB kings. I'm done tuning!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on November 08, 2016, 02:40:14 PM
Nicely done  8)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on November 08, 2016, 04:13:01 PM
48 shots from 865-830 fps. 40 shots on regulation around 853fps avg with 25.39 JSB kings. I'm done tuning!

Welcome to the club! Good work! So how many in the 40/40 (no res) club now is it 3?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on November 08, 2016, 04:15:30 PM
48 shots from 865-830 fps. 40 shots on regulation around 853fps avg with 25.39 JSB kings. I'm done tuning!

I went through a "few" tins of JSBs tuning mine.
Heck when your shooting 56 shot strings......pellets get used up quick!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 08, 2016, 04:45:48 PM
Lol I got very lucky when I tore everything apart and I put it together and that's how my tune turned out with no further adjustments. But that was just this time I burned through alot figuring out what the heck was wrong with it at first.

But yes finally I joined the group. I believe there is 3 you, shorty and now me and were waiting on John/fuzzygrub and Ozarkairgunner.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 08, 2016, 05:02:23 PM
Way to go Dairyboy..... :D Awesome work.

You sure do go through a lot of pellets. I have been using the 33.95's and still waiting for the 25.4's.

5 mags at this power and ES on our stock tube is just a pleasure to shoot now.

We have taken a 215cc SSG/SSS equipped 24/28 shot at 40 fpe and just under 4%ES 25 Mrod to a 40fpe SSG/SSS regulated 25Mrod with 40 "or more" shots under 3% ES on a 190cc tank.

That's around a 45% increase in shot count all under 3% ES. That's amazing...... I still can't get over it.

So Dairyboy,
What did you end up with for reg settings, TP, springs ect. ?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 08, 2016, 05:13:25 PM
I'm still waiting the arrival of my reg with hopeful  ambitions to join y'all on this 40/40 thing.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on November 08, 2016, 05:16:09 PM
No, I'm not there yet  :'(    I think I could get it slightly better as is, but the main gains will be LW hammer/light poppet spring.

Since we are comparing to prior work/tunes, it would seem we need to keep it to 3K fills.  Right now, some of the numbers posted here are exaggerated based on over-filling.   
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 08, 2016, 05:29:30 PM
Fuzzygrub is right.

PBguns is at 3200psi fill and I am at 36/37 shots at 3000 psi fill. Iam not sure what Dairyboy is at for a starting fill.

But,
As soon as those darn 25.4's come in, I hope all changes occur for me. It should and it should be real positive.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 08, 2016, 05:41:22 PM
Right now my reg is set at ~1950 psi or so. Normal Huma reg (without built in gauge port) and a hill gauge port. Hill .25 valve with light poppet spring. 28gram LW hammer from Rocker1 on a WAR SSG with heavy spring. .162 TP with .187 barrel port. Very little preload on the SSG spring and small gap. Mine was on a 3200/3150 fill so yeah was over filled. But don't think it came off the reg until 43 shots. So should be close to 40 for 40 on a 3000 fill but I'm not sure
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 16, 2016, 09:49:27 PM
Okay guys I know this kinda died off, but my Huma regulator just made it  in recently and I'm hoping to get the results y'all have gotten, may start to install by this weekend. I'm going to start with my set point at 141bar and work from there.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 17, 2016, 05:15:58 PM
Good luck to you!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 17, 2016, 05:23:41 PM
Can't wait to hear about it CJ.

I am starting to think nobody really cares about a 40/40 tune "or more" with their 25 cal marauder or if we are pulling their legs on it since it sounds so impossible.

Your gonna love it if it works out for you. If you need anything to get there, I would be more than happy to help.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 17, 2016, 06:00:47 PM
I was even skeptical about it while running it over the chrony and it just kept going and going and going  ;D it's a fun gun now and as soon as I get a new scope for it will sight in to Polymags and have shots for all day 8)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 17, 2016, 06:29:38 PM
Dillion,
I know what you mean. Everyone knows me here as the "bad" guy or "troll" or "rude way"  or just some dumb kid. Man, I have absolutely no reason to lie and I will explain and tell you exactly how I did it. That's what GTA is for........

Not only that, help you as a friend and not business person to make a buck to the best of my ability.

I do understand that there are vendors and pro's that are here to help with the people that can not do the mechanical work. For me, it's more about the DIY'er like us that can do the impossible.

It's just hard to prove it sometimes and get the idea past with a nice political speaking voice ( I have a hard time with that ).
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on November 18, 2016, 04:25:58 AM
I was even skeptical about it while running it over the chrony and it just kept going and going and going  ;D it's a fun gun now and as soon as I get a new scope for it will sight in to Polymags and have shots for all day 8)

When I started getting my first strings....that's exactly what I thought (I was in disbelief as the pellets kept going, and going, and going).
Then my concern turned to how repeatable of a tune is it?  I have broke the rifle down twice (experimenting a little more), & every time going back to the tune is easy.  I agree It made the .25 really fun!
The consistency still brings a big smile.

I think there will be 2-3 new members to the 40/40 club any day.
I read on another forum  a .25/ssg/reg build, and how the probe was turned down a little to improve flow.
I still have a OEM bolt/probe, guessing that's a project for one of these nights. Can't imagine that having any negative impact on my stings....only positive.  :D
I'm so deep in this tuning rabbit hole I can't see light anymore.  ;)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 18, 2016, 02:17:28 PM
Mike,
As you know I am really interested in who does this 40/40 tune. Who are these 2 or 3 guys that are getting close and what forum.I can't find them.

The bolt probe mod is one thing I do. Although, I just don't reduce the diameter of the probe but pull back the shoulder (Pakprotector-thanks) for .18" barrel porting. For me and one other it created a 50 fps increase and the other a lower pressure tune at a higher FPE.

http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=112722.msg1079967#msg1079967 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=112722.msg1079967#msg1079967)
http://airgunguild.com/pcp-c02-and-helium-powered-airguns/gen-2-25-modded-mrod-modded-bolt/ (http://airgunguild.com/pcp-c02-and-helium-powered-airguns/gen-2-25-modded-mrod-modded-bolt/)

Motorhead "Scott's" bolt mod did not appear to utilize this on his bolt shaping build and under performed for a low pressure tune.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 18, 2016, 02:24:21 PM
I really have to say this:

Bob,
If it wasn't for you getting out the SSG in Jan 2016, no one would have seen these numbers. Awesome work. You are a stand up guy for sharing this.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Motorhead on November 18, 2016, 02:30:58 PM
Motorhead "Scott's" bolt mod did not appear to utilize this on his bolt shaping build and under performed for a low pressure tune.

What is it with you Shorty ???
If you can't say something constructive turning near every post into some sort of P i s s i n g contest that your tuning efforts trump others work, don't say a dang thing !
The probe work you speak of was not required because we hit the target power & count customer wanted.
Those who seek MAX power and MAX shot count has no bearing on others work who were not after such results.

Enough already !!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 18, 2016, 02:34:02 PM
Here's my number:
386-503-6137

Call it.

I am off from work today. I ain't that what your painting a picture of me.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 18, 2016, 02:36:48 PM
Shorty- my name is Tim. I really hate shorty. It's my cat's name. funny how that it is.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on November 18, 2016, 02:57:45 PM
Mike,
As you know I am really interested in who does this 40/40 tune. Who are these 2 or 3 guys that are getting close and what forum.I can't find them.

The bolt probe mod is one thing I do. Although, I just don't reduce the diameter of the probe but pull back the shoulder (Pakprotector-thanks) for .18" barrel porting. For me and one other it created a 50 fps increase and the other a lower pressure tune at a higher FPE.

http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=112722.msg1079967#msg1079967 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=112722.msg1079967#msg1079967)
http://airgunguild.com/pcp-c02-and-helium-powered-airguns/gen-2-25-modded-mrod-modded-bolt/ (http://airgunguild.com/pcp-c02-and-helium-powered-airguns/gen-2-25-modded-mrod-modded-bolt/)

Motorhead "Scott's" bolt mod did not appear to utilize this on his bolt shaping build and under performed for a low pressure tune.

I'm sure when they get their tunes to where they want....they will share their findings. IMO its not my business to post their work (kind of rude, and stealing their thunder).
They will share when they feel they got to their tune (or need a little assistance).
I respect and value what Scott says and shares, there are less than 3-4 members on GTA that I really listen up and pay attention whenever they post.....Scott is top of that list.


Saying that I think modding the probe area on my bolt can give me a little extra on my tune.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on November 18, 2016, 07:55:53 PM
My gun has a leak and reg is creeping but here's my last string.  I took a couple shots to bring the regulated air down to normal pressures before starting string so no idea what starting pressure is.

01)  849.9                21)  837.4
02)  847.9                22)  849.6
03)  838.6                23)  847.6
04)  836.1                24)  848.9
05)  838.0                25)  837.0
06)  841.0                26)  842.8
07)  833.5                27)  845.3
08)  839.9                28)  832.7
09)  829.6                29)  832.6
10)  843.9                30)  853.4
11)  840.2                31)  843.2
12)  844.2                32)  841.2
13)  844.6                33)  844.3
14)  842.7                34)  846.2
15)  838.2                35)  841.5
16)  841.5                36)  844.8
17)  845.9                37)  838.9
18)  853.7                38)  838.1
19)  834.2                39)  831.6
20)  837.2                40)  828.3
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 18, 2016, 08:50:29 PM
My gun has a leak and reg is creeping but here's my last string.  I took a couple shots to bring the regulated air down to normal pressures before starting string so no idea what starting pressure is.

01)  849.9                21)  837.4
02)  847.9                22)  849.6
03)  838.6                23)  847.6
04)  836.1                24)  848.9
05)  838.0                25)  837.0
06)  841.0                26)  842.8
07)  833.5                27)  845.3
08)  839.9                28)  832.7
09)  829.6                29)  832.6
10)  843.9                30)  853.4
11)  840.2                31)  843.2
12)  844.2                32)  841.2
13)  844.6                33)  844.3
14)  842.7                34)  846.2
15)  838.2                35)  841.5
16)  841.5                36)  844.8
17)  845.9                37)  838.9
18)  853.7                38)  838.1
19)  834.2                39)  831.6
20)  837.2                40)  828.3

That's looking great!!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 18, 2016, 10:07:29 PM
My gun has a leak and reg is creeping but here's my last string.  I took a couple shots to bring the regulated air down to normal pressures before starting string so no idea what starting pressure is.

01)  849.9                21)  837.4
02)  847.9                22)  849.6
03)  838.6                23)  847.6
04)  836.1                24)  848.9
05)  838.0                25)  837.0
06)  841.0                26)  842.8
07)  833.5                27)  845.3
08)  839.9                28)  832.7
09)  829.6                29)  832.6
10)  843.9                30)  853.4
11)  840.2                31)  843.2
12)  844.2                32)  841.2
13)  844.6                33)  844.3
14)  842.7                34)  846.2
15)  838.2                35)  841.5
16)  841.5                36)  844.8
17)  845.9                37)  838.9
18)  853.7                38)  838.1
19)  834.2                39)  831.6
20)  837.2                40)  828.3

That's a great string, mind if I ask what pellet you were using
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on November 18, 2016, 10:32:00 PM
Sorry forgot to include some info.

JSB Kings 25.39
WAR Valve
WAR SSG with different spring for easy cocking
Huma reg without gauge port set to about 124 bar
Stock gauge block and hammer

Fill was less than 3k not sure since i had a leak and i had to take a couple shots to bring regulated pressure back down to normal.
String stopped at about 1700 psi.

Barrel drilled out to 0.1875 to match valve and transfer port.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on November 18, 2016, 11:59:09 PM
Dang that's with a stock gauge block & hammer!?!?!

Nice job David!!!!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 07:43:33 AM
Great work David!!!!

 Welcome to the club.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 08:45:35 AM
Mike,
I do believe doing some work on the bolt will make it better. The important thing to remember that it only really helps if the barrel port is .17" or greater.

Here's how I did mine:
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 08:47:30 AM
Here's a few more things I did.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 08:49:21 AM
and this. Flush hammer throw and SSS.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 09:02:50 AM
I also did one other thing. Not sure if it helps with the "refilling" of the plenum but, I removed the tie off screw on the regulator.  You know, that screw that you would connect a piece of wire to so that you can pull the reg out.

I found a little trick when regging the 22 (no screw there either). To get the reg out with out pulling the valve out, all you have to do is put the degass tool in to open the valve and with your bolt closed, add shop air to muzzle of the barrel while holding your finger over the gauge port hole in the pressure tube. Popped right out for me.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Motorhead on November 19, 2016, 12:13:14 PM
I also did one other thing. Not sure if it helps with the "refilling" of the plenum but, I removed the tie off screw on the regulator.  You know, that screw that you would connect a piece of wire to so that you can pull the reg out.

I found a little trick when regging the 22 (no screw there either). To get the reg out with out pulling the valve out, all you have to do is put the degass tool in to open the valve and with your bolt closed, add shop air to muzzle of the barrel while holding your finger over the gauge port hole in the pressure tube. Popped right out for me.

That screw has a reason for being there ... FLOW DAMPER
Removing it speeds up the refill process while also INCREASING the seat impact speed.
You WILL GET far shorter life out of the seal disk and regulator that will suffer set-point creep a lot sooner than if screw was kept in place.

FYI ...
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on November 19, 2016, 12:14:57 PM
According to huma that screw is there to slow the flow of air into the plenum making the regulator more consistent.   There's a small groove underneath the label where i tied some fishing line to pull it out.

I think the stock gauge block is limiting my max fps to about 880 fps.  Increasing spring tensions won't raise velocity after that point.  So using an 8lb hammer spring is perfect for me right now at least until i figure out a way to open up the gauge block without a lathe or mill.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 19, 2016, 12:32:19 PM
According to huma that screw is there to slow the flow of air into the plenum making the regulator more consistent.   There's a small groove underneath the label where i tied some fishing line to pull it out.

I think the stock gauge block is limiting my max fps to about 880 fps.  Increasing spring tensions won't raise velocity after that point.  So using an 8lb hammer spring is perfect for me right now at least until i figure out a way to open up the gauge block without a lathe or mill.

Actually I believe your reg set point is what's causing you to max out there crank it up higher and should get more fps
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 01:01:00 PM
Scott and David,
Thanks, for the heads up on that screw. I kind of thought it was "extra" parts and for the easy of pulling it out. Maybe that's one of the reasons for my gun having a little higher ES than others.

I am not sure about the gauge block needing to be hogged out either unless you think it's due to plenum size. Increasing that reg setting from 1800 psi to 1950/2000 psi sure should do the trick. I am not sure if you seen the pictures of the newly drilled barrel port with the shoulder pulled back vs stock. Big difference there.

I have a half-azzed  half hogged out gauge block from my .22 if you want to try it out. It ain't pretty man, and may need some TLC but should give you a little more plenum. Your more than welcome to have it.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on November 19, 2016, 01:56:05 PM
I've tried the regulator set at 124, 131, 137, and 144 bar.  The difference between 124 and 144 bar was about 10 fps.  When the reg creep hit about 2400 psi, the gun shot 920 fps for 2 shots then dropped back down to 880 fps.  Figure the extra plenum volume cant hurt maybe get an extra shot or 2.  I saw a couple threads showing the newer huma reg with gauge port hitting 50 fpe at about 145 bar so i'm guessing there's more volume with that setup than the older style reg with stock gauge block and that's making a difference.  Either that or a heavier slower pellet is staying in the barrel longer making more muzzle energy.

Not sure about the barrel port picture got a link?

Thanks for the offer but i'm in no hurry to degas air tube again.

BTW hand pump tuning is a pain  :(
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Motorhead on November 19, 2016, 02:02:22 PM
I have a half-azzed  half hogged out gauge block from my .22 if you want to try it out. It ain't pretty man, and may need some TLC but should give you a little more plenum. Your more than welcome to have it.

Done on BOTH ENDS  ;) .... followed up with plunging a 1/2" end mill "OFF CENTER" to remove web material across from gauge mount area buys a lot more internal plenum space  ;)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 02:08:30 PM
Acflier posted some of the pictures of the stock bolt vs modified bolt showing the difference.

http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=112722.msg1079967#msg1079967 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=112722.msg1079967#msg1079967)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 19, 2016, 02:17:59 PM
Boring out that gauge block was the first time using a boring bar on the lathe (first time grinding a boring bit too). Didn't have a mill to finish it. I actually tried to off center the gauge block in the jaw to see if I can pull the webbing out with the boring bit but it looked and felt a little dangerous so I stopped and just bagged up the part.



Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on November 19, 2016, 03:33:01 PM
Some good posting and data today. Nice work guys!!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on November 19, 2016, 06:39:49 PM
If you want to see a really hogged out MRod gauge port.... look at Reply #42 in this thread.... http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=109718.40 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=109718.40)

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 20, 2016, 01:33:13 PM
With you guys that have done this 40/40 tune, some or most of you have mentioned that the gun has become a little more quite.

I have made absolutely no changes to the stock shroud and baffles and wanted to see if there is any correlation between doing the 40/40 mod vs straight up no reg.

I didn't do a sound comparison but, I just did a sound comparison between the 22 regulated (25fpe) vs the 25 cal 43 fpe. I used my computer using 8.1 windows and the free app for db numbers 3 to 4 ft away from the computer outside.

A hand clap at 3 ft away was 88 to 90 db for reference since I know this computer and app is bologna.

