GTA

All Springer/NP/PCP Air Gun Discussion General => PCP/CO2/HPA Air Gun Gates "The Darkside" => Topic started by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 01:01:36 PM

Title: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 01:01:36 PM
Ok I have seen a lot of questions regarding filling methods for PCP Airguns. Here is my opinion, but please share yours!
I have a benji pump, 3000 PSI 80 cu ft scuba tank with fill station and a 4500 psi Great white (97 cu ft SCBA) tank. What i have found is that for my needs right now the SCUBA tank and the pump are plenty. The scuba tank has a burst disc in the K valve assembly that will burst at 140% of the maximum psi rating of the tank or in the case of my 3000 psi tank that is 4200 psi. When I get my tank filled after it has had time to cool down the pressure in it is a little over 3300 psi. since my best shot strings with my P-Rod are achieved with a starting fill of 2700 psi down to 1700 psi I can get over 40 fills of my P-Rod. The tank still has plenty of pressure to fill my Disco to 2200 psi for many fills. Both the P-Rod and the Disco are not bad to fill with the benji pump. I bring just the pump when I'm in the field (ok sometimes I bring the great white  :D) So tell me, what do y'all prefer and why? Where do you get yours filled? Paintball shop?
 Scuba Shop? Fire Department? This might help answer some questions I have seen from newer PCP owners like me!

Thanks

Phil
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Geronimo on June 22, 2017, 02:13:00 PM
3 SCBA 4500 psi tanks. filled free by my local fire department. I shoot a lot and hated bothering them weekly. now with 2-60 minute and 1-45 minute tank, it's usually once a month. the cool thing is now some local firefighters have some interest in precharged rifles. I'll eventually get a compressor but it's hard to spend the money when I can get em filled now for free. my poor pump is very lonely.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 02:14:42 PM
3 SCBA 4500 psi tanks. filled free by my local fire department. I shoot a lot and hated bothering them weekly. now with 2-60 minute and 1-45 minute tank, it's usually once a month. the cool thing is now some local firefighters have some interest in precharged rifles. I'll eventually get a compressor but it's hard to spend the money when I can get em filled now for free. my poor pump is very lonely.
Very cool. I work for a city and the Fire Dept. fills my tanks for free also...sort of, I do spring for Pizzas or the occasional sandwich tray from Jimmy Johns.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Wayne52 on June 22, 2017, 02:21:12 PM
3 SCBA 4500 psi tanks. filled free by my local fire department. I shoot a lot and hated bothering them weekly. now with 2-60 minute and 1-45 minute tank, it's usually once a month. the cool thing is now some local firefighters have some interest in precharged rifles. I'll eventually get a compressor but it's hard to spend the money when I can get em filled now for free. my poor pump is very lonely.
You sure as heck can't beat that deal, I've got two of the SCBA tanks, it costs $5 a piece to get them filled but that's really cheap compared to what some folks have to pay.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lazer Wolfe on June 22, 2017, 02:26:56 PM
Like you I am new to PCP's as well. I found a scuba shop about 30 miles (one way) from me, problem is they only fill to 3,200 psi and I can't find anyone who fills to 4,500 in my area. so I purchased a trio of tanks-two full size and a pony to top off with. Most of my guns are larger caliber and really not so good up the air and I wanted to minimize trips to town as much as possible. I really can't speak on shot count or how well this system works for me because I've yet to try it out, life keeps getting in the way but hopefully that will soon change.

I don't have a pump at this point but might get one in the future.

I really need my own compressor but don't have a garage so not sure where I could put it.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Geronimo on June 22, 2017, 02:44:34 PM
3 SCBA 4500 psi tanks. filled free by my local fire department. I shoot a lot and hated bothering them weekly. now with 2-60 minute and 1-45 minute tank, it's usually once a month. the cool thing is now some local firefighters have some interest in precharged rifles. I'll eventually get a compressor but it's hard to spend the money when I can get em filled now for free. my poor pump is very lonely.
Very cool. I work for a city and the Fire Dept. fills my tanks for free also...sort of, I do spring for Pizzas or the occasional sandwich tray from Jimmy Johns.


that's the right thing to do. they charge zero but I usually "donate" a case of Gatorade when they fill them. the guys are super appreciative. the first time I brought Gatorade, they acted like I'd handed each of them a $100 bill. I don't mind to give when people appreciate your effort. couldn't ask for a nicer group of guys.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: wimpanzee on June 22, 2017, 03:05:44 PM
local paintball shop fills my 4500psi tank (to usually about 4300psi) for free. Well, almost, i float them a $10 or $20 whenever i have cash on me, which isn't often...
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: mann on June 22, 2017, 04:52:17 PM
I have a shoe box that I use in my basement with a small bostich shop compressor for a tank I got 90 cu in 4500 psi and a scuba tank but only use the small tank I get about 8 to 10 fills on my 25 mrod and more on my disco and like 5 or 6 fills on my recluse 357  takes about 45 mins to top off the tank to 4700 psi
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 04:55:57 PM
I have a shoe box that I use in my basement with a small bostich shop compressor for a tank I got 90 cu in 4500 psi and a scuba tank but only use the small tank I get about 8 to 10 fills on my 25 mrod and more on my disco and like 5 or 6 fills on my recluse 357  takes about 45 mins to top off the tank to 4700 psi
So a small compressor is enough to use with the shoebox? I'm thinking about getting one after we move to our new house. It's way further out in the boonies. how many gallons is your bostich compressor?
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Taso1000 on June 22, 2017, 05:41:01 PM
Quote
So a small compressor is enough to use with the shoebox? I'm thinking about getting one after we move to our new house. It's way further out in the boonies. how many gallons is your bostich compressor?

