When I first got into casting I tried melting down a fishing weight, or something resembling one, it wasn’t my first time casting so I could tell something was wrong. It was a very time consuming process to separate all the dross from my good lead. I ended up discarding a few lbs worth of lead as a result.Good luck getting all the lead off, if I found myself in desperate need of pure lead, or at least usable lead I would probably buy a bag of lead shot. I once tried reclaiming lead from a car battery, I didn’t recover enough from it to even bother melting it. It was some kind of mesh, not much there.
It would appear you have Zinc contamination. GRRRR!I Can't for the life of me understand how the blocks got all of that on the surfaces. Unless you heated the molds in the lead, and they opened. Allowing the Zinc to weld. Never buy lead made from wheel weights. Too high a chance of getting Zink. And even if not, the antimony in it will cause the pellets to age harden. Not good. Not good at all.