The 22 at 3ft away was 83db and the 25 at 3 ft away at 43 fpe was 86db.

Between the 2, the 22 won hands down but that 25 at almost twice the power was pretty neat to see the numbers and not bother the neighbors.

Pretty cool :D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on November 26, 2016, 11:21:57 AM
Help the new guys (like me) out.  I have a 25 Caliber Marauder shipping to me.  I have ordered the Huma 25 caliber regulator with integral gauge port, as well as the SSG full hammer kit.  Those resources are fairly easy to find.  A 3/16 drill is fairly easy to source for increasing the transfer port internal diameters.  However, could you post a web link for the Hill valve, and the lighter (28 gram?) hammer?  It wouldn't hurt for someone to list any other goodies (with links), which may make it easier to get to the beloved 40 shots at 40 FPE club?  I would prefer to only have the Marauder apart the minimum number of times, as (for right now) I only have a hand pump. 
I will start the ball rolling:
Huma Regulator:
http://trenieroutdoors.com/gear/huma-airgun-regulators/benjamin-marauder-25-huma-regulator-with-gauge/ (http://trenieroutdoors.com/gear/huma-airgun-regulators/benjamin-marauder-25-huma-regulator-with-gauge/)
Gen II SSG W/ Hammer:
http://wickedairrifles.com/store.html (http://wickedairrifles.com/store.html)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 26, 2016, 11:46:10 AM
Valve spring

https://hillairgun.com/products/lightest-rated-valve-spring-i-offer-for-benjamin-crosman-pcps/

Valve

https://hillairgun.com/products/25-and-22-cal-valve-assembly-for-your-marauder-rifle/

Hammer

https://hillairgun.com/products/hill-hammer/
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on November 26, 2016, 11:52:38 AM
Thank You for posting this DairyBoy.  Just a quick question; does the Hill hammer have to be drilled to work with the WAR SSG? What poundage hammer spring do you recommend for use with the three products you listed?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 26, 2016, 12:40:18 PM
Yes it does need to be drilled out but easy to do so i have a spare drilled out if you want it. I'm using the spring that comes with the WAR SSG
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on November 26, 2016, 02:01:08 PM
DairyBoy, thank you for the kind offer.  I was just concerned about disturbing the anodized coating for the hammer on a sliding surface.  The anodized finish is a hardness of about Rockwell 57 on the C scale, which gives it both corrosion and wear resistance.  It would be nice if he had an SSG compatible version with the 0.25 inch hole, instead of a thread; this way the sliding surface would keep the nice anodized finish.  I suspect a drilled hole would be slightly cheaper to make, than a drilled and tapped hole. 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 26, 2016, 05:30:44 PM
Good luck Todd.

Looks like you have everything lined up perfectly to pull it off.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on November 26, 2016, 07:13:38 PM
Well I thought I'd let you all know why it's taking so long to get the results from my install. While I was working on the valve and boring out the transfer port I knocked my trigger assembly down and accidentally stepped on it breaking my sear. First thing Monday morning I'll be calling crosman to get it on the way.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on November 26, 2016, 07:30:35 PM
OUCH, sorry to hear that OzarkGunner.  When it broke, did you feel a searing pain?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on November 26, 2016, 08:31:29 PM
Thanks again DairyBoy. 
I ordered the parts from Hill.  He even agreed to put the 6 pound spring in my valve for the same price (instead of the stock spring which normally comes with the valve); that saved a few bucks and the fuss of installing it upon arrival.
I got the Valve with 6# spring, the Hammer, Silicon lube and a couple of the 0.187 transfer ports.  Now I just have to wait for all the toys to come in to start the build.
Before I start, a baseline will be done with the Marauder, this will confirm basic function before any changes.  It will also allow a direct comparison with the final results.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 26, 2016, 09:06:00 PM
That's great! Have fun with it and I'm glad I could help! And I've dealt with Mr. Hill on multiple occasions and have built 3 different guns with his parts very nice guy to deal with and he does know his Mrods
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: JTB530 on November 28, 2016, 08:08:10 AM
Is there better efficiency with a hill, war, or cothran valve over the stock one with the reg/ssg. 40/40 sounds amazing to me over the stock rifle which I was already happy with. I would like to set up a rifle for close to 50fpe with the jsb kings. Besides the rifle itself and the regulator (huub or altaros) what else do I need to buy and what is the best shot count I could hope for at that fpe?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on November 28, 2016, 09:37:23 AM
JTB530,  I am not a pro at this, but I can say the following.  Each valve has a certain sweet spot (actually a bell curve) where it produces the best efficiency.  That curve also includes a range of calibers it works best with (larger calibers requiring a greater volume of pressurized air).  This is also affected (tuned) by the poppet valve spring in the valves.  The Hill valve, with a lighter poppet spring, with a lightweight hammer works well at 40 FPE.  The Cothran and WAR valves are better optimized for higher volume builds (higher volumes required for larger calibers and velocities).  Be aware that some of those listed are way overkill for getting 50 FPE.  All good efficiency builds are all about reducing wasted air, and optimizing flow.  This frequently means drilling out the transfer port on the barrel to a larger size, and may mean reducing the Bolt probe diameter at the transfer port.  For most people, using an SSG (or equivalent hammer de-bounce mod), to reduce or eliminate multiple strikes of the hammer on the valve is critical.  Reducing the mass of the hammer *can* also help with bounce issues.  As FPE goes up, generally more hammer spring and mass are required.  You can compensate (to some degree) by reducing the poundage of the spring behind the valve poppet.  The single most important thing to remember is: "changing just one thing in a balanced system, changes everything".  Before embarking upon this course, I looked to see what other people were doing to achieve it.  I am sure there are several posts on how other people achieved 50fpe with the 25 caliber Marauder.  Give my friend mr. Google a shot.  Search for " Marauder 50 FPE", and see how others have found success.  Find the example which has the longest shot group with the smallest variation.  You probably can't go wrong with emulating success.  Keep in mind each rifle is slightly different; what worked well for one is not guarantied to work perfectly for all.  Minor burrs, and corners (along the air path) which are not lightly radiused may cause measurable variations.  I have ported and polished a few motorcycle and car heads in my time; it is frequently the small nuances which make a lot of difference.  Best of luck with your goals; they are very achievable.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 28, 2016, 10:11:14 AM
I can easily hit 50fpe out of my gun with the Hill valve and light poppet spring. You just have to bump up the reg pressure slightly right now mine is at 1900~ easily can hit 45fpe
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: JTB530 on November 28, 2016, 11:13:23 AM
Dillon what kind of shot count do you get at that power level?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 28, 2016, 12:58:36 PM
JTB350  not quite sure as my target was the 40fpe for 40 shots. I'm actually planning on detuning it to 35fpe and giving it to my dad as a Christmas gift so if I have time I'll test it at 50fpe
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on November 28, 2016, 03:22:03 PM
DairyBoy,  are you thinking he is going to need the regulator set to about 2100 pounds to reach his 50 FPE goal?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 28, 2016, 04:39:12 PM
Yes I would believe so that's where shorty had (has?) his setup for his 50fpe at 24 shots.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 28, 2016, 05:24:57 PM
I am just under the 2000psi mark. Somewhere around 1900/1950.

Yes you can always up the pressure to get the 50fpe but that bolt is what is really hampering the low pressure higher fpe. This one mod that I do is the only difference between all of us right now. IMO. Just remember it is all about balance. By increasing the reg pressure you will loose available air to produce higher shot counts.

Think of it this way, If you open up the barrel port to .187" to fully maximize the valve exit port and transfer port (all .187"), you now have a bolt "shoulder" blocking the newly .187" barrel port (gen 2 with bolt probe). You mine as well just be running a .16"/.17" exit port on the valve and barrel port. IMO. Which works well (actually really good) for the 40/40 tune like PBguns and Dairyboys.

Mine,
Can peak at 55 fpe but I have only run a 40/43fpe tune and a 50fpe tune so far.

It is also my opinion, that the stock hammer can be used with an SSG or SSS along with the stock poppet spring. I am running a stock hammer with a SSS and a poppet spring very similar in strength "if not a little more" than a stock one.

I guess it really doesn't matter how you get there. Just share what you have done and if you need help, we are there.



Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 28, 2016, 06:06:32 PM
I have a Gen1 bolt in mine no blocking air for mine :) but yes I'm sure stock hammer and valve spring would work just fine this is just how my gun came with all those aftermarket parts already just had to tune really was all.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on November 28, 2016, 06:22:14 PM
Hey Dillon,
This might be a stupid question but, is the Gen 1 bolt and Gen 2 interchangeable between the 2 platforms without modification ? Or, is your gun a Gen 1 ?

I have only owned Gen 2's.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on November 29, 2016, 02:05:57 AM
I wasn't sure myself but they are interchangeable Tim.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: fishcowboy on December 09, 2016, 12:06:49 PM
What the *(&^ happened? I just woke up realizing that I have 17 airguns. Two years ago I had 1 "760"!
My G2 Srod got 14 shots out of the box-not good enuf.  After much research (thankyou), I went to work on the gun.
10# spring, 6" air tube ext., white o-rings, curved trigger,  de-pinger, Huma reg @ 2200.  No milling or drilling (I am a machinst).  Fill 3100, 25g kings, annnd this gives me 32 shots (920-880) at 75yds with 1-1/2" group.
My Son has a Ruger 10/22 & I out shoot him with the Mrod (especially when he can't find any bullets for sale!). The Predator & Benjamins shoot fine, but only out to 50yds.  ;)  Rich B.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 12, 2016, 01:16:22 PM
Hey guys, starting to wonder what I'm doing wrong here, after getting my new sear in and fixing the trigger issue I'm back up and running, had a few problems trying to get my popet to seat in the valve, but after putting a small oring around the valve stem that problem was fixed, but I'm only getting about 19 good shots before I fall off the reg and they're all in the 740fps range, a little slower than what I wanted. Reg is set at almost 2000psi. What am I doing wrong?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on December 12, 2016, 01:22:33 PM
What's all done to your gun?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 12, 2016, 01:24:30 PM
Mostly still as close to stock as possible I did bore out the transfer port slightly to the 3/16" and closed my gap, don't know the exact length, and slightly increased my preload.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 12, 2016, 02:02:10 PM
CJ,
If you only bored out the transfer port sleeve, your gonna need some more work.

You will need a WAR valve, Hill valve, or port your exiting valve to have a minimum of .17" exit port.
Then the transfer port sleeve (which it sounds like you have that covered ).
and lastly
Drill the barrel port to match TP and exit of valve.

Power should be there then and if you don't get the shot count, go for the SSG or SSS for the hammer spring.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 12, 2016, 02:07:01 PM
I did bore out the sleeve and the stock valve, as well as an additional little bit of work on the valve to allow for just a tad more flume, I didn't drill the barrel, and I have an SSG installed already. But shouldn't I still be getting more shots, even if they are low velocity? Also I've been debating on buying another valve, I just don't have to funds right now, but even with another valve, would I still need to enlarge the port on the barrel?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on December 12, 2016, 02:16:04 PM
Yes enlarge the barrel port is a must. If you screwed your gap in that's an issue thats what helps with the efficiency. Wait light bulb you might have reached your power potential with the reg setting without opening the barrel port. First things drill that out to match. Second you might have too much hammer spring at this point and just wasting air. Decrease the gap slightly to where it's just 15fps below your max fps right now and then see what that does
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 12, 2016, 02:20:11 PM
Okay, after I get off this evening I'll drill out the barrel port and debur, and reset my SSG settings and see how things are and try to let you know by tomorrow.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: fishcowboy on December 12, 2016, 02:27:41 PM
I am "guessing" the o-ring is restricting the amount of air.  Try adjusting the HS & HT.   Also the SSG might be limiting the air.   RB
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 13, 2016, 11:36:35 PM
Okay, update....well I'm getting over 40 shots now off the reg but seem to be maxing out at 36fpe, close but no cigar, I'm going to try increasing the reg up just a bit and see if that gets me there. I thought I had it set closer to 2000, but I'm actually down closer to 1800.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 13, 2016, 11:52:50 PM
Can't wait to join you to the club. Yup, bump that reg to 2000psi and I think your there.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on December 13, 2016, 11:57:34 PM
Can't wait to join you to the club. Yup, bump that reg to 2000psi and I think your there.

+1  ;D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on December 14, 2016, 05:37:32 AM
Can't wait to join you to the club. Yup, bump that reg to 2000psi and I think your there.
+2 (any updates)??
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: J M on December 14, 2016, 08:56:09 AM
Okay fellas I am going to try to join your 40/40 club. I have basically zero experience with PCP mods so going strictly from what I have read here.
I am pretty much ready to order reg.  and associated parts to start the journey!
To date the only mods I have made are WAR SSG and of course clean up debur and polish internals.

A few last decision need to be made before I start ?

I am looking at both Huma and also been studying Robert lane regulators. I am currently leaning towards Lane for the simple reason he also has a reg. made for  the marauder to accommodate the gauge but mostly he has pretty clear dimensioned instructions regarding porting and where and how much to drill and or modify internals which are helpful, I assume they would also apply to Huma but?

Do I also need aftermarket valve, springs and hammer to achieve this tune or can stock parts be used?

Any last words of wisdom before I order would be appreciated?

 :o

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 14, 2016, 02:36:52 PM
J M, I have done mine as close to stock as possible and it's been a headache, and if done over I'd probably ordered the hill valve and transfer sleeve, but to answer your question, yes it can be done with the stock valve, springs, and hammer. I should also note that I did put a light coat of moly on my hammer to help it hit a bit harder. You will need to modify the valve and barrel by drilling out to 3/16 on the transfer. I'll also be going by the hardware store to see if I can't find something to drop in for a new sleeve that I can use without the orings and get more air moving thru, I'll let y'all know how it goes.

Guys it'll be tomorrow before I have a chance to turn the reg up and let you know how it goes.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on December 14, 2016, 10:48:53 PM
Can't wait to hear about it CJ.

I am starting to think nobody really cares about a 40/40 tune "or more" with their 25 cal marauder or if we are pulling their legs on it since it sounds so impossible.

Your gonna love it if it works out for you. If you need anything to get there, I would be more than happy to help.

I can tell you that I've been following, and I care. I remember RayK saying how nice it was to take only his rifle and 5 mags and go hunting, and I thought, that's what I want.

I picked up a Huma reg a couple of weeks ago at a deal I couldn't pass up, or I probably wouldn't have it now. I also have a Hill lightweight hammer and am studying you guys' experience to decide where to go from here.

Also, to those of you already in the club, how about a quick recap of what you did and then maybe post some groups?

Thanks to all for sharing your hard work and success.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on December 15, 2016, 10:24:17 AM
No groups past 25yds but here's what mine is doing with a stock barrel. Top groups is 5 shots with polymags, bottom right is 5 with JSB kings bottom left is 5 with AA 25.4 gr. Was shooting minute of sparrow at 75yds the other day. 5 shots and 4 hits only because the miss hit a branch right in front of the bird.

(https://s6.postimg.org/nziu0zqy9/IMG_20161204_091856679.jpg) (https://postimage.org)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on December 15, 2016, 10:52:44 AM
No groups past 25yds but here's what mine is doing with a stock barrel. Top groups is 5 shots with polymags, bottom right is 5 with JSB kings bottom left is 5 with AA 25.4 gr. Was shooting minute of sparrow at 75yds the other day. 5 shots and 4 hits only because the miss hit a branch right in front of the bird.

(https://s6.postimg.org/nziu0zqy9/IMG_20161204_091856679.jpg) (https://postimage.org)
No surprise there the stock .25 Marauder is excellent and accurate out past 50 yards if the shooter does their part and regulated just makes accurate shooting that much easier with the shot to shot consistency. That's why I hand load all my rifle ammo
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: J M on December 17, 2016, 11:08:19 PM
Parts are ordered, fro the 40/40 mods. I went ahead and went with Huma Reg, and  hill valve, I think I'll play around with turning down my existing hammer, maybe drill some hole thru the flanges to cut the weight.

Anyone know exactly what material ( spec) is best to build a newer lightweight hammer out of, Aluminum? I remember reading about someone using nylon or derilin? 
 

 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on December 18, 2016, 10:12:32 AM
GoneShootN,
My build (which is essentially a Dairyboy clone) is here:
http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=118687.0 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=118687.0)
I have been tuning through a chrony, so I rapidly look up after each shot to read the chrony (which disturbs aim follow through).  This means I don't have any pictures of accurate shot groups.
Since that build (a couple weeks ago), I ordered a new Hill 25 gram hammer (the first one was drilled through to support the WAR SSG) and Hill's 261/262 short stiff spring. The new parts are not yet installed.

     The current extreme spread (ES) in velocity is around 1.89 percent over 40 shots with JSB Exact King 25.39 grain pellets.  With the 16 FPS variation, this makes for a 1 inch vertical Point of Impact (POI) difference at 100 yards (according to Hawke Chair Gun software).  At 25 yards, the ES seems to make no measurable difference in the vertical point of impact. I got in a new scope and mount yesterday, so my focus has been playing with moving scopes around on my air rifles and re-zeroing them; further modification of the Marauder this weekend is unlikely. 

