Greg,A 440 should shoot a 7.9 gr (Crosman Premier Hollow Points aka CPHP) pellet at ~ 900fps brand new after a few thousand shots may be down around 850. If you are getting much lower than that you have an issue. The issue may not be your spring though, it could be you piston seal or your breach seal. Breach seal is easiest to check with a piece of toilet tissue draped over the breach when shooting the tissue should not move or have holes in it. Next easiest to check is a visual on the spring it's self, pull the action out of the stock and look into the cocking slot, the spring should be nice and evenly spaced all along the slot if you see doubled coils it is broken. The Piston seal inspection require disassembly...