I recommend pure lead myself, I started out with lead that I found with my metal detector (lead pipe and ingots) that I'd found and originally saved for casting for my muzzle loaders however using it for pellets soon depleted the supply so I started buying pure lead from Rotometals which is about the best deal. I got the split pig ingot which in my case was 58lbs deleivered USPS. Right now it's getting to the point where I need to buy another one and they're actually cheaper now than what they were when I ordered my first one a year ago in July. They're 99.9% pure.