     For those who are pondering regulator choices, my only experience is with the Huma.  Any new regulator will typically need to be used for a couple hundred shots before it truly settles in. Mine experienced creep (pressure over the set regulated amount for the first shot) when new, which has since settled down.   Some things noted about the one I got (huma regulator for 25 cal with integral gauge block).  The plenum size is more than adequate for efficient shooting.  When I first slapped all the parts together, but had not tuned, it was hitting with 48 FPE force with 25.39 grain pellets.  With a little tuning, it would have easily hit 50+ FPE.  This was with a regulated pressure of 2000 PSI.  As a 50+ FPE gun was not my goal, the regulator was reduced to 1900 PSI in order to encourage more efficiency at 40 FPE.  Ultimately, it may get moved further down to 1800 PSI.  The numbers on the "adjustment knob" on the Huma regulator are a "serving suggestion"; which is to say, they are not dead on.  The Huma I have produces more pressure than indicated on the knob.  I would recommend running a small steel wire to the regulator screw on the end of the knob, for the purpose of supporting easy yanking and removing the regulator.  I failed to do this.  I ended up fabricating a coat-hanger with a hook at the end for grabbing the screw and pulling the regulator out.  Do not forget to put a silicon oil lubricated thumb over the gauge hole in the air tube when pulling the regulator.  This will reduce the chance of cutting one of the O-Rings when pulling and inserting the regulator.  In spite of all the things said above, I like the Huma regulator, it has worked well for me (once broken in). 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on December 18, 2016, 10:50:12 AM
GoneShootN,
My build (which is essentially a Dairyboy clone) is here:
http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=118687.0 (http://www.gatewaytoairguns.org/GTA/index.php?topic=118687.0)
I have been tuning through a chrony, so I rapidly look up after each shot to read the chrony (which disturbs aim follow through).  This means I don't have any pictures of accurate shot groups.
Since that build (a couple weeks ago), I ordered a new Hill 25 gram hammer (the first one was drilled through to support the WAR SSG) and Hill's 261/262 short stiff spring. The new parts are not yet installed.

     The current extreme spread (ES) in velocity is around 1.89 percent over 40 shots with JSB Exact King 25.39 grain pellets.  With the 16 FPS variation, this makes for a 1 inch vertical Point of Impact (POI) difference at 100 yards (according to Hawke Chair Gun software).  At 25 yards, the ES seems to make no measurable difference in the vertical point of impact. I got in a new scope and mount yesterday, so my focus has been playing with moving scopes around on my air rifles and re-zeroing them; further modification of the Marauder this weekend is unlikely. 

     For those who are pondering regulator choices, my only experience is with the Huma.  Any new regulator will typically need to be used for a couple hundred shots before it truly settles in. Mine experienced creep (pressure over the set regulated amount for the first shot) when new, which has since settled down.   Some things noted about the one I got (huma regulator for 25 cal with integral gauge block).  The plenum size is more than adequate for efficient shooting.  When I first slapped all the parts together, but had not tuned, it was hitting with 48 FPE force with 25.39 grain pellets.  With a little tuning, it would have easily hit 50+ FPE.  This was with a regulated pressure of 2000 PSI. As a 50+ FPE gun was not my goal, the regulator was reduced to 1900 PSI in order to encourage more efficiency at 40 FPE.  Ultimately, it may get moved further down to 1800 PSI.

As close to 40/40 as I can get is my goal, as well. I requested the reg set to 150 bar, so it may have to be adjusted down, too. I will be watching your experience, as you are ahead of me.

Quote
  The numbers on the "adjustment knob" on the Huma regulator are a "serving suggestion"; which is to say, they are not dead on.  The Huma I have produces more pressure than indicated on the knob.  I would recommend running a small steel wire to the regulator screw on the end of the knob, for the purpose of supporting easy yanking and removing the regulator.  I failed to do this.  I ended up fabricating a coat-hanger with a hook at the end for grabbing the screw and pulling the regulator out.

I will do that.

I have the same regulator as you. I'm guessing that your gauge now shows the regulated pressure? So you can use that as you adjust the reg pressure?

Quote
Do not forget to put a silicon oil lubricated thumb over the gauge hole in the air tube when pulling the regulator.  This will reduce the chance of cutting one of the O-Rings when pulling and inserting the regulator.  In spite of all the things said above, I like the Huma regulator, it has worked well for me (once broken in).

I've read to do the thumb thing. I'm wondering, though, since gauge block/regulator o-rings do the sealing, if it might be a good idea to relieve those sharp edges with a Dremel tool?

I still have to either work on the valve or purchase one and decide what to do about the hammer. Will be watching OldPro's progress on the dual-spring mod, too. In any event, I will probably wait until hunting season is over to begin re-tuning. Thanks for the info. Please keep us posted as you make progress.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 18, 2016, 11:15:04 AM
Hey Todd,
I had to look up spring 261. Let us know how it works out. Sounds real similar to what I am running. I am just curious about the spring rate on it compared to mine.

You should get some real good numbers running that spring and lightweight hammer combination.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 18, 2016, 11:25:21 AM
If we can get somebody to build this auxiliary plenum chamber that replaces the pressure gauge we should see efficiency numbers even higher along with higher max FPE.

Simple thing that replaces the pressure gauge. Pull out the pressure gauge and replace with this canister. Instant 10cc to 15cc to the plenum with out stripping the whole gun down and modifying everything.

The plenum is the only thing holding us back from a 2.0 or more efficiency right now and an fpe at or over 60 fpe. I can already do just over 55 fpe regulated at the 1900psi but before the regulator I could hit nearly 70fpe at 1900psi.





Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on December 18, 2016, 12:31:49 PM
IMHO: Having this chamber protrude below the stock where many people hold their hand (its the balance point on the Mrod) will be more detrimental than not having as high of efficiency.  Also, without a gauge to monitor, figuring out the reg set-point is harder. 

I think that this chamber is a stop gap approach, which requires a custom part that needs to be made only if you bought that type of huma reg.  If that was the goal from the start (higher eff/power/etc), pick a reg that you have more control over the plenum size, then if need be, for shot count, add a res ext.   

An alternative, if you started with this style reg, you can add back the gauge block (hogged out one) or one from Tim Hill.   It will require you to drill a hole in the airtube for venting, though.  Many people don't like doing that, but if you decide to go back to the stock gun, parts from crosman are readily available, and would probably cost less than the custom chamber.  I did the drill vent on my fist reg, and it is very doubtful that it will ever go back.   I thought I'd post this idea which most can do over the custom part add on chamber. 


Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on December 18, 2016, 12:39:54 PM
Tim, how is that machined?.... Obviously you can't hollow out the chamber through that tiny hole, so curious how you made the rest of it, what the wall thickness is, how the other end is secured, etc.etc....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 18, 2016, 02:20:40 PM
John,
Nothing would be sticking out of the gun. Actually, you wouldn't even know it was there unless you turned the gun over to see what the pressure was. Instead of seeing the gauge, you would just see a flat piece of metal.

Here's what it would like like on the gun.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on December 18, 2016, 02:31:13 PM
John,
Nothing would be sticking out of the gun. Actually, you wouldn't even know it was there unless you turned the gun over to see what the pressure was. Instead of seeing the gauge, you would just see a flat piece of metal.

Here's what it would like like on the gun.

Yep, forgot about the gauge ext. ;)   So, it comes down to a cost/convenience decision. 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 18, 2016, 03:09:10 PM
Bob,
I really wish I could tell you that I used some kind of exotic machining tool to make it and the wall thickness is this and that.

But,

It's only a mock up of what it could look like. The canister in the pic is not functionable. I am by far from being able to design and machine a part like this. I just figure if I continue mentioning how cool this would be, someone might make one. :D. I would buy it tomorrow unless I figure out how to do it with HPA couplings and caps first.

I'll tell you though,
There is plenty of room from the pressure tube to the flush part of the stock. It's slightly over the 1" diameter all the way from the flush part of the stock to the pressure tube.

Can you predict what the efficiency at the same power level would (or % of increase) be and or predict what that max fpe (or % of increase in fpe) would be with the additional 10/15cc's?

So no one wastes their time on something that may not even work.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on December 18, 2016, 03:21:42 PM
I would assume the OD is 1" (the same as the guage, as it has to fit through the stock).... and I appears to be about the same length (for the body).... If we assume a 1/8" wall thickness (I did not do the math for the stress on the flat end), that makes the inside volume about 5.4 cc.... That is assuming you can figure out how to make it that large.... The only easy way I can see to make one is to use a male to male 1/8" NPT pipe nipple (assuming the threads in the MRod gauge block are that), and make the body in a separate piece, boring the inside through the hole that will be threaded (very tricky).... You will need at least 3/16" of thread depth, so that makes the end wall thicker, so now you are down to about 5 cc.... The pipe nipple you use will have to be rated for the pressure, which means the through hole will not be larger than about 3/16".... That makes it smaller than the valve inlet passages, so it might not quite be 100% effective as plenum volume.... If you want to do the math on how the increased plenum volume might help, you can use the method I did in Lloyd's "Friendly .30 cal MRod" thread that is currently running....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 18, 2016, 03:43:21 PM
I know it sounds "kind of" impossible to do but, ideas never stop there.

Another thought was to use a "T" instead of the pressure gauge to gauge block connection and go towards the muzzle end in the stock with just HPA fittings and tubes already made.

This way the pressure gauge can still be used and all is hidden in the stock. Sounds like alot easier that way and get even more plenum.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on December 18, 2016, 04:35:24 PM
You could always make something like this "T" adapter.... It uses a 16 gr. CO2 cartridge, the one I had was listed as 500 bar (7250 psi) to burst.... which means a MSWP of just under 2100 psi.... It has 3/8"-24 NF threads on the neck.... Internal volume is 20 cc, but you can only drill the neck out large enough to feed the plenum, it would not be a 100% part of it, in terms of preventing pressure drop....

(http://i378.photobucket.com/albums/oo221/rsterne/Millenium%20Pumper/IMG_2725.jpg) (http://s378.photobucket.com/user/rsterne/media/Millenium%20Pumper/IMG_2725.jpg.html)

It fits inside a recess in the stock, like this.... This was my Disco Pumper Carbine, but you get the idea.... In this case, it was only used as additional volume to give an extra shot or two without repumping.... The shot volume (plenum) was inside the main tube and valve (about 20 cc)....

(http://i378.photobucket.com/albums/oo221/rsterne/Millenium%20Pumper/IMG_2753.jpg) (http://s378.photobucket.com/user/rsterne/media/Millenium%20Pumper/IMG_2753.jpg.html)

You could also make a tublular steel reservoir with threaded end plugs.... one of which had a male nipple to attach to the gauge port, and a female thread for the gauge.... Then you could make it any size you wanted (limited only by what would fit inside the stock).... If you increased the pipe nipple threads in the gauge block to 1/4" NPT, you could make larger passages.... Sounds like you are running up against the problems of trying to fit a regulator inside an existing reservoir and then trying to get too much FPE for the plenum volume.... Lloyd is running into the same problem in his .30 cal at 80 FPE at 2200 psi.... just not enough room inside the MRod tube for a big enough plenum and still have a large enough HPA reservoir for many shots....

Credit for using a 16 gr. CO2 as an auxiliary HPA reservoir goes to Steve in NC on the Yellow Forum....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 18, 2016, 04:39:13 PM
Yup, that looks great but like I said, I fear messing with the HPA. I am just not ready for that yet.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on December 18, 2016, 04:44:08 PM
Just because your reservoir is small, doesn't mean you don't have to engineer it correctly.... I don't have the math skills to tell you how thick a flat end on a cylinder needs to be for a given diameter and pressure.... all I know is that it is weaker than a tube.... The bottom inside corners of your reservoir will be under the greatest stress, I think....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on December 19, 2016, 10:37:39 AM
Generally,

On the 25 Caliber Huma regulator, they partially hogged out the plenum where the gauge sits.  It has more volume than the stock gauge block.  For those who want a larger plenum there appears to be more material which could be safely removed. 

GoneShootN,

Yes, the gauged version of the Huma was ordered specifically so I could see what my regulated pressure is.  I had already validated the accuracy of the gauge which was in the stock (they are notoriously inaccurate) so a correction could be applied to the displayed value.  In the link I provided you, putting a radius on all sharp edges (to include the gauge hole) was suggested.  However, it is always a good idea to take steps to protect the gasket even with a smoothed edge.  The gasket tries to bulge outward from the gauge hole when it is moving past, so some gentle pressure is good insurance. 

Shorty,

Tim Hill sent me a spreadsheet showing his values he got with the 261 spring and 25 Gram hammer.  Shot count and velocities were similar to the results I got, with slightly less Extreme Spread (ES).  Trying the spring is more about reducing ES slightly, than getting a higher shot count.  Keep in mind his lower ES may have been an indicator his tube or hammer was better lubed or polished.  The higher ES I have may also be an artifact of the variations from the hammer sliding on the shaft of the SSG.  Hard to say without testing.  The 261 spring is definitely shorter and stiffer than the stock spring.  Quite possibly, I may be fussing over nothing.  Some people would be quite happy with a 1.89 ES over 40 shots, but I can't help but feel it could be even better.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on December 19, 2016, 11:12:31 AM
Any opinions on which is better, the HUMA or Audrius regulators? I am wanting to give this a try and see Tim Hill sells a kit with the Audrius reg, but it seems most are using a HUMA.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 19, 2016, 06:07:11 PM
Don't know about the Audruis but the HUMA with gauge port vents through the gauge port hole in the pressure tube. That's one of the I got that one too.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on December 19, 2016, 06:27:44 PM
I've heard the audrius are great! ezman I believe has used them and loves them. I wouldn't hesitate to order that kit if I were you.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on December 19, 2016, 08:21:01 PM
Thanks for the info. One other question, what is the best way to debur the barrel port after drilling?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: oldpro on December 20, 2016, 02:24:57 AM
 With these https://www.amazon.com/12pc-Sphere-Diamond-Grinding-Dremel/dp/B003UOE1ZI (https://www.amazon.com/12pc-Sphere-Diamond-Grinding-Dremel/dp/B003UOE1ZI)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on December 20, 2016, 11:00:23 AM
Thanks Travis.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on December 25, 2016, 04:25:55 PM
Got the Hill regulator kit installed and first string seems pretty good.
JSB 25.39 Running Hill valve,gauge block, hammer and spring,stock striker, Hill hi-flow TP and Audrius reg
1.  832  3000
2.  842
3.  843
4.  842
5.  843  2800
6.  840
7.  846
8.  840
9.  847
10.847  2650
11.843
12.843
13.845
14.844
15.847  2500
16.841
17.844
18.842
19.842
20.840  2350
21.846
22.843
23.852
24.848
25.842  2200
26.850
27.851
28.843
29.848
30.848  2000
31.848
32.856
33.846
34.843
35.844  1900
36.844
37.847
38.847
39.847
40.843  1750
41.844
42.841
43.836
44.839
45.831  1600
46.830
47.825
Any thoughts or suggestions are appreciated.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 25, 2016, 04:36:59 PM
Congratulations!!!! :D

Welcome to the 40/40 tune on your first try. String looks great to me. Looks like the first 40 shots from 3000psi to 1750psi is running around a 1.62 efficiency. Well done.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on December 25, 2016, 04:41:09 PM
Thank You Sir, I thought it looked pretty good, but I wanted to hear opinions of the resident experts.
Mr.Hill deserves most of the credit for putting all the parts together, all I did was install them without cutting the o rings, then turn a few screws.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on December 25, 2016, 05:10:43 PM
That's great!! Might need another .25 Mrod to have 2 regulated .25s  ::)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on December 25, 2016, 05:53:25 PM
That's great!! Might need another .25 Mrod to have 2 regulated .25s  ::)
Oh believe me, I would have had another one when the $399 deals were going on but none of them will ship to this stupid state I live in! >:( One for high power, one for lower power and whisper quiet. ;)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on December 25, 2016, 06:19:50 PM
Lol I'm thinking about it as well a 60 fpe and a 40fpe mrod
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on December 26, 2016, 12:02:28 AM
Nice another 40/40 member! Well done!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 26, 2016, 12:13:51 AM
Hey guys, sorry I haven't posted in a while been really busy with work. Still haven't been able to get my 40/40 to quite work out for me. Currently bumped my reg up just a bit and sitting just slightly under the 2k set. I have drilled out my valve and barrel transfer port to the 3/16" and using some refrigerator tubing as a transfer sleeve that has the same 3/16" opening, I turned my bolt probe back a bit to allow the air to travel a bit easier, been working with the SSG set but seem to keep getting stuck with the same results. I'm currently getting getting 34 shots before falling off the reg and have a good looking string averaging 741fps with the JSB heavies which gives my just barely 41fpe. Don't know what else to do??? Any ideas?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: PBguns on December 26, 2016, 12:17:45 AM
My first (and for the most part my current) 40/40 tune is using a modified WAR SSG.....I haven't been on the forums much in the last month or so. Just a quick "check in" every now and again.
Back when I started on my regulated build more than a few told me "a 40/40 type tune just wouldn't work well when it came to a regulated .25 mrod" (now look what we have accomplished)!
I noticed Travis has the TSS now...I need to read his thread in depth when I get a chance, hopefully in the next day or two.
Thinking I might buy one of those....and see what I can do with one of those w/ my tune.



Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 09:21:29 AM
CJ,
Your real close and seem to have just about everything to do the job. I can only think of couple things that may be preventing the 40/40 tune.

Leaky transfer port sleeve, incorrect SSG adjustment, barrel port alignment to transfer port.

To see if you have a leaky transfer port sleeve:
Load a pellet in, remove the magazine, place (lay or drape) 1 sheet of TP (toilet paper) over the receiver. Fire. If the TP fly's off, you need to work on the transfer port sleeve or your barrel Oring is blown out or damaged.
If this is the problem, just buy one from canniborrowsomeammo or hill for a couple bucks.