A Shoebox Max only uses .2 cfm @ 85 psi.  I don't know the exact numbers for the F10 version but maybe double that.  Super low air requirements.  Just make sure your compressor is oil free or you'll have to filter the oil.

Taso
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Alexander Arvizu on June 22, 2017, 08:13:04 PM
I use a HPA compressor and 90ci and 88cf scba tank. Compressor is small, inexpensive and fast. Never run out of air!
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: UncleJohn on June 22, 2017, 09:04:46 PM
I believe that one of the most important things when considering HPA cylinders is something I learned on Joe Brancato's web page.  Don't buy one if you don't have a way to fill them.  Sure, people move and situations change but the principle is sound advice.

I have two 4500psi cylinders.  I have a NinjaPCP and a 30-minute SCBA cylinder.  I have relatives in the local fire department so that is a big plus.  I use the larger cylinder to fill the small one so I can be more portable in  the field.  Some paintball fields have compressors which can fill to 4500 psi.  One near me does this for $5.00.

There's my story, I hope it helps.

John
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: mann on June 22, 2017, 09:10:57 PM
The bostich is like a 5 or 6 gallon compressor and I turn the regulator to about 95 psi to speed up the fill a little and it really isnt that loud
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on June 22, 2017, 09:28:52 PM
 ;D After I bought my third PCP the Hill Pump was permanently shelved. I bought the Freedom 8 compressor and a dual Gauge Guppy tank from Joe B. great rig and no regrets. I have since acquired two 45 minute SCBA tanks and slow fill valves for both I never run out of air or worry about getting the tanks filled
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 10:15:48 PM
;D After I bought my third PCP the Hill Pump was permanently shelved. I bought the Freedom 8 compressor and a dual Gauge Guppy tank from Joe B. great rig and no regrets. I have since acquired two 45 minute SCBA tanks and slow fill valves for both I never run out of air or worry about getting the tanks filled
Awesome solution. But I wouldn't expect anything less from an old pro like yourself.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 10:17:23 PM
I believe that one of the most important things when considering HPA cylinders is something I learned on Joe Brancato's web page.  Don't buy one if you don't have a way to fill them.  Sure, people move and situations change but the principle is sound advice.

I have two 4500psi cylinders.  I have a NinjaPCP and a 30-minute SCBA cylinder.  I have relatives in the local fire department so that is a big plus.  I use the larger cylinder to fill the small one so I can be more portable in  the field.  Some paintball fields have compressors which can fill to 4500 psi.  One near me does this for $5.00.

There's my story, I hope it helps.

John
Thanks John
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 10:18:12 PM
I use a HPA compressor and 90ci and 88cf scba tank. Compressor is small, inexpensive and fast. Never run out of air!
That's a great set up
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 22, 2017, 10:20:12 PM
Quote
So a small compressor is enough to use with the shoebox? I'm thinking about getting one after we move to our new house. It's way further out in the boonies. how many gallons is your bostich compressor?

A Shoebox Max only uses .2 cfm @ 85 psi.  I don't know the exact numbers for the F10 version but maybe double that.  Super low air requirements.  Just make sure your compressor is oil free or you'll have to filter the oil.

Taso
Great tip thanks! I really want a shoe box compressor. If for nothing else the freedom to fill at home and whenever I want.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: USAFANG6799 on June 22, 2017, 10:33:23 PM
When I was first looking to delve into the PCP world I chose the SCUBA tank because it was the least impact $ wise and fill wise. Dive shop less than 1/2 hour away, used tank for $80, $7 refill.
The cost of the MRod ll was expensive enough. Took my breath away thinking how expensive all that was. When I fill my MRod with air I also fill my lungs to help catch my breath given the cost of it all  ;D

Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: FuzzyGrub on June 23, 2017, 08:31:56 AM
Great tip thanks! I really want a shoe box compressor. If for nothing else the freedom to fill at home and whenever I want.

FWIW: The max will top off a guppy in less than an hour, from 3kpsi.  A 90ci, a little less time.  They work fine for all my prod versions and Mrods.   Now, tuning the bulldog (340cc), that sucked the guppy down very quickly. 

Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Sfttailrdr46 on June 23, 2017, 10:32:16 AM
Fuzzy, once we go to big bore and high FPE the Guppy becomes too small for anything but topping off in the field when hunting, it does not have the capacity for an all day range session with a few hundred shots .
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: FuzzyGrub on June 23, 2017, 10:59:08 AM
Fuzzy, once we go to big bore and high FPE the Guppy becomes too small for anything but topping off in the field when hunting, it does not have the capacity for an all day range session with a few hundred shots .

I'm lucky that the range is at my house, not far from the SB.  :)   But agree, a big bore at the range is going to need a bigger tank.  I think a 60 min SCBA would end up being the most economical.  If that is the case, I feel the SB max should be upgraded to at least a Freedom. 
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Conrad Smith on June 23, 2017, 11:19:03 AM
I have the Air Venturi and fill it at the local paintball place for $5. I asked the local fire department, they looked at me like I was crazy. They had never heard of a PCP. LOL
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Lmgunner13 on June 23, 2017, 03:07:46 PM
I have the Air Venturi and fill it at the local paintball place for $5. I asked the local fire department, they looked at me like I was crazy. They had never heard of a PCP. LOL
Yup I had the same experience at first. I had some pictures on my phone and am good friends with the Fire Marshal so that helped. The rural fire department doesn't have a dive team so they can only fill an older style of SCBA tank. But the station near city hall has the hot set up. Heading there now to fill my scuba tank.
Title: Re: Scuba vs SCBA
Post by: Conrad Smith on June 24, 2017, 05:40:12 PM
HA headed to the paint ball place and filled mine up this morning. :) Best $5 spent this week. LOL