After reassembly, I was pleased to find the weaker spring had solved the problem I was having. It also eliminated the weird squeaking sound that the pump had always made at the bottom of the compression stroke. So over the course of the last 2 weeks, the pump was much more enjoyable to use. Felt great and pumped great.
Yeah, extruding was also my best guess as to how it would fail so soon. I would have expected as much had it been a 60A but I figured the 75A would have fared at least better than roughly 10 rather sedate pumping sessions. It's what I had on hand so figured I would try it. Next time I go in, I'll get a small bag of 90A Viton and try again.