SSG adjustment:
Have really no idea since I do not use them. All I can say is make sure there is a gap between the hammer face and valve stem.

Barrel port alignment to transfer port sleeve:
Remove the upper receiver from the HPA tube, place the transfer port sleeve in the upper receiver and using the back of a .187" drill bit, push the back of the drill bit though the transfer port sleeve into the barrel port. The back of the bit should be able to go right into the barrel.
If there is an alignment problem, Loosen the barrel by the 2 set screws, place the transfer port sleeve in along with the back of the drill bit and into the port of the barrel (your using the back of the bit as an alignment tool). Tighten down the barrel and all should be aligned.

I really can't see any other reason why your not hitting the 40/40 tune. It would be terrible (funny) if it's just a messed up chrony ;D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Boomer! on December 26, 2016, 09:38:12 AM
I don't want to hyjack this thread, but it seems a good starting point. I have a brand new MRod .25. I'm waiting on the air supply. I've read lots about tuning and getting a 40/40 would be ideal. I have enough tinkering skills to make new kitchen cabinets, pull & install toilets & hot water tanks, spackle walls, tie flies, etc. However, I do better from good instruction, like on YouTube.

I was reading about de-pingers, SSGs, FAME, Huma & Robert Lane moderators, trigger spring adjustments, etc. What couple of videos have you seen that are really clear for a NOOB who wants to tinker? What are the 3 things I should do (other than purchasing a chrono)? polish everything down, SSG, Regulator? I read that I can adjust down the loudness/report by re-porting something to a larger diameter. Is this possibly with woodworking tools, or is it going to require purchasing some milling tools?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 26, 2016, 10:18:18 AM
Hey Boomer,  well as you can tell I'm still a novice myself but there are more than a few videos and threads out there to help a newbie with the Mrod, congrats on getting one by the way. You'll probably get many different answers from many different people for the same thing. One thing you may want to keep in mind is that not everything is a concrete way to do this or that, what works well for some might not work at all for others and it will take a little trial and error for you to find what works best for you. Another note to add is that I wouldn't change a thing until you have a crony so you know what your starting point is and when you do start to disassemble take careful note of where everything was set.
As far as the noise goes, I did bore out the gas exhaust holes at the end of the barrel, inside the shroud, and kicked them back, I laid the drill back at an angle and they're more oval shaped now. This did make it quieter without affecting accuracy. Not a great deal, but definitely noticeable. I wish you the best of luck on your endeavors and look forward to hearing about it.

This video helped me a lot with my first breakdown https://youtu.be/kCqPYmHG048

Shorty,
Thanks you for your ideas and I out of the thing youv3 listed there is only one that I haven't checked so far and that's the transfer sleeve in the breech. I'll be sure to try that when I get home tonight with a little tissue paper and keep my fingers crossed that that's it. I wish it was just a crony thing lol, that'd make things so much easier, but I doubt my luck is that good. I'm worried it might actually just be that I'm still using a stock valve and valve spring, other than the Huma, everything is still original or modified stock form. I'll probably end up dealing with this as it is for a bit and when funds free up order a Hill valve with the 6lb spring, high flow transfer sleeve,  and possibly the light weight hammer.
I'll admit that it's been a little trying up to this point and I'm a little nervous about taking it back apart and losing what I have, although I probably will trying to work on the 40/40. But for some reason my rifle seems a bit more accurate than before I don't know if it's because of the tune or because I but a thin oring on the shroud inside the barrel band causing it to no longer be "floating"
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 10:32:17 AM
CJ,
I am using a stock valve too. There is nothing wrong with using the stock valve ported out. Heck, before the reg, I was hitting a 1 shot 90fpe with 43.2 eujins. Since Dairy boy mentioned using 2 guns (one for low power 40fpe and one for high power 60fpe) I am gonna try a 60 fpe string today from my regged 25 cal using those eujins.

That Bob Sterne with Steve from SC additional plenum idea won't get out of my head along with Bob's regulated disco build. That extra plenum makes such a huge difference. I just have to figure out how to get everything tucked away into the stock nicely.

I am also pretty sure Hill valve's are "stock" modified. The only 2 valves I know that are completely custom and made from scratch is the WAR valve and Cothran valve.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on December 26, 2016, 10:44:23 AM
CJ,
I am using a stock valve too. There is nothing wrong with using the stock valve ported out. Heck, before the reg, I was hitting a 1 shot 90fpe with 43.2 eujins. Since Dairy boy mentioned using 2 guns (one for low power 40fpe and one for high power 60fpe) I am gonna try a 60 fpe string today from my regged 25 cal using those eujins.

That Bob Sterne with Steve from SC additional plenum idea won't get out of my head along with Bob's regulated disco build. That extra plenum makes such a huge difference. I just have to figure out how to get everything tucked away into the stock nicely.

I am also pretty sure Hill valve's are "stock" modified. The only 2 valves I know that are completely custom and made from scratch is the WAR valve and Cothran valve.
What you guys have accomplished is great stuff I just bought a bunch of parts and when I realised that I didn't have the machine shop tools ( metal lathe and Milling machine ) I just shrugged and shipped everything to someone with a better skill set and the right tools to do it right. So now I will end up with a .30 Marauder Gen II with 80 to 100 FPE and ~14 shots on regulator. I like tour Idea better less expensive and a consistent 40 FPE 40 shot rifle. Keep up the good work
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on December 26, 2016, 10:53:15 AM
Shorty,
Okay, well I'll keep my fingers crossed and hope that maybe is something simple that I just haven't gotten tweaked properly yet and keep working at it, yeah the added flume would be nice, but I don't see that being something that I'll do unless someone develops a cheap drop in the industry just have to hide in the stock. I'm really really trying hard to keep from spending any more money on the Mrod right now, I've got 2 other builds I'd really like to get done first as well as getting a big bore for next year's deer hunting. I'm planning on converting two 2400kt's to HPA. One will be for the wife as a light weight .25 repeater that she can use for some medium game hunting, and the other I'll use the 14.6" lw barrel on in .22 for a fun plinking and squirrel gun.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 11:58:12 AM
Look at that. Seems like max power with 43.2 Eujins is at the top of the knee. Who would of thought, a 60 FPE (Ok 59.4fpe) regulated 25Mrod with all stock MODIFIED parts except for the hammer spring and huma reg.

Now I am real curious to know how many shots at a kitty kat hair away from 60 fpe.

HS   FPS   FPE
0   659   42
1   738   52
2   778   58
3   785   59

Man,
If we,me or someone can get that extra plenum thing going, I can see our platforms hitting 70+fpe on regulation for a clip or 2 and be able to make one adjustment (without taking the gun apart) using the HS adjuster to bring the power down to 35fpe/40fpe for a great shot count string.

I always said I wanted 1 gun that can run the full power gama with just a 1 screw adjustment and not have to take that gun apart to make that change.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on December 26, 2016, 12:26:20 PM
Look at that. Seems like max power with 43.2 Eujins is at the top of the knee. Who would of thought, a 60 FPE (Ok 59.4fpe) regulated 25Mrod with all stock MODIFIED parts except for the hammer spring and huma reg.

Now I am real curious to know how many shots at a kitty kat hair away from 60 fpe.

HS   FPS   FPE
0   659   42
1   738   52
2   778   58
3   785   59

Man,
If we,me or someone can get that extra plenum thing going, I can see our platforms hitting 70+fpe on regulation for a clip or 2 and be able to make one adjustment (without taking the gun apart) using the HS adjuster to bring the power down to 35fpe/40fpe for a great shot count string.

I always said I wanted 1 gun that can run the full power gama with just a 1 screw adjustment and not have to take that gun apart to make that change.
Shorty if you have an M-rod Huma Regulator the reg for the Hatsan has the same size air tube but a larger plenum chamber so if you order just the plenum and hog out the Gauge port you should be all good.  ;) your welcome You will loose a little HPA capacity but it will give you added regulated volume . I can't remember which vendor Might be AG exporters that will sell just the plenum
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 12:37:20 PM
Thanks Don. You gotta know me by now though. I hate fishing where everyone else fishes.

I think if I work hard enough, I can figure out how to add this extra plenum without losing the HPA side and make it a complete drop in part. This one part would be the golden asset for regulating your 25.

If I am thinking right, all you would need is the "extra plenum" , the Huma with gauge port, and an SSG or the new TSS. No need for new valves,porting, or anything else to achieve the 40/40 tune or super close.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on December 26, 2016, 01:17:59 PM
Thanks Don. You gotta know me by now though. I hate fishing where everyone else fishes.

I think if I work hard enough, I can figure out how to add this extra plenum without losing the HPA side and make it a complete drop in part. This one part would be the golden asset for regulating your 25.

If I am thinking right, all you would need is the "extra plenum" , the Huma with gauge port, and an SSG or the new TSS. No need for new valves,porting, or anything else to achieve the 40/40 tune or super close.
I get it but I have to confess until I retire and have the opportunity to learn the metal lathe and milling machine I have to rely on others for all the heavy lifting since my knowledge is all second hand where modding is concerned. If all goes well I plan on building a >22 gen II Marauder with longer TJ's Barrel and upgraded longer shroud with more baffles to keep the beast backyard friendly . I will also set it up with a longer Titanium air tube and regulator to maximize power and shot count
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 01:29:29 PM
Sounds like a good plan.

It would be great if someone came up with a larger diameter shroud with baffles to keep the length the same. You know, a receiver spacer, longer screw on the bolt to catch the hammer (or vise versa), and a 1.25" or 1.5" shroud with baffles. ;D

The 22 is a hammer. My regged 22 synrod maxes out to around 31fpe but, I know if I jumped the reg to 2000psi (set at 1550psi now), it would be able to hit 42fpe and with that stupid plenum adapter would make it a 55fpe regulated 22 synrod.

Add a TJ barrel or whatever barrel at a length of 24" to 26" and I have no idea where it would put that FPE at (I am sure it would be high).

So many things to do. ;D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on December 26, 2016, 01:33:58 PM
Sounds like a good plan.

It would be great if someone came up with a larger diameter shroud with baffles to keep the length the same. You know, a receiver spacer, longer screw on the bolt to catch the hammer (or vise versa), and a 1.25" or 1.5" shroud with baffles. ;D

The 22 is a hammer. My regged 22 synrod maxes out to around 31fpe but, I know if I jumped the reg to 2000psi (set at 1550psi now), it would be able to hit 42fpe and with that stupid plenum adapter would make it a 55fpe regulated 22 synrod.

Add a TJ barrel or whatever barrel at a length of 24" to 26" and I have no idea where it would put that FPE at (I am sure it would be high).

So many things to do. ;D
Right now I'm watching what Lloyd is doing with my .30 Marauder. Basically with off the shelf parts he has it right at ~80 fpe and I sent him some Bobs Boat tail 70 gr .30 bullets to play with
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 01:42:27 PM
I have been watching your build too. It's gonna be a nice 30 cal. You sure got the right guy building it. ;D I just want to see Lloyd in his scientist white coat testing it. I love it when he wears that. :D

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on December 26, 2016, 02:04:04 PM
 ;) ;D Ever since I joined this forum 3 years ago I have had the privilege to meet and in some cases spend time with generous and inventive people with talent and passion for this hobby we all share. Your springs and thinking outside the box has also contributed to the significant progress we have made with PCP performance in the last 2 years
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 02:38:45 PM
Gee thanks Don, I still feel like ball slapping you. :D "who would do something like that" ?????

That's a joke :D. You just gotta know me to appreciate it.

Your a great moderator and I for one thank you for what you do. Still want to ball slap you though (just for fun)..... :D "dang" kids......

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on December 26, 2016, 02:49:13 PM
Gee thanks Don, I still feel like ball slapping you. :D "who would do something like that" ?????

That's a joke :D. You just gotta know me to appreciate it.

Your a great moderator and I for one thank you for what you do. Still want to ball slap you though (just for fun)..... :D "dang" kids......
Just remember that I qualify as elderly and as such That might be considered elder abuse although my 24 year old stepson would rather pick on someone his own 6'4" 260 than the fat old biker that lives with his mom  ;) ;D ;D ;D Just retaliating in good fun  ;D ;D ;D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 02:56:40 PM
LMBO..... ;D :D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: J M on December 26, 2016, 08:39:23 PM
Santa brought me some goodies for the Marauder so and I had the day off so installed and tested.

Gun is Gen II .25
Huma Reg
Hill Valve, Lightweight hammer and HF Transfer port.
Turned down bolt probe to .115
War SSG
pellet JSB 24.39

All tuning was essentially the same, method which was set up and adjust GAP and preload to get in the low 40 PF range and then shot for count.

1st attempt
Huma set at 135 BAR (read about 2200 or so on marauder gauge)
fill to 3000 PSI
31 shots
AVG FPS 864.9
SD 4.5
ES 18

2nd attempt
Upped fill a little to 3100 and lessened pre load, played w gap to get it in the 40 FP range (860 fps range w that pellet).
35 shots ( last 3 off regulator)
AVG FPS 865.8
SD 5.5
ES 17
 
Now I'm thinking I have reg. set to high to achieve a  40/40 ?
De-gas pull reg. and re set reg to 130 Bar, re assemble, gas up and go back to chrony.

3rd attempt
fill back to normal 3000 psi
Got 40 shots ...Hooo Ra ! ( although last 4 shot off reg ? Close but no cigar?

AVG FPS 860.1
SD 5.4
ES 25 ( last couple shots started dropping off averages significantly). 

Close but no cigar
 I'm thinking another small turn down or regulate to say perhaps 125 Bar would do the trick?

Thoughts or advise appreciated?


 


Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 26, 2016, 08:58:04 PM
Great work JM....

One question:
Did you drill out the barrel port to match the transfer port sleeve ? If you didn't, that's where the power and shot count is going to come in to play with all the rest of the work done.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on December 27, 2016, 12:18:46 AM
J M,
     If you are attempting 40 fpe, consider dropping your regulator to about 1800 to 1900 pounds.  I had the WAR SSG adjusted to the least spring compression, and a rather large gap to get it Down to 40 FPE.  (however, I had specified the Hill valve with the 6 pound spring installed). 
It does not require very much pressure to hit 40 FPE.

 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on December 27, 2016, 11:16:05 AM
I ended up replacing my war ssg spring with an 8lb spring from McMaster.  It made the gun much easier to cock and still have enough power to hit 40 fpe for 40 shots.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: mobilemail on December 27, 2016, 11:35:07 AM
I ended up replacing my war ssg spring with an 8lb spring from McMaster.  It made the gun much easier to cock and still have enough power to hit 40 fpe for 40 shots.

Could you give me the P/N and/or specs for the spring?  I'm going to make an SSG for my gen1 .22, I have the other parts laying around but didn't know what spring to get.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on December 27, 2016, 12:05:12 PM
This is the one i used for my gun.

(https://www.mcmaster.com/mvb/library/20120730/9657k413l.gif)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: J M on December 27, 2016, 11:01:08 PM
shorty, yes I drilled out the barrel port.
Adder tooth, yes I'm going to turn the reg, down a little more. its currently at 130 Bar on the reg.  but show about 2100 psi on the marauder gauge. Could be  the gauge is reading a little high?

Pretty happy with where this going, vastly improved over stock already.
I didn't have any problem hitting 40  FPE with the way its set up, contrary, my first few shot were high 800's  I had to back the hammer spring way off and more gap to slow it down a little. was shooting for 860 fps to get 40 FPE number. Thinking that was the minimum target  and that would stretch the shot count out to get the 40 shots off he regulator.

First chance,  I'm going to turn it down a bit probably to 125 to 127.5 and try again.

question
I have heard regulators have to break in (settle in), how many shots does it take and will it change shot count at all ?



Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 28, 2016, 08:46:39 AM
Have no idea what kind of break in time is needed.

I forgot to say yesterday:
Welcome to the club. Congratulations on the 40/40 tune. Your gonna love it.  ;D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on December 28, 2016, 09:17:52 AM
J M,
  The tough question is: which gauge do you trust.  Of my three gauges (two guns, one pump), I trust the pump a bit more, as it is a higher quality gauge.  So how do I validate the less accurate gauge on the gun?  Before the regulator was installed, the value displayed on the gauges were compared.  But even now a comparison is possible (even with the regulator in place).  I shoot the gun until it barely falls off the regulator, then I see how much pressure the pump needs to have before air just begins to move into the air gun.  Then I read the value on the pump's gauge and compare it with the gauge in the stock (which now shows the regulated pressure). Keep in mind all regulators will have a small pressure drop across them, the quality of a gauge can be "somewhat" measured by how small the pressure loss is.   My issue is further complicated by the fact the gauges on my Maximus on Marauder match, but differ from the pump's gauge.  Some day I may purchase a super-duper gauge to settle the issue, but for less than a 10 percent difference, I am not inclined to quibble. 

    All of the foo-foo above aside.  My Huma regulator seems to produce more pressure than what it is set for.  (roughly 7 bar higher than the actual setting).  The single sample of the Huma regulator on hand took about 200+ shots before it appeared to fully settle in.  Hope this helps you.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: WHITEFANG on December 29, 2016, 11:12:04 AM
On the Marauder. 25 converted BP I used all WAR valve and more. The gun shot as a regulated gun. Shooting jsb exacts the gun shot 55+ accurate fpe. Shots at birds 100 yards+- with ease.

