That's not the same pump link that was used on the 2100s.The ones I've seen have 2200 stamped on the left front side close to the main pivot.The best pump arms IMO are the old 766 versions with the protruding rivet.They're designed for a 4 3/4" stroke vs 5" for the newer guns.They also used a 1/4" longer brass valve which really helps the 22 cal guns.Since the gun sounds like it's powerful and accurate, you may just wish to get a 2100 pump link and adjustable piston.
The p/n for the 2100 pump link is 2200B013.I ordered a few in 2016, cost $7.05 apiece.Might try Crosman on Monday as they may still have some.Otherwise you can get them on Ebay.Like this one:https://www.ebay.com/itm/Crosman-American-Classic-BB-Pellet-Gun-177-Cal-Pump-Arm/273664067222?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649