As for the sound I improved it with a larger shroud od on the area of the factory shroud muzzle end and it added 5+-" to the overall lenght. On the bull pup the added lenght did not look as a goose gun.

Here is the Marauder WAR bottle gun and the Evanix RS2 9MM with that set up. It can be made more friendly.

(http://i1326.photobucket.com/albums/u643/FANG59LOBO/20150627_191553_zps9de3f2f5.jpg)[/URL (http://s1326.photobucket.com/user/FANG59LOBO/media/20150627_191553_zps9de3f2f5.jpg.html)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ezman604 on December 29, 2016, 12:26:33 PM
Took off work yesterday to burn a last day of vacation and get some bench time therapy. :)
Yep, love the Audrius regulators. But would like to try the Huma with gauge port. Anyway, extensive work on a Gen1 .25 MRod along with installation of the Audrius set to 2K. Has my external power adjuster. Will post a couple of shot strings (one for max power and one for shot count) as soon as I can get more trigger time. My goal is at least 4 magazines (32 shots) at 47-48fpe. I know it will generate at least 57fpe when turned up but not sure exactly for how many shots. Guessing at least 16. Will see.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ezman604 on January 01, 2017, 10:45:32 PM
Just finished the bench work on this one. Can use a bit of tweaking to fine tune it. But what was done was an Audrius regulator set to 2100psi installed. Gauge block opened up, valve input cap opened up, poppet stem necked down and lighter poppet spring. Valve output port opened to 0.165". TP and barrel port both opened to match.
Light weight hammer added with internal SSG and medium weight spring. External power adjuster added. Power adjuster set for approximately 2 turns out for a starting area of 830-840fps with 25.39gr JSB rounds. Here's a 40 shot string. Ending pressure 1750psi.

I'll add that this one has lots of adjustability as far as power. It can be turned up and I've seen it slam out 33.95gr JSB at 57-58fpe. It can also be turned down for lower power and a much longer shot string. The SSG spring preload can also be tweaked. And one last shameless plug, this one will be available soon in a classified gate near you.
:)

(http://i979.photobucket.com/albums/ae272/ezman604/.25%20MRod%20Audrius_zpsxfzcy1yr.jpg)

  1   831   38.94
  2   844   40.17
  3   831   38.94
  4   848   40.55
  5   835   37.45
  6   839   39.69
  7   847   40.45
  8   837   39.5
  9   831   38.94
10   838   39.6
11   833   39.13
12   816   37.55
13   807   36.72
14   823   38.19
15   826   38.47
16   814   37.36
17   834   39.22
18   831   38.94
19   826   38.47
20   823   38.19
21   827   38.56
22   823   38.19
23   826   38.47
24   840   39.79
25   835   39.31
26   833   39.13
27   837   39.5
28   835   39.31
29   833   39.13
30   827   38.56
31   821   38.01
32   826   38.47
33   837   39.5
34   835   39.31
35   833   39.13
36   831   38.94
37   827   38.56
38   826   38.47
39   821   38.01
40   820   37.45

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on January 02, 2017, 09:55:27 AM
Very nice work!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on January 02, 2017, 05:22:52 PM
Great job-string looks good to me. Another one added to the 40/40.

A little advice to people thinking about doing this 40/40 tune or just regulating their Mrod, do yourself a favor and get a new pressure gauge. This is my second Mrod and now it's going to be my second pressure gauge. Mine took a dump.

When is crossman gonna splurge for something better than this cheapo pressure gauge that fails continuously ? So disappointing some times. :(
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ezman604 on January 02, 2017, 05:48:22 PM
Yep, I replace mine with these...
http://www.ebay.com/itm/171826034342?_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT (http://www.ebay.com/itm/171826034342?_trksid=p2057872.m2749.l2649&ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: WHITEFANG on January 02, 2017, 07:59:32 PM
Good work!! The low numbers can be thrown by inconsistent pellets sizing. 40 shots is great for that gun.

So you are using the SSG with the light spring and how light of a hammer? Assuming I may have missed that you are using the lightweight valve spring?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ezman604 on January 02, 2017, 08:17:30 PM
Yep, lighter weight valve poppet spring. One you can actually operate the poppet with your finger, something you cannot do with the OEM spring. :)
This hammer is 42gram in weight. Down from the 77gram OEM hammer. And it makes much better power, accuracy and more stable results with the JSB MKII 33.95gr rounds.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on January 03, 2017, 08:38:56 PM
That's great!! Might need another .25 Mrod to have 2 regulated .25s  ::)
Just bought the .25 that Travis used for testing the TSS
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on January 04, 2017, 01:43:53 AM
That's great!! Might need another .25 Mrod to have 2 regulated .25s  ::)
Just bought the .25 that Travis used for testing the TSS


You lucky dog!! In assuming it came with the TSS huh?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ShawninIL on January 04, 2017, 07:47:39 AM
That's great!! Might need another .25 Mrod to have 2 regulated .25s  ::)
Just bought the .25 that Travis used for testing the TSS


You lucky dog!! In assuming it came with the TSS huh?
Yep and fully tweaked and tuned by the man himself. Should be on the way today.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on January 04, 2017, 10:19:27 AM
That's great!! Might need another .25 Mrod to have 2 regulated .25s  ::)
Just bought the .25 that Travis used for testing the TSS


You lucky dog!! In assuming it came with the TSS huh?
Yep and fully tweaked and tuned by the man himself. Should be on the way today.

Nice buy for sure! Let us know how it is
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Zachary Hoy on January 04, 2017, 10:23:16 AM
I wanted to say thank you for everyone who contributed to this thread and provided the info to help me join the 40/40 club. It was a fun road to travel ending in success.

Description: Synrod .25/reg/135bar/Hill valve, hammer, striker
Notes 1: lightest valve spring, 262 hammer spring, bored out to .187
Notes 2: Polished tube, Bolt probe thinned, hand lapped barrel, gen 2
Distance to Chrono (FT): 6.00
Ballistic Coefficient: 1.000
Bullet Weight (gr): 25.430
Altitude (FT): 0.0
Temp: 52 °F
BP: 29.95 inHG
Shots
#     FPS        FT-LBS     PF
40    829        38.81      21.08     
39    831        39.00      21.13     
38    834        39.28      21.21     
37    843        40.13      21.44     
36    838        39.66      21.31     
35    842        40.04      21.41     
34    844        40.23      21.46     
33    838        39.66      21.31     
32    844        40.23      21.46     
31    841        39.94      21.39     
30    850        40.80      21.62     
29    849        40.71      21.59     
28    845        40.33      21.49     
27    843        40.13      21.44     
26    837        39.57      21.28     
25    840        39.85      21.36     
24    834        39.28      21.21     
23    837        39.57      21.28     
22    836        39.47      21.26     
21    832        39.09      21.16     
20    837        39.57      21.28     
19    831        39.00      21.13     
18    833        39.19      21.18     
17    833        39.19      21.18     
16    836        39.47      21.26     
15    835        39.38      21.23     
14    842        40.04      21.41     
13    845        40.33      21.49     
12    846        40.42      21.51     
11    846        40.42      21.51     
10    843        40.13      21.44     
9     844        40.23      21.46     
8     845        40.33      21.49     
7     839        39.75      21.34     
6     847        40.52      21.54     
5     848        40.61      21.56     
4     827        38.63      21.03     
3     830        38.91      21.11     
2     831        39.00      21.13     
1     828        38.72      21.06     
Average: 838.83
StdDev: 6.35
Min: 827
Max: 850
Spread: 23
True MV: 839.40
Shots/sec: 0.00
Group Size (IN): 0.00
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on January 04, 2017, 05:35:03 PM
Another success story.

Sounds like this 40/40 is starting to be the norm. ;D

I think it's getting time to start developing that (drop in) extra plenum to take this 40/40 tune to the next level. :D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on January 05, 2017, 01:01:42 PM
I wonder if it would be possible to get 24/50, 32/45, and 40/40 by just changing the gap on ssg.  It would be nice to have like a single adjustment that could adjust power like that.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on January 05, 2017, 02:21:12 PM
I wonder if it would be possible to get 24/50, 32/45, and 40/40 by just changing the gap on ssg.  It would be nice to have like a single adjustment that could adjust power like that.

40 shotsat 40 FPE would be a total of 1600 FPE for the fill. Wouldn't the equivalent at 50 FPE/shot be 1600/50 = 32 shots at 50 FPE/shot? If so, I wonder if that would be doable, perhaps, as David suggested, via adjusting the SSG?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on January 05, 2017, 02:33:28 PM
I wonder if it would be possible to get 24/50, 32/45, and 40/40 by just changing the gap on ssg.  It would be nice to have like a single adjustment that could adjust power like that.

40 shotsat 40 FPE would be a total of 1600 FPE for the fill. Wouldn't the equivalent at 50 FPE/shot be 1600/50 = 32 shots at 50 FPE/shot? If so, I wonder if that would be doable, perhaps, as David suggested, via adjusting the SSG?

In general, all things equal, if you are going to a higher fpe, the efficiency will decrease, and you will not achieve the math you stated.   
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on January 05, 2017, 02:37:02 PM
I wonder if it would be possible to get 24/50, 32/45, and 40/40 by just changing the gap on ssg.  It would be nice to have like a single adjustment that could adjust power like that.

40 shotsat 40 FPE would be a total of 1600 FPE for the fill. Wouldn't the equivalent at 50 FPE/shot be 1600/50 = 32 shots at 50 FPE/shot? If so, I wonder if that would be doable, perhaps, as David suggested, via adjusting the SSG?

In general, all things equal, if you are going to a higher fpe, the efficiency will decrease, and you will not achieve the math you stated.

Given what is being done at 40+- FPE, I wonder that might be doable, then, at 50 FPE or 60?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on January 05, 2017, 03:01:10 PM
To get to the current 40/40, significant valve modding or aftermarket valves were used.  Not much more room left, so most likely your shot count will be lower than prediction.  Also, as mentioned by Shorty, plenum size is going to come into play.   So if you didn't have the "chamber ext" he mentions, then that will cost you airtube volume and shot count loss. 

Typical hunting, not going to need as many high power shots.  Even this 40/40 is overkill for typical hunting. 
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: addertooth on January 05, 2017, 03:32:52 PM
Zachary Hoy,
Turn down your regulator pressure to 125-129 Bar and your extreme spread will go down.  In your posted shot string your velocity goes up as you start to come off the regulator, a sign your regulator pressure is too high.  As well as your ES going down, you may discover you get a couple more shots as well (and it looks like your average velocity will go up as well).  This is assuming you leave all other adjustments exactly where they currently are.   Best of luck.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on January 05, 2017, 03:35:57 PM
Generally, in a regulated PCP, as you increase the FPE requirement, you need a higher setpoint pressure, or the efficiency suffers.... even if you can attain the higher FPE level.... This means that the typical trade off in FPE and shot count you see in an unregulated PCP doesn't often apply.... As you increase the setpoint pressure to achieve the higher FPE, you lose "headroom", ie the amount of HPA available between your fill pressure and setpoint, and that costs you directly on shot count.... For instance, if you increase the setpoint from 1800 psi to 2200, on a gun with a 3000 psi fill, the headroom in the HP side of the regulator decreases from 1200 psi to 800 psi, which relates to a direct 33% loss in the air available to produce shots.... Factor in that your shots are now more powerful, and each one requires more air, and the shot count drops dramatically, even if the efficiency remains the same.... If you don't increase the plenum size, you are likely to lose efficiency at the increased FPE level, further reducing shot count.... and if you do increase the plenum size, you lose even more air on the HP side, which again loses the ability to produce shots....

In a nutshell, that is the basic reason that regulated PCPs are more suitable for low to medium power applications.... The exception is if they are specifically designed, from the ground up, for a high-power application.... with a large bottle and a large plenum....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ezman604 on January 05, 2017, 03:43:46 PM
Just finished the bench work on this one. Can use a bit of tweaking to fine tune it. But what was done was an Audrius regulator set to 2100psi installed. Gauge block opened up, valve input cap opened up, poppet stem necked down and lighter poppet spring. Valve output port opened to 0.165". TP and barrel port both opened to match.
Light weight hammer added with internal SSG and medium weight spring. External power adjuster added. Power adjuster set for approximately 2 turns out for a starting area of 830-840fps with 25.39gr JSB rounds. Here's a 40 shot string. Ending pressure 1750psi.

I'll add that this one has lots of adjustability as far as power. It can be turned up and I've seen it slam out 33.95gr JSB at 57-58fpe. It can also be turned down for lower power and a much longer shot string. The SSG spring preload can also be tweaked. And one last shameless plug, this one will be available soon in a classified gate near you.
:)

(http://i979.photobucket.com/albums/ae272/ezman604/.25%20MRod%20Audrius_zpsxfzcy1yr.jpg)

  1   831   38.94
  2   844   40.17
  3   831   38.94
  4   848   40.55
  5   835   37.45
  6   839   39.69
  7   847   40.45
  8   837   39.5
  9   831   38.94
10   838   39.6
11   833   39.13
12   816   37.55
13   807   36.72
14   823   38.19
15   826   38.47
16   814   37.36
17   834   39.22
18   831   38.94
19   826   38.47
20   823   38.19
21   827   38.56
22   823   38.19
23   826   38.47
24   840   39.79
25   835   39.31
26   833   39.13
27   837   39.5
28   835   39.31
29   833   39.13
30   827   38.56
31   821   38.01
32   826   38.47
33   837   39.5
34   835   39.31
35   833   39.13
36   831   38.94
37   827   38.56
38   826   38.47
39   821   38.01
40   820   37.45



FYI and to answer the question about being able to get results from simply adjusting an SSG assembly.
Yes...it can be done quiet easily. The above string was made with the MRod after installing the Aurdius regulator set to 200-2100psi. PERSONALLY, I can't see regulating anything above .20cal. Now, to me, anything above that caliber has a primary mission that includes hunting. And if hunting, I'm not concerned with getting 40-50 shots. I want at least 2 clips at max power and range. But hey, that's just me.
This same MRod that posted these numbers above posted these numbers below. This is without the Audrius regulator but with the light weight hammer and internal SSG. Turned up, this one can crank out 56-58fpe from JSB MKII 33.95gr for at least 2 good magazines. Simply turning the power adjuster down will give you a much longer string at reduced power. Virtually the same as the regulated airgun IMO.
I had a regulator laying around and to post in this thread, I installed it just to see. I'm still convinced the right internal modifications with an internal SSG and power adjuster is the way to go.
I've almost got my schedule of projects cleared and will be benching all of my MRods and Discos soon to make these same internal improvements.
Here's the string unregulated and achieved by simply adjusting the SSG.

#     FPS        FT-LBS
1     748        42.19
2     766        44.24
3     778        45.64
4     790        47.06
5     794        47.53
6     795        47.65
7     801        48.37
8     799        48.13
9     814        49.96
10    821        50.82
11    831        52.07
12    823        51.07
13    830        51.94
14    837        52.82
15    827        51.57
16    841        53.33
17    851        54.60
18    840        53.20
19    850        54.47
20    846        53.96
21    836        52.69
22    845        53.84
23    839        53.07
24    833        52.32
25    822        50.94
26    814        49.96
27    813        49.84
28    808        49.22 
29    803        48.62
30    788        46.82
31    791        47.17     
32    775        45.29
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Zachary Hoy on January 05, 2017, 04:09:07 PM
Zachary Hoy,
Turn down your regulator pressure to 125-129 Bar and your extreme spread will go down.  In your posted shot string your velocity goes up as you start to come off the regulator, a sign your regulator pressure is too high.  As well as your ES going down, you may discover you get a couple more shots as well (and it looks like your average velocity will go up as well).  This is assuming you leave all other adjustments exactly where they currently are.   Best of luck.


What would you suggest another 5 bar? That was the very first 40 shots after installing the regulator and es has tightened up. I do however have that spike still. NM I missed the first sentence somehow. My apologies
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on January 05, 2017, 05:24:48 PM
Here's my 50fpe tune. Easily do-able with just 2 turns on my hammer spring. :D

33.95 grain JSB's

Shot   FPS   FPE
1   814   50.0
2   824   51.2
3   827   51.6
4   825   51.3
5   825   51.3
6   826   51.4
7   817   50.3
8   825   51.3
9   812   49.7
10   817   50.3
11   810   49.5
12   814   50.0
13   812   49.7
14   822   50.9
15   815   50.1
16   824   51.2
17   827   51.6
18   827   51.6
19   820   50.7
20   823   51.1
21   825   51.3
22   825   51.3
23   816   50.2
24   818   50.5
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on January 05, 2017, 06:01:00 PM
Pretty good example right there.... a drop from 40x40 = 1600 FPE to 24x50 = 1200 FPE total (a 25% loss) with the power increase.... and that doesn't allow for the added efficiency gained by changing from 25 gr. pellets to 34 gr....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: David9862 on January 05, 2017, 06:08:57 PM
Shorty.. You're using a short stiff spring with zero preload right?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on January 05, 2017, 06:30:27 PM
Yup. My short stiff spring. At 2 turns on the hammer spring adjuster it puts the hammer right on the valve stem. 2.5 turns begins to give preload.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on January 05, 2017, 06:32:01 PM
Generally, in a regulated PCP, as you increase the FPE requirement, you need a higher setpoint pressure, or the efficiency suffers.... even if you can attain the higher FPE level.... This means that the typical trade off in FPE and shot count you see in an unregulated PCP doesn't often apply.... As you increase the setpoint pressure to achieve the higher FPE, you lose "headroom", ie the amount of HPA available between your fill pressure and setpoint, and that costs you directly on shot count.... For instance, if you increase the setpoint from 1800 psi to 2200, on a gun with a 3000 psi fill, the headroom in the HP side of the regulator decreases from 1200 psi to 800 psi, which relates to a direct 33% loss in the air available to produce shots.... Factor in that your shots are now more powerful, and each one requires more air, and the shot count drops dramatically, even if the efficiency remains the same.... If you don't increase the plenum size, you are likely to lose efficiency at the increased FPE level, further reducing shot count.... and if you do increase the plenum size, you lose even more air on the HP side, which again loses the ability to produce shots....

In a nutshell, that is the basic reason that regulated PCPs are more suitable for low to medium power applications.... The exception is if they are specifically designed, from the ground up, for a high-power application.... with a large bottle and a large plenum....

Bob

Thanks, Bob. Great info. I think the bulb may be beginning to glow a bit.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on January 05, 2017, 11:16:25 PM
40 FPE is not a high-powered tune for a .25 cal.... With equal barrel length and pressures, and similar proportions on the ports (eg. 75% of caliber, for example), the following tunes are roughly equivalent....

.177 cal.... 20 FPE
.22 cal.... 30 FPE
.25 cal.... 40 FPE
.30 cal.... 60 FPE
.35 cal.... 80 FPE

The above power levels are quite reasonable to achieve with a regulated PCP and still get a good shot count and efficiency.... At 1.5 times those FPE levels, things get more difficult with a regulator, and you have to start thinking about longer barrels, bigger ports and plenums, and maybe higher setponts.... To get twice those FPE numbers, you are really pushing what can be achieved with a regulated PCP, and you will be looking at bullets to get the FPE and bottle guns to get the shot count.... In most cases, starting with a conventional, single tube PCP, you would be better off unregulated....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Dairyboy on January 05, 2017, 11:21:13 PM
I broke down and bought a TSS for my regulated Mrod im thinking im going to be able to get a higher power tune than my last and looking forward to the easier cocking for sure!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 05, 2017, 11:34:25 PM
40 FPE is not a high-powered tune for a .25 cal.... With equal barrel length and pressures, and similar proportions on the ports (eg. 75% of caliber, for example), the following tunes are roughly equivalent....

.177 cal.... 20 FPE
.22 cal.... 30 FPE
.25 cal.... 40 FPE
.30 cal.... 60 FPE
.35 cal.... 80 FPE

The above power levels are quite reasonable to achieve with a regulated PCP and still get a good shot count and efficiency.... At 1.5 times those FPE levels, things get more difficult with a regulator, and you have to start thinking about longer barrels, bigger ports and plenums, and maybe higher setponts.... To get twice those FPE numbers, you are really pushing what can be achieved with a regulated PCP, and you will be looking at bullets to get the FPE and bottle guns to get the shot count.... In most cases, starting with a conventional, single tube PCP, you would be better off unregulated....

Bob

I enjoy reading your posts, Bob. Always concise and very informative.  In your opinion what mods would have to be made to get a good number of 40 fpe .22 shots? Assuming a heavy pellet like the HN barracuda 21.14? Is it possible to get to 40/40 or somewhere close with a .22?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on January 05, 2017, 11:43:07 PM
I broke down and bought a TSS for my regulated Mrod im thinking im going to be able to get a higher power tune than my last and looking forward to the easier cocking for sure!

Great, but how did you manage it? I didn't think they were available quite yet. Not on the web site, yet, that I could see. In any event, I will be looking forward to your results. Good luck.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 05, 2017, 11:47:01 PM
I broke down and bought a TSS for my regulated Mrod im thinking im going to be able to get a higher power tune than my last and looking forward to the easier cocking for sure!

Great, but how did you manage it? I didn't think they were available quite yet. Not on the web site, yet, that I could see. In any event, I will be looking forward to your results. Good luck.

They are in the WAR store. $70.00.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on January 05, 2017, 11:47:44 PM
Well, it is easier to get 40 FPE in .25 cal than in .22 cal, because the air has more area to push on.... To get 40 FPE in .22 cal is going to be similar to trying to get about 53 FPE in a .25 cal in terms of efficiency.... but you only need enough air (at that efficiency) to develop 40 FPE, not 53 FPE.... Shorty got 24 shots with his 50 FPE tune in .25 cal, so at the same pressure you might get 30-32 shots in .22 cal.... I think three mags at 40 FPE should be easy, but four 10-shot mags at 40 FPE in .22 cal might be pretty tough with a regulated MRod....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 05, 2017, 11:57:52 PM
Well, it is easier to get 40 FPE in .25 cal than in .22 cal, because the air has more area to push on.... To get 40 FPE in .22 cal is going to be similar to trying to get about 53 FPE in a .25 cal in terms of efficiency.... but you only need enough air (at that efficiency) to develop 40 FPE, not 53 FPE.... Shorty got 24 shots with his 50 FPE tune in .25 cal, so at the same pressure you might get 30-32 shots in .22 cal.... I think three mags at 40 FPE should be easy, but four 10-shot mags at 40 FPE in .22 cal might be pretty tough with a regulated MRod....

Bob

Thanks for the info, Bob. I would not be disappointed with 30/40 out of my .22. I have a reg and all of Tim Hill's stuff on the way. Guess we will see. Thanks again.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on January 06, 2017, 01:22:50 AM
It is highly unlikely you will get 30 shots at 40 FPE with your .22 cal.  The main thing to focus on is the accuracy and finding the most accurate pellet for your unique barrel.  The speed at which you push a pellet will be part of the accuracy equation.  I have pushed the 21.14gn to 35 FPE once, but the accuracy and shot count were reduced at that level.  However, this was with a stock valve and porting so I suppose you could hit 40 FPE at the peak with a modified valve and heavy lead, but not for 30 shots unless you fill to levels beyond the manufacture's safe operating recommendations.  I run 40 shots at 30 FPE at a 2% ES for accuracy at 50 yards and beyond, but that's just me and what I like my .22 to do.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 06, 2017, 10:45:33 AM
It is highly unlikely you will get 30 shots at 40 FPE with your .22 cal.  The main thing to focus on is the accuracy and finding the most accurate pellet for your unique barrel.  The speed at which you push a pellet will be part of the accuracy equation.  I have pushed the 21.14gn to 35 FPE once, but the accuracy and shot count were reduced at that level.  However, this was with a stock valve and porting so I suppose you could hit 40 FPE at the peak with a modified valve and heavy lead, but not for 30 shots unless you fill to levels beyond the manufacture's safe operating recommendations.  I run 40 shots at 30 FPE at a 2% ES for accuracy at 50 yards and beyond, but that's just me and what I like my .22 to do.

Thanks for your response, Keith. Once I get some baselines established and figure out which pellet it likes I'll just go from there. I plan to install the reg by itself and establish a new baseline and so on with the mods one at a time. I'm looking forward to the process!! Your 40 @ 30 with 2% ES @ 50 yards plus sounds very good to me. Hopefully I can get somewhere in that neighborhood.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Wayne52 on January 06, 2017, 10:53:52 AM
Terry I've seen where guys are using the .25 Mrod valve in their .22 also, I've never really looked into it but it's worth finding out about.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 06, 2017, 10:55:06 AM
Terry I've seen where guys are using the .25 Mrod valve in their .22 also, I've never really looked into it but it's worth finding out about.

Thanks Wayne. That's interesting. I had not read about that.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: rsterne on January 06, 2017, 12:32:41 PM
40 shots at 30 FPE will be easier to obtain than 30 shots at 40 FPE in .22 cal.... To get 40 FPE you will probably need larger ports than stock, in a regulated MRod....

Bob
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 06, 2017, 01:27:43 PM
40 shots at 30 FPE will be easier to obtain than 30 shots at 40 FPE in .22 cal.... To get 40 FPE you will probably need larger ports than stock, in a regulated MRod....

Bob

Thanks, Bob. Do I hear 35@35? :) lol.... If the weather is good enough I'm going to try out some different pellets and attempt to establish a bone stock baseline this weekend. I'll make a separate post with those strings so my inexperienced ramblings aren't in the midst of someone else's thread.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: FuzzyGrub on January 06, 2017, 01:29:05 PM
Terry I've seen where guys are using the .25 Mrod valve in their .22 also, I've never really looked into it but it's worth finding out about.

On Gen II, the main difference is the poppet spring.   The 25 cal TP has a larger ID than the 177/22 TP.  ie the valve itself won't buy any real performance improvement.  Tim's valve that he has ordered will be much better than stock.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 06, 2017, 01:30:58 PM
Terry I've seen where guys are using the .25 Mrod valve in their .22 also, I've never really looked into it but it's worth finding out about.

On Gen II, the main difference is the poppet spring.   The 25 cal TP has a larger ID than the 177/22 TP.  ie the valve itself won't buy any real performance improvement.  Tim's valve that he has ordered will be much better than stock.

Thanks for that info! I've got the basic tune info from Tim and the parts are supposed to be in my mail box today. I'm interested to see how this all goes.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on January 06, 2017, 01:44:26 PM

Just out of respect for Shorty's thread on regulated 25s, I would recommend starting your own .22 cal Armada build thread so these guys can get back to the OPs original topic.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 06, 2017, 01:51:40 PM

Just out of respect for Shorty's thread on regulated 25s, I would recommend starting your own .22 cal Armada build thread so these guys can get back to the OPs original topic.

Will do. Was stated a couple posts back.  ;) Sorry for the hijack, Shorty!!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on January 06, 2017, 02:08:11 PM
No problems here Terry. Just to help you out, here's a table of stats on my 22synrod when it was NOT regulated. Porting was at .141".

Bob,
What your saying is so true with high power and regulated shots as it sits now with what we have. Although, things are going to change soon with this additional auxiliary plenum.
Just think, this drop in part (experimental and on the drawing table) should be able to bring those high power regulated shots with a "stock-looking" configuration.

I just need to work harder or get a few others on board. I firmly believe this auxiliary plenum can get a 22 to 40 fpe for 35 to 40 shots and a 25 cal to 65fpe+ for 16 to 24 shots while being able to tune it back (with a hammer spring adjustment) to a medium power level for efficiencies over 1.9 and all on the stock tube making the gun look like it's in it's stock configuration.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: TerryH on January 06, 2017, 02:13:46 PM
No problems here Terry. Just to help you out, here's a table of stats on my 22synrod when it was NOT regulated. Porting was at .141".

Bob,
What your saying is so true with high power and regulated shots as it sits now with what we have. Although, things are going to change soon with this additional auxiliary plenum.
Just think, this drop in part (experimental and on the drawing table) should be able to bring those high power regulated shots with a "stock-looking" configuration.

I just need to work harder or get a few others on board. I firmly believe this auxiliary plenum can get a 22 to 40 fpe for 35 to 40 shots and a 25 cal to 65fpe+ for 16 to 24 shots while being able to tune it back (with a hammer spring adjustment) to a medium power level for efficiencies over 1.9 and all on the stock tube making the gun look like it's in it's stock configuration.

Thank you, Tim.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on January 06, 2017, 03:11:41 PM

Shorty, I have always been impressed with your dual wire spring and the numbers you get with it.  I would love to try one with my setup.  I have watched your videos a number of times using it.  I have not received the TSS test kit from Travis he talked about, but I know he has his hands full with the TSS launch and he may have changed his mind about having me test it. 


Like you, I can appreciate the efforts it takes to come up with a new mod.  My DIY SSG and F.A.M.E. mods took a lot of time and effort to develop.  I gave the ideas away for free because it takes even more effort to launch them and support them.


The TSS idea came from your time and efforts creating the dual wire spring and I for one will always remember that.  You have come up with several really neat mods in the recent past including the SSS idea that I pay close attention to.  keep it up! 


Keith
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on January 06, 2017, 03:22:18 PM
I would have sent a couple to you if you asked. I just don't have enough wire to make them anymore. :D

With the skills that you have, I have a feeling you can make one or better.  Here's the video on how to make it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XR8GlE6aX9s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XR8GlE6aX9s)

Go on amazon and search "music wire" at what ever size you need. Music wire will work just as good. Piece of cake.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on January 06, 2017, 03:36:31 PM

I would have sent a couple to you if you asked. I just don't have enough wire to make them anymore. :D

With the skills that you have, I have a feeling you can make one or better.  Here's the video on how to make it:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XR8GlE6aX9s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XR8GlE6aX9s)

Go on amazon and search "music wire" at what ever size you need. Music wire will work just as good. Piece of cake.


Yes I have watched that video a few times.  You do make it look easy.  I'll have to give it a try.  Thanks!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Ozarkairgunner on April 15, 2017, 12:32:07 AM
So I know this kinda died off a while back but wanted to let y'all know I finnaly joined the 40/40. Took me a while to save up money for a few new parts, Hill light hammer and Hill valve with 6lb valve spring. I got 38 shots on the reg averaging 763fps and the last 2 shots just barely making 40fpe at 752fps and 738fps. All using the JSB MK2 33.9
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: kkarmical on May 29, 2017, 12:58:19 PM
I should be more than happy with my 29 shots,  but my string isn't as flat and I just feel there's a couple more shots hiding inside of it, that last shot I rushed.  But still 29 shots @ 52 fpe ain't too shabby for now...
I think next for me is to explore different springs with this ssg/mds combo or maybe go back to stock hammer for now I'm pretty stoked getting down to 5%..
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on May 29, 2017, 01:10:55 PM

I should be more than happy with my 29 shots,  but my string isn't as flat and I just feel there's a couple more shots hiding inside of it.  But still 29 shots @ 52 fpe ain't too shabby for now...

With that inconsistency in velocity, I would consider polishing the hammer tube. Check out Travis Whitney's Youtube video on the subject. Of course, he uses a ball hone of the correct grit, but there may be another way. I know this can make a big difference on Marauders.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CiXzq4WVA5s (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CiXzq4WVA5s)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: kkarmical on May 29, 2017, 01:31:49 PM

I think there's too much spring with ssg/mds combo, should be able to flatten it out by trying different springs at some point.  I was getting 24 shots that were really all over the place  12-14% es, so I backed it down a bit and ES came down it ain't perfect by no means but single digits + 5 more shots was a good compromise with where I am right now.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on May 29, 2017, 07:17:34 PM
That's a good many shots with good power no doubt. A high ES can be caused by many things. You definitely would want the hammer sliding as consistently as possible to rule it out.  Maybe clean the air tube and hammer free of grease and dirt then put a little dry graphite under the hammer. That stuff really works well on mine.  Makes it really slick to slide and doesn't attract dirt so much.  Good ventilation on both sides of the hammer is good to have also.  Good luck.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ackuric on May 29, 2017, 07:48:11 PM
I should be more than happy with my 29 shots,  but my string isn't as flat and I just feel there's a couple more shots hiding inside of it, that last shot I rushed.  But still 29 shots @ 52 fpe ain't too shabby for now...
I think next for me is to explore different springs with this ssg/mds combo or maybe go back to stock hammer for now I'm pretty stoked getting down to 5%..

I found my best efficiency at  .185" porting but I didn't try THAT many combinations of tp sizes, primarily .201" (my exit port size), .185", and .171"...efficiency at .171" and .201" were nearly equal which I found odd but at .185" I achieved better efficiency. I can't say a .05" size difference will equate to much for you but that's my observation.

The erratic fps could be so many things, but if the reg is broken in then its either too broken or isn't  able to perform at 1% es or better at that power level...could be a few other things but with the MDS hammer its less likely, but maybe something in your ssg setup is causing it? Worth investigating, idk how yours is built...

That is a great shot count though for the power you're obtaining, if you want a few more shots to give you another clip I would reduce the power down to 825~ FPS...
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: kkarmical on May 29, 2017, 11:02:44 PM

I'm going to shoot it a while like this and see if it settles down, but I think it's ssg/mds it's so smooth and easy cocking I can just tell there's too much spring for it.  I might try the stock hammer and see if I can make a change.

Also it may have been me as late night shooting I may have rushed more shots than I thought.  I may try tuning reg down a bit.

Also I think I could have taken 2 more shots, so I'm going to leave it set like this, shoot it for a while, then shoot another string take more time between shots and see if that alone brings me closer to that flatline.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: ackuric on May 30, 2017, 06:48:32 AM

I'm going to shoot it a while like this and see if it settles down, but I think it's ssg/mds it's so smooth and easy cocking I can just tell there's too much spring for it.  I might try the stock hammer and see if I can make a change.

Also it may have been me as late night shooting I may have rushed more shots than I thought.  I may try tuning reg down a bit.

Also I think I could have taken 2 more shots, so I'm going to leave it set like this, shoot it for a while, then shoot another string take more time between shots and see if that alone brings me closer to that flatline.

Too much spring has never caused my tunes to have a bad ES, only when coming off reg. On reg the only thing that really wrecked havoc on my ES was metal hammer galling and even then my es was 2-2.5%...

I highly suspect the regulator can't handle that high of power as well as say 40 fpe. JMO. Also if you have a VERY small plenum for this power level, that will cause this effect...as you dont have enough potential FPE in your plenum...

Lets just ASSUME you have only 20 cc plenum (as I once did)

That would give you a potential FPE of 384.. (this doesn't mean max in 1 shot, just what is available total as you can't expend all of this in one shot)

For the 50+ FPE you're gunning for you IDEALLY want a potential FPE of  AT LEAST 700...IMO. That would require a plenum of 39 CC's (@ 2k set point) to operate efficiently...

Your plenum is likely struggling to perform at that power level. I bet you won't have an erratic es like that @ 36-40 fpe :)

I also suspect your plenum volume is around 10-15 CC...or something crazy low. (200-300 potential fpe)

Hope I can save you some time, pellets, air and frustration as I am pretty sure my diagnosis is spot on. GL

Also too low of a set point for the desired FPE can also cause a higher shot to shot inconsistency...FYI, by creating the same effect as above.

-Matt
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: HighAltitudeAir on November 25, 2017, 10:54:06 AM
I know this is an older thread. I own an Aramda and want to improve shot count as well as accurcey with a workable power level which is not the most important.  I have ordered a cheep eBay regulator to tinker with and mod, and I have a Huma with gauge block and portport for the permanent setup. I have every thing in this forum on moding the Marauder gen II, but most of it has a cause and effect problem, like hammer gualing  hard cocking, and the Armada can't have any thing sticking out back of the hammer tube, because of the stock. So I also picked up a drop in Steve HDD current design unit from AOA. I have been thinking of get a used marauder stock to do the tuning with and then locking every thing in to a permanent state then back into the Armada stock. Has any thing evolved to reduce the need or hammer mods, and othe problem?
Thanks for any help.
CH
P.S.
 This is 25 cal new Armada. I need to fire a few more strings to get a broader data base. I contacted Scott about a tune rom him. Not knock on Scott, but didn't get much hope of achieving what I want. Being an engineer with a lot toys like CNC mill, and lathes as well forging power hammer. I just don't accept the word can't.
C?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on November 25, 2017, 11:03:22 AM
I know this is an older thread. I own an Aramda and want to improve shot count as well as accurcey with a workable power level which is not the most important.  I have ordered a cheep eBay regulator to tinker with and mod, and I have a Huma with gauge block and portport for the permanent setup. I have every thing in this forum on moding the Marauder gen II, but most of it has a cause and effect problem, like hammer gualing  hard cocking, and the Armada can't have any thing sticking out back of the hammer tube, because of the stock. So I also picked up a drop in Steve HDD current design unit from AOA. I have been thinking of get a used marauder stock to do the tuning with and then locking every thing in to a permanent state then back into the Armada stock. Has any thing evolved to reduce the need or hammer mods, and othe problem?
Thanks for any help.
CH
Talk to Rocker1 he can make you an MDS hammer or several other vendors also make drop in MDS hammers
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: HighAltitudeAir on November 25, 2017, 11:38:33 AM
I know this is an older thread. I own an Aramda and want to improve shot count as well as accurcey with a workable power level which is not the most important.  I have ordered a cheep eBay regulator to tinker with and mod, and I have a Huma with gauge block and portport for the permanent setup. I have every thing in this forum on moding the Marauder gen II, but most of it has a cause and effect problem, like hammer gualing  hard cocking, and the Armada can't have any thing sticking out back of the hammer tube, because of the stock. So I also picked up a drop in Steve HDD current design unit from AOA. I have been thinking of get a used marauder stock to do the tuning with and then locking every thing in to a permanent state then back into the Armada stock. Has any thing evolved to reduce the need or hammer mods, and othe problem?
Thanks for any help.
CH
Talk to Rocker1 he can make you an MDS hammer or several other vendors also make drop in MDS hammers
I was thinking about turcite instead of MDS and 12L44  as the hammer to get close to the stock weight of the stock hammer. Turcite is used to repair matching tool ways. They can carry a lot of weight and will never wear out or deform under pressure. It is oil proof and does not scratch under grit or dirt. It is capable millions of cycles under extreme load. I have used dry film lubricants that can eliminate metal to metal wear under extreme loads and conditions the may work very well on metal hammers?
C.H.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: HighAltitudeAir on December 08, 2017, 12:19:35 PM
Going to install a Hill valve, increased volume gauge section and Regulator in my Armada. I was woundering if a depinger is needs to be installed also. I hate the ping when you fire it. I will be using it for pest control and don't want to run everything off after the first shot
CH
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: mobilemail on December 08, 2017, 01:15:25 PM
Going to install a Hill valve, increased volume gauge section and Regulator in my Armada. I was woundering if a depinger is needs to be installed also. I hate the ping when you fire it. I will be using it for pest control and don't want to run everything off after the first shot
CH

The regulator should take care of the ping for you.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on December 08, 2017, 06:36:13 PM
A short stiff spring solves the problem of an SSG sticking out of the back of the gun. Just as efficient without all the work.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: HighAltitudeAir on December 08, 2017, 09:27:58 PM
Ok, great thanks Mark. I was hoping that was the case. I working on the Armada now and hoping I would not have to wait on a depinger.
CH
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 09, 2018, 02:46:19 PM
Here's my situation, so far ...

Rifle:   Marauder .25 synthetic stock

Mods:
Huma regulator with gauge port, set to 150 bar
Drilled valve and barrel ports to 11/64"
Hill lightweight valve spring
Hill 262 hammer spring
Hill high flow transfer port
Hill lightweight hammer

When the rifle is filled to 3000 psi, the rifle gauge shows 2350 psi.

The first thing I noticed was a much better sound. No more "buh-loop" as with stock setup. Just a  nice crisp, but quiet "BAP". Tim Hill recommends no more than 2.0 turns in on the hammer spring in going for a 40/40, but I had to go all the way to 4.0 to get to the 40 fpe range, or an average fps of about 845. At that point the cocking effort is a bit more than I would like, and I have to be careful to not double-load.

One thing I am going to have to address is that the hammer spring setting tends to drift down as the rifle is fired. That was an issue with the first shot in the below string, so I had to adjust back to 4.0, beginning with shot 2. By the end of the string, however, the hammer spring had drifted back down to 3.5 turns in.

So, what I have done seems to have improved the performance of the rifle, but I am a long way off from a 40/40 tune, and that is disappointing. Not that I'm not there, as I didn't expect to be, but that I seem to be so far off. The string is below. I would appreciate any thoughts or suggestions.

-------------------------------------
1.   821 (HS had slipped, adjusted back to 4.0)
2.   842
3.   838
4.   839
5.   849
6.   839
7.   842
8.   846
9.   852
10.   846
11.   845
12.   848
13.   845
14.   841
15.   850
16.   848
17.   845
18.   851
19.   849
20.   839 (off reg)

Shots 20-32:  839 fps down to 830


For shots 2-19
--------------------
High   851
Low   838
ES   13
ES%   1.54
Avg   845

End pressure 2200 psi
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on July 09, 2018, 05:39:57 PM
Jere,
That's alot of Hill parts in that gun.... My biggest question for you is what did Tim Hill say about it ?

My thoughts,
Everything looks great there to do the 40/40 but you can use some pixy dust. On the valve, did you open the throat to a minimum of .25" and no greater than .26" ? Even though you opened the port to 11/64 (.171") the valve still needs to breathe down stream to the HPA.
Hogging the entrance of the valve to .5" nearly all the way down to the poppet seat helps with the available plenum.

Lastly, opening the exit port,transfer port, and barrel port to .187" helps much better. To see the real results from a .187" porting, you should truly pull the shoulder back on the bolt probe.

If you were to do all that, I think you can get the 40/40 tune at just under 2000psi ( 1950 psi ).

It's a shame that no one sells a true guaranteed drop in 40/40 tune for a reasonable price yet.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 09, 2018, 06:43:45 PM
Jere,
That's alot of Hill parts in that gun.... My biggest question for you is what did Tim Hill say about it ?

Says sounds like I need a higher flowing valve assembly to get there.

Quote
My thoughts,
Everything looks great there to do the 40/40 but you can use some pixy dust. On the valve, did you open the throat to a minimum of .25" and no greater than .26" ? Even though you opened the port to 11/64 (.171") the valve still needs to breathe down stream to the HPA.
Hogging the entrance of the valve to .5" nearly all the way down to the poppet seat helps with the available plenum.

No, I didn't. Maybe because I didn't know to do that, and maybe because I don't know what the throat is. :-) Would that require a mill?

Quote
Lastly, opening the exit port,transfer port, and barrel port to .187" helps much better. To see the real results from a .187" porting, you should truly pull the shoulder back on the bolt probe.

I only went to 11/64" (.169") because Tim Hill said, "I don't drill the stock valve body more than .161 i.d..  I don't want to chance a bent valve seat from the constant high pressure." I know that he used to sell modified stock valves, so I figured it was good advice.


Quote
If you were to do all that, I think you can get the 40/40 tune at just under 2000psi ( 1950 psi ).

It's a shame that no one sells a true guaranteed drop in 40/40 tune for a reasonable price yet.

Thanks for the input.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: shorty on July 09, 2018, 07:49:29 PM
Jere,
I am sorry If I came across a little difficult. It's just because It looks like you spent a good bit of change to get a 40/40 tune.

The throat is just behind the poppet. You can use a drill bit but it is very challenging to keep the valve seat neat and clean for a good seal. If you do a drill bit make sure you "seat" the poppet well with a light abrasive such as car polish.

I am sorry again as all I did to get the 40/40 is all homemade parts except the reg.

The valve was hogged to the valve seat to .5" , the throat is .25" , I opened up the valve cap to .475" , made a new poppet spring to fit valve body/poppet head, drilled ports to .187", pulled back bolt probe, ran a short stiff spring.
The first time I did this was with a battery powered drill and vise.

Just doing that is good for 55fpe for 16 shots with 33.95's and just over 40 shots with 25.39's at 40 fpe.

Sorry if you took my comments the wrong way
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 09, 2018, 08:08:46 PM
Jere,
I am sorry If I came across a little difficult. It's just because It looks like you spent a good bit of change to get a 40/40 tune.

The throat is just behind the poppet. You can use a drill bit but it is very challenging to keep the valve seat neat and clean for a good seal. If you do a drill bit make sure you "seat" the poppet well with a light abrasive such as car polish.

I am sorry again as all I did to get the 40/40 is all homemade parts except the reg.

The valve was hogged to the valve seat to .5" , the throat is .25" , I opened up the valve cap to .475" , made a new poppet spring to fit valve body/poppet head, drilled ports to .187", pulled back bolt probe, ran a short stiff spring.
The first time I did this was with a battery powered drill and vise.

Just doing that is good for 55fpe for 16 shots with 33.95's and just over 40 shots with 25.39's at 40 fpe.

Sorry if you took my comments the wrong way

No, no, no! Just the opposite. I very much appreciated your suggestions. That's exactly what I asked for. I'm not sure what I said to make your feel otherwise. I surely didn't mean to, so I apologize for my obviously poorly worded reply. Where I said, "Maybe because I didn't know to do that, and maybe because I don't know what the throat is. :-)", I was making fun of my own ignorance when speaking to someone much more experienced. So, just lame humor perhaps?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Bigragu on July 09, 2018, 10:23:52 PM
Jere, put a hill peek striker on that hammer. You won’t believe how much that quiets down the gun. I already had Tim’s moderator installed awhile back, but recently installed the peek striker on his hammer, and I had to check the velocities it was so quiet. I got worried that I was shooting at around 500 FPS it was that quiet. Just a small PFFFTTT! Is all I hear now.

I’m averaging 841 for like 36 shots, using the 26 grain H&N crow magnums on my 25 cal. ChairGun says I’m at 41 ft lbs. Just did this today. 2 turns CW on that hammer spring adjustment is all.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Bigragu on July 09, 2018, 11:17:56 PM
And, I want to add, that Shorty not only knows his stuff with the tweaking of these marauders, but he’s very helpful thru PM’s also.

At least with me he is, lol!!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 09, 2018, 11:37:18 PM
And, I want to add, that Shorty not only knows his stuff with the tweaking of these marauders, but he’s very helpful thru PM’s also.

At least with me he is, lol!!

What valve are you using to get there?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Bigragu on July 10, 2018, 12:09:08 AM
And, I want to add, that Shorty not only knows his stuff with the tweaking of these marauders, but he’s very helpful thru PM’s also.

At least with me he is, lol!!

What valve are you using to get there?

I am using Tim Hill’s valve. It came with his premium kit. Basically everything you already have, but with his Audrius regulator and his valve.

The one thing I’ll never quite find out, is when I first installed that kit I was in the high 860’s to low 850’s for like 26 shots. An extreme spread of about 15 psi, and only two turns on the hammmer screw.

Then I foolishly watched a video on you tube, where a guy runs a ball hone to buff the pressure tube up. When I say foolishly, I’m meaning I should have left everything alone. I like the fact that I de burred all the slots and hole in the pressure tube, and got it to a mirror finish on the inside.

But since then, for the life of me, I cannot get up to the 860’s anymore for that long a string. 856 FPS, if I recall, was what I was averaging with that string.

 Oh, well. I’m so close to that 40/40 tune averaging 841, I’m just going to say I achieved it, lol
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on July 10, 2018, 12:43:09 AM

Here's a 40/40 tune I did, but was running 41 fpe for 35 shots instead, close enough.  The notes at the bottom in the graph show I was using the Hill valve and also the ports Tim was talking about, but I was also using a Hill TP at .161 so I was restricted at that point and still made it.  The reg was set 1950 psi as Tim talked about as well.  hope this helps.


(https://image.ibb.co/ch890o/25_39_tune.jpg)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Bigragu on July 10, 2018, 01:40:50 AM
Keith, thanks for posting that. I believe I saved that spreadsheet in my photos for to use as a guide
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Thane on July 10, 2018, 03:25:22 AM
Some progress with mrod .25 strings 25.39gr with Huma set at 1800, starting at 3100psi.

Red is my 40/40
Purple is a power 34gr  string  30/47
Blue for 55/38 near the valve lock point and wilder ES
Yellow was an attempt at reducing velocity with transfer port restriction of power tune only, poor shot count good ES.

Huma is the only purchased mod the rest came from the great contributions here using a small machine lathe and mill. Turned an MDS hammer with bronze insert, FFH with a stiff spring puts these strings within 3/4 of a turn preload.
Stock gen II valve, stock valve spring, .187 TP, 1/2 Bore, stock valve seat, .266" behind seat and ported. Turned bolt probe to 0.1" and shoulder turned back. Plastic line TP.

Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 10, 2018, 11:40:15 AM

What valve are you using to get there?

I am using Tim Hill’s valve. It came with his premium kit. Basically everything you already have, but with his Audrius regulator and his valve.

I considered that but wanted to see how close I can get this way first.

Quote
The one thing I’ll never quite find out, is when I first installed that kit I was in the high 860’s to low 850’s for like 26 shots. An extreme spread of about 15 psi, and only two turns on the hammmer screw.

Then I foolishly watched a video on you tube, where a guy runs a ball hone to buff the pressure tube up. When I say foolishly, I’m meaning I should have left everything alone. I like the fact that I de burred all the slots and hole in the pressure tube, and got it to a mirror finish on the inside.

But since then, for the life of me, I cannot get up to the 860’s anymore for that long a string. 856 FPS, if I recall, was what I was averaging with that string.

 Oh, well. I’m so close to that 40/40 tune averaging 841, I’m just going to say I achieved it, lol

That's seems to defy logic. Still, you got there.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 10, 2018, 11:41:50 AM

Here's a 40/40 tune I did, but was running 41 fpe for 35 shots instead, close enough.  The notes at the bottom in the graph show I was using the Hill valve and also the ports Tim was talking about, but I was also using a Hill TP at .161 so I was restricted at that point and still made it.  The reg was set 1950 psi as Tim talked about as well.  hope this helps.


(https://image.ibb.co/ch890o/25_39_tune.jpg)

Nice string! Also great spreadsheet/graphic. Thanks for posting it.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 10, 2018, 11:45:14 AM
Some progress with mrod .25 strings 25.39gr with Huma set at 1800, starting at 3100psi.

Red is my 40/40
Purple is a power 34gr  string  30/47
Blue for 55/38 near the valve lock point and wilder ES
Yellow was an attempt at reducing velocity with transfer port restriction of power tune only, poor shot count good ES.

Huma is the only purchased mod the rest came from the great contributions here using a small machine lathe and mill. Turned an MDS hammer with bronze insert, FFH with a stiff spring puts these strings within 3/4 of a turn preload.
Stock gen II valve, stock valve spring, .187 TP, 1/2 Bore, stock valve seat, .266" behind seat and ported. Turned bolt probe to 0.1" and shoulder turned back. Plastic line TP.

(https://lh5.googleusercontent.com/atkvMeYIzApINJuqWHoLhuNygsEgEhkwr_1cj5pod1DLSAouancoYP_BsKkh4oRXt7nEVaqvYpsGpw=w2836-h1618)

Thane - It looks like you are trying to post an image, but I'm not seeing it. Anybody else seeing the image?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on July 10, 2018, 11:46:31 AM
Here's a free spreadsheet a made to share if you need one:  Click here to download the free spreadsheet (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EBm-pOyrzbe_7awzH0Piii4KYHhR8Fev/view?usp=sharing
/)
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 10, 2018, 11:49:01 AM
Here's a free spreadsheet a made to share if you need one:  Click here to download the free spreadsheet (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EBm-pOyrzbe_7awzH0Piii4KYHhR8Fev/view?usp=sharing
/)

Yeah, I did need one. Thanks.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Thane on July 10, 2018, 01:41:46 PM
Fixed the attached image with my strings. Really like that spread sheet, will import some string data!

Nope, password protected spreadsheet...

Got it, stuck some strings in, very nice breakdown of data.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on July 10, 2018, 02:21:14 PM
Fixed the attached image with my strings. Really like that spread sheet, will import some string data!



Thanks!  I see you have some very nice strings there.  Your spreadsheet does compare more strings at a time.  My spreadsheet does have a place to store some strings for future reference plus the three graphs so 12 in total, IIRC.  I tried to keep the spreadsheet simple for the novice, but still have a few features too like comparing three strings at once with just a tab click.  Just paste your FPS string in the FPS column in any of the three graphs.  Just highlight, right click and select clear content for any past string data you want to remove.  There are some locks on certain cells to keep the formulas intact and prevent issues when using it.


I did create a much more advanced spreadsheet that is much more automated, but I don't think it's for everyone.  It will store 80 strings currently and automatically puts the full string and all associated notes and data in any of the three spreadsheets I select along with correcting any overlapping data.  Still working on more features for it too, just another hobby for me.  I like storing strings from the forum if all the data is provided.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: imadunatic on July 10, 2018, 07:20:44 PM
Here's a free spreadsheet a made to share if you need one:  Click here to download the free spreadsheet (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EBm-pOyrzbe_7awzH0Piii4KYHhR8Fev/view?usp=sharing
/)

Keith,

How did you get to the tune in the spreadsheet? That looks just about perfect to me.... (upper 800's with the 25.4's for over 35 shots).

Kevin
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 10, 2018, 07:22:00 PM
I was going to take the reg out and drop the pressure a bit and found out something interesting - the degas tool won't work with the Hill hammer with supplied set screw striker. Won't reach far enough. So, instead of just removing the reg, I had to take the rifle apart to get to the hammer. I installed the stock striker and locked it down. Then put back together and degassed.

I set the reg to about 130 bar, which is just at, or a bit shy of, 2k on the rifle gauge. We'll see what that does.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: oldpro on July 10, 2018, 07:42:11 PM
I was going to take the reg out and drop the pressure a bit and found out something interesting - the degas tool won't work with the Hill hammer with supplied set screw striker. Won't reach far enough. So, instead of just removing the reg, I had to take the rifle apart to get to the hammer. I installed the stock striker and locked it down. Then put back together and degassed.

I set the reg to about 130 bar, which is just at, or a bit shy of, 2k on the rifle gauge. We'll see what that does.
Pulling the reg in and out and degassing is a pain that’s all about to go away. Sorry the video is so clunky I was trying to balance the gun adjust the reg and watch the gauge while filming all by myself(bad idea) ;D      https://instagram.com/p/BlEXDu7HWXh/
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: oldpro on July 10, 2018, 07:46:18 PM
 Ill get Matt to film while I do it Friday this was late last night and I was all alone. First prototype by the way and it worked great!
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 11, 2018, 12:42:28 AM
Well, it looks like I made it to the 32/36 club. That's all day squirrel hunting on one fill. Not where I want to be but way better than before regulator and Hill parts.

So, where from here? I might try to hog out the valve as Shorty suggested, or I might go for a new valve. The question then would be, which one - the Hill valve or the Jefferson State/WAR valve and Twin Spring System?

Thoughts?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: oldpro on July 11, 2018, 12:54:30 AM
JSAR valve is best used unregulated it’s a power valve. The Hill valve is a good option but the WAR Cobra valve is probably the best valve made for regulating JMHO.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Motorhead on July 11, 2018, 01:01:48 AM
JSAR valve is best used unregulated it’s a power valve. The Hill valve is a good option but the WAR Cobra valve is probably the best valve made for regulating JMHO.

Will SECOND the WAR Cobra as an EXCELLENT valve in general & far better under regulation than any thing in the market place.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on July 11, 2018, 03:20:35 AM
Here's a free spreadsheet a made to share if you need one:  Click here to download the free spreadsheet (https://drive.google.com/file/d/1EBm-pOyrzbe_7awzH0Piii4KYHhR8Fev/view?usp=sharing
/)

Keith,

How did you get to the tune in the spreadsheet? That looks just about perfect to me.... (upper 800's with the 25.4's for over 35 shots).

Kevin



As best I can tell, those are not actual strings.  I think I do remember entering random numbers just to demonstrate the spreadsheet's displays.  It's been well over a year since I have even look at this.  If you notice the dates and regs are set the same on all three graphs and also the fill pressures so definitely not legitimate strings.  I always have data/notes of my setups and these strings are missing those.  You're suppose to replace them with your strings lol.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: imadunatic on July 11, 2018, 06:59:49 AM
You're suppose to replace them with your strings lol.

Yeah I got that... LOL. I just happened to notice while I was looking over the sheet that it looked awesome, like too good to be true.  ;D
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: imadunatic on July 11, 2018, 07:02:27 AM
JSAR valve is best used unregulated it’s a power valve. The Hill valve is a good option but the WAR Cobra valve is probably the best valve made for regulating JMHO.

Travis,

Any data on this? I'm most likely going regulated, hogged out stock valve first on the .25 synrod, but I've been eyeballing the JSAR and WAR valves for phase 2.

Kevin
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: mobilemail on July 11, 2018, 10:06:36 AM
Here is my contribution to the discussion.  I did this when about a month ago. The valve is not OEM, I think (but I'm not sure) it's a Cothran valve from at least four years ago. I have never disassembled or modded the valve, but it had a noticably lighter poppet spring than the OEM Crosman valve.  I used a full MDS JSAR hammer and an OEM hammer spring, and an Audrius regulator. Results are 40 shots @ 37fpe:

Jsb 25.4gr pellet                  
                  
   3000-1600psi
1   811   812   808   806   808   789
2   815   810   809   809   804   787
3   811   813   809   807   804   779
4   814   810   808   807   808   
5   814   811   807   810   806   
6   811   808   807   807   803   
7   811   811   808   808   796   
8   812   810   805   807   794   

Recorded in strings of 8 because of mag count.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 12, 2018, 12:43:19 AM
JSAR valve is best used unregulated it’s a power valve. The Hill valve is a good option but the WAR Cobra valve is probably the best valve made for regulating JMHO.

Will SECOND the WAR Cobra as an EXCELLENT valve in general & far better under regulation than any thing in the market place.

Is that valve compatible with the Twin Spring System?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: oldpro on July 12, 2018, 01:57:37 AM
 Scotty and I worked very hard on the Cobra valve when I was with WAR. I designed it and built the first Prototype here at home Scott then helped me test and refine it. I can’t build them for sale that would be bad Karma even though it’s my design. That design belongs to WAR now and you can contact Jim or purchase one on his website. As far as information there is plenty here just use the search engine. Scott has converted many valves himself to Cobra tech and used it to win his National FT title last year.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on July 12, 2018, 03:27:16 AM
JSAR valve is best used unregulated it’s a power valve. The Hill valve is a good option but the WAR Cobra valve is probably the best valve made for regulating JMHO.

Will SECOND the WAR Cobra as an EXCELLENT valve in general & far better under regulation than any thing in the market place.

Is that valve compatible with the Twin Spring System?


It sure is and I would recommend the TSS with dual springs especially if you plan on using the upper scale of a reg.  That valve closes back lightning fast and can be a little harder to crack open when approaching say a 2000psi set point.  Very nice valve indeed and extremely efficient on air usage.  It may also have had some revision from the original valve I have, but IDK of any personally.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 12, 2018, 02:02:02 PM
It sure is and I would recommend the TSS with dual springs especially if you plan on using the upper scale of a reg.  That valve closes back lightning fast and can be a little harder to crack open when approaching say a 2000psi set point.  Very nice valve indeed and extremely efficient on air usage.  It may also have had some revision from the original valve I have, but IDK of any personally.

I want 40 fpe, but with present setup (including Hill lightweight hammer and 262 hammer spring) and 4 turns on the HS, the cocking force is a tad more than I would like. Probably wouldn't be a problem with a side cocking mechanism, but I find it a bit tricky with the Marauder bolt system. At the same FPE - say 35-45 - would the TSS help that at all?

Also, in the same vein, I have read that an MDS hammer would help in cocking, but I have also read that there are problems, like expanding/contracting in different temps or humidity, etc. Do those claims have merit? If not, what MDS hammer would you guys recommend?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on July 12, 2018, 02:53:32 PM

The MDS "Super Hammer" from JSAR will make cocking much smoother.  It wont gall the air tube like the metal hammers do.  This will aid or eliminate double loading.

Most if not all of the issues with the MDS hammers stem from over tightening the hammer's lug screw.  Doing this will warp or disfigure the hammer causing binding with the air tube.  Just snug the cocking lug screw flush with the hammer and all should be fine.

With restricted air flow to the pellet skirt, cranking in the hammer spring is the only way to achieve enough valve lift to reach higher velocities.  It is much preferred to have sufficient airflow with short burst of HPA to gain higher velocities and to achieve the best efficiency and the easiest cocking effort.

Using two springs, which the TSS does, greatly reduces the cocking effort verses one heavier spring.  The TSS has more headroom than the stock end cap.  The longer the spring you can fit, the easier the cocking effort will be for a given tune.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 12, 2018, 02:55:47 PM

The MDS "Super Hammer" from JSAR will make cocking much smoother.  It wont gall the air tube like the metal hammers do.  This will aid or eliminate double loading.

Most if not all of the issues with the MDS hammers stem from over tightening the hammer's lug screw.  Doing this will warp or disfigure the hammer causing binding with the air tube.  Just snug the cocking lug screw flush with the hammer and all should be fine.

With restricted air flow to the pellet skirt, cranking in the hammer spring is the only way to achieve enough valve lift to reach higher velocities.  It is much preferred to have sufficient airflow with short burst of HPA to gain higher velocities and to achieve the best efficiency and the easiest cocking effort.

Using two springs, which the TSS does, greatly reduces the cocking effort verses one heavier spring.  The TSS has more headroom than the stock end cap.  The longer the spring you can fit, the easier the cocking effort will be for a given tune.

Great! Thanks for the info.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: AlanMcD on July 12, 2018, 03:12:57 PM
I will add that I have been running the JSAR valve regulated with great success, but I am doing so in a "power tune" configuration in a .25 cal Gen I Marauder.  I am running it regulated at 2100 psi using a lightweight hammer and an original TSS with 0.190" ports.  It is launching 34 grain JSBs at ~52 FPE, and is doing so at an efficiency level of 1.53 FPE/CI.  I am very happy with the overall performance of this set up - very powerful, accurate, quiet, and with reasonable cocking efforts.

My gun gives me 24 shots at this level off a 3000 psi fill, but I am using a lightweight air tube with an extra 3 inches of length . . . .
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 12, 2018, 03:18:25 PM
Oh, another question - It was suggested to go to maybe 3/16" for the valve and barrel ports. Tim Hill said that he was concerned that going bigger than .16" on a stock valve might "chance a bent valve seat from the constant high pressure". Has anyone who has gone this big ever had a problem with it?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: oldpro on July 12, 2018, 03:43:54 PM
I will add that I have been running the JSAR valve regulated with great success, but I am doing so in a "power tune" configuration in a .25 cal Gen I Marauder.  I am running it regulated at 2100 psi using a lightweight hammer and an original TSS with 0.190" ports.  It is launching 34 grain JSBs at ~52 FPE, and is doing so at an efficiency level of 1.53 FPE/CI.  I am very happy with the overall performance of this set up - very powerful, accurate, quiet, and with reasonable cocking efforts.

My gun gives me 24 shots at this level off a 3000 psi fill, but I am using a lightweight air tube with an extra 3 inches of length . . . .
Your correct Allan If you go beyond stock power levels and let the valve breath the JSAR valve is excellent not so at lower power levels though.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Thane on July 12, 2018, 04:06:20 PM
Oh, another question - It was suggested to go to maybe 3/16" for the valve and barrel ports. Tim Hill said that he was concerned that going bigger than .16" on a stock valve might "chance a bent valve seat from the constant high pressure". Has anyone who has gone this big ever had a problem with it?

I have over 2,400 shots on a stock valve with stock valve spring and transfer ports drilled to .187 with stock raised valve seat and no leaking yet. It is a very close cut behind the seat and if I did it again I would offset the port a bit for a safer margin. Stock valves are inexpensive and tinkering with them gives you great respect for the guys developing balanced valves and what they can achieve.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 12, 2018, 04:09:29 PM
I will add that I have been running the JSAR valve regulated with great success, but I am doing so in a "power tune" configuration in a .25 cal Gen I Marauder.  I am running it regulated at 2100 psi using a lightweight hammer and an original TSS with 0.190" ports.  It is launching 34 grain JSBs at ~52 FPE, and is doing so at an efficiency level of 1.53 FPE/CI.  I am very happy with the overall performance of this set up - very powerful, accurate, quiet, and with reasonable cocking efforts.

My gun gives me 24 shots at this level off a 3000 psi fill, but I am using a lightweight air tube with an extra 3 inches of length . . . .

If you don't mind saying, where'd you get the longer lightweight tube?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Motorhead on July 12, 2018, 04:59:47 PM
I will add that I have been running the JSAR valve regulated with great success, but I am doing so in a "power tune" configuration in a .25 cal Gen I Marauder.  I am running it regulated at 2100 psi using a lightweight hammer and an original TSS with 0.190" ports.  It is launching 34 grain JSBs at ~52 FPE, and is doing so at an efficiency level of 1.53 FPE/CI.  I am very happy with the overall performance of this set up - very powerful, accurate, quiet, and with reasonable cocking efforts.

My gun gives me 24 shots at this level off a 3000 psi fill, but I am using a lightweight air tube with an extra 3 inches of length . . . .

If you don't mind saying, where'd you get the longer lightweight tube?

Jefferson State Air rifles sells them
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 12, 2018, 05:33:37 PM
I will add that I have been running the JSAR valve regulated with great success, but I am doing so in a "power tune" configuration in a .25 cal Gen I Marauder.  I am running it regulated at 2100 psi using a lightweight hammer and an original TSS with 0.190" ports.  It is launching 34 grain JSBs at ~52 FPE, and is doing so at an efficiency level of 1.53 FPE/CI.  I am very happy with the overall performance of this set up - very powerful, accurate, quiet, and with reasonable cocking efforts.

My gun gives me 24 shots at this level off a 3000 psi fill, but I am using a lightweight air tube with an extra 3 inches of length . . . .

If you don't mind saying, where'd you get the longer lightweight tube?

Jefferson State Air rifles sells them

I had only looked at the one with the gauge port, and, apparently, you have to get one w/o the port in order to specify a custom length. I can't imagine doing without the gauge, so I guess it's not an option for me. Thanks.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: oldpro on July 12, 2018, 05:43:23 PM
I will add that I have been running the JSAR valve regulated with great success, but I am doing so in a "power tune" configuration in a .25 cal Gen I Marauder.  I am running it regulated at 2100 psi using a lightweight hammer and an original TSS with 0.190" ports.  It is launching 34 grain JSBs at ~52 FPE, and is doing so at an efficiency level of 1.53 FPE/CI.  I am very happy with the overall performance of this set up - very powerful, accurate, quiet, and with reasonable cocking efforts.

My gun gives me 24 shots at this level off a 3000 psi fill, but I am using a lightweight air tube with an extra 3 inches of length . . . .

If you don't mind saying, where'd you get the longer lightweight tube?

Jefferson State Air rifles sells them

I had only looked at the one with the gauge port, and, apparently, you have to get one w/o the port in order to specify a custom length. I can't imagine doing without the gauge, so I guess it's not an option for me. Thanks.
Jere you just call the shop we can make it with or without its up to you.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: Bigragu on July 12, 2018, 06:22:52 PM
I will add that I have been running the JSAR valve regulated with great success, but I am doing so in a "power tune" configuration in a .25 cal Gen I Marauder.  I am running it regulated at 2100 psi using a lightweight hammer and an original TSS with 0.190" ports.  It is launching 34 grain JSBs at ~52 FPE, and is doing so at an efficiency level of 1.53 FPE/CI.  I am very happy with the overall performance of this set up - very powerful, accurate, quiet, and with reasonable cocking efforts.

My gun gives me 24 shots at this level off a 3000 psi fill, but I am using a lightweight air tube with an extra 3 inches of length . . . .

If you don't mind saying, where'd you get the longer lightweight tube?

Jefferson State Air rifles sells them

I had only looked at the one with the gauge port, and, apparently, you have to get one w/o the port in order to specify a custom length. I can't imagine doing without the gauge, so I guess it's not an option for me. Thanks.

Jere, just make sure and plan on picking up the synthetic, MDS hammer from JSA, also, as you do not want to run your factory steel hammer against an aluminum tube. Hopefully you’ll get perfect timing, and JSA will have that new no bounce synthetic hammer in stock, when you do order their tube. That little invention right there, is a game changer.
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: GoneShootn on July 12, 2018, 06:36:48 PM
Jere, just make sure and plan on picking up the synthetic, MDS hammer from JSA, also, as you do not want to run your factory steel hammer against an aluminum tube. Hopefully you’ll get perfect timing, and JSA will have that new no bounce synthetic hammer in stock, when you do order their tube. That little invention right there, is a game changer.

Have you tried one of those hammers? Wouldn't the TSS, if you went that way, take care of bounce, too?
Title: Re: Calling all 25 cal marauder REGULATED guns
Post by: triggertreat on July 13, 2018, 12:41:45 AM
I have one of those new hammers in route to me.  Can't wait to test it out.  I do believe it will be a gem, but we'll see and report.