Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl



Author Topic: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl  (Read 8476 times)

Offline JJ1514

  • Plinker
  • **
  • Posts: 102
  • yes
Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« on: January 30, 2012, 08:33:01 PM »
Hi, I am a new member here and I'm looking to get a new gun. I have narrowed it down between 2 choices, the walther talon magnum with nitro piston or the benjamin trail np xl. Which one would you reccomend? Thank you  ;)

  • Ridgefield,CT

Offline Tarheel

  • Raleigh, NC
  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1568
  • Real Name: Dave
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #1 on: January 30, 2012, 08:43:42 PM »
Welcome to GTA !

First of all, I would recommend deciding if you prefer a conventional stock or a thumb-hole stock.

Next, decide if you prefer a wooden stock or a composite stock.

The NP XL will need an aftermarket trigger blade ( $32.00 shipped - GRT-III from Charlie Da Tuna ), while the WTM's trigger is adjustable from the factory.

Since the initial investment price ( $300.00 ) is identical, that is not an issue.

In my opinion, those are the things to decide first.

Dave
Even with the finest pellet rifle in the world, shooting the most accurate pellet in that particular rifle, and sighting through a perfectly-adjusted scope with the world's finest optics, it all still boils down to the person holding the rifle . . . !

Crosman Nitro Venom .22 (Wood Stock)

180 BAR GAS RAM - HATSAN (Coming Soon )

Offline thekid

  • Old Timer
  • ******
  • Posts: 4019
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #2 on: January 30, 2012, 09:06:20 PM »
How long you been shooting airguns?
What is the primary purpose of this Airgun, target shooting, hunting and pesting, both?

Welcome to Gta
Rob

Offline Mpac

  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1635
    • My youtube channel
  • Real Name: Daniel
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #3 on: January 30, 2012, 09:16:08 PM »
I have the np xl and you'll need to invest on a bushing and washer kit they sell here on the forum. as for the trigger it'll take time to getting use too or get the grt trigger as Dave said.I have no idea on the walther talon someone will chime in on it soon.I really like my np xl with jsb 18 grain ammo.Here's a 20 yard group with my xl the group on the left is a 10 shot setting.
  • Telferner ,Tx
Keep Air Guns In The Right Hands(YOURS)
RWS 350Panther/22cal. self-tuned 29+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS 460Mag/22cal. >.130 wire 26.0 FT.Lbs.
RWS 350 Wood/177 cal. .130 wire Kit 22+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS P5 Mag/177cal. 6+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS 34's 177classic/22cal.both Vortek Kits
Beeman GS1000 177cal. 16.5 + Ft.Lbs.
Hatsan 135/.25 Vortek Kit 33+ Ft. Lbs.
Beeman QT(gas ram) 21.0+ Ft.Lbs.
Benji XL1100/22Cal. 26.7Ft.Lbs.
Remington Express/.177-15.5+Ft.Lbs.

Offline Nomadic Pirate

  • Hog Seeker
  • Old Timer
  • ******
  • Posts: 9325
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #4 on: January 30, 2012, 09:16:37 PM »
I have both,....Walther Talon NP all the way !!!
  • North Shore Oahu Hawaii
WARP .25

Offline Tarheel

  • Raleigh, NC
  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1568
  • Real Name: Dave
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #5 on: January 30, 2012, 09:27:16 PM »
Hi, I am a new member here and I'm looking to get a new gun. I have narrowed it down between 2 choices, the walther talon magnum with nitro piston or the benjamin trail np xl. Which one would you reccomend? Thank you  ;)

Also, which caliber ( .177, .22, .25 ) are you considering ?

Dave
Even with the finest pellet rifle in the world, shooting the most accurate pellet in that particular rifle, and sighting through a perfectly-adjusted scope with the world's finest optics, it all still boils down to the person holding the rifle . . . !

Crosman Nitro Venom .22 (Wood Stock)

180 BAR GAS RAM - HATSAN (Coming Soon )

Offline JJ1514

  • Plinker
  • **
  • Posts: 102
  • yes
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #6 on: January 30, 2012, 10:30:25 PM »
Sorry for not being specific, I am considering .177 or .22, I will be using it for targets and pest control, I know the .22 is more effective for hunting, but I like the .177 flatter trajectory. I have been shooting the same airgun for 2 years (crosman phantom). I like the wooden stock more, but i'll take performance over looks. Why would I need a bushing and washer kit? Thank you for your help ;)
  • Ridgefield,CT

Offline supertech77

  • supertech77
  • Old Timer
  • ******
  • Posts: 2246
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #7 on: January 30, 2012, 10:57:52 PM »
walther talon hunter all the way in 22cal.needs no trigger upgrade has a quattro,has a sas,and is dead nut accurate out of the box,mine was,and it was a spring gun then,now its a np,and its only 209,00 at air gun depot new,i would suggest you get one it 22cal.and use your phantom 177cal for plinking,i love mine.but the xl100 is imo a nice looking air gun,but i like thumb hole stock,si think the talon is more powerful,also you might want to consider a mike melick tuned b-28 or 25cal,he,s having a sale on the 25cal right now at flying dragon air guns,good luck choosing ;there are so many great options out there; ;D
[break barrels}
hatsan sc 22 pistol
wfh, 22 NP [tuned]
Ruger air magnum 177,[tuned]
22 cal [tuned]
25 cal [tuned]
np trail 22,[tuned]
 
(pcp's}               
B-50 177  [tuned]
B50 22 [tuned]
850 22 [tuned] 
mrod 22 [tuned]
mrod 25  [tuned]
Sumatra .25 cal 500[stock]
condor .25 [tuned]
condor .257 hot rod [D.N valve system]
rainstorm 2 357.[stock]
shin-sung Fire 201 / 357 [tuned]
Sam-yang 909t [aaf tune kit]
Sam yang 909s , 45 [tuned]
 TEXAN  457 . [stock ]

Offline Tarheel

  • Raleigh, NC
  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1568
  • Real Name: Dave
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #8 on: January 30, 2012, 10:58:58 PM »
Sorry for not being specific, I am considering .177 or .22, I will be using it for targets and pest control, I know the .22 is more effective for hunting, but I like the .177 flatter trajectory. I have been shooting the same airgun for 2 years (crosman phantom). I like the wooden stock more, but i'll take performance over looks. Why would I need a bushing and washer kit? Thank you for your help ;)

Since your application is target shooting & pest control, with a preference for .177 caliber and a wooden stock, I would recommend the Benjamin Trail NP XL 1500 over the Walther Talon Magnum,

I have a Crosman Nitro Venom ( wood stock ) in .22 caliber with a GRT-III trigger, but I am looking to get a Talon Magnum / Hatsan 125 ( same gun ), most likely in .22 caliber ( I have been looking at .25 ) and modify it for considerably more power, via a 180 bar gas ram swap, strictly as a hunting rifle.

For your application and needs, the Trail NP XL should be a great rifle !

Dave
« Last Edit: January 30, 2012, 11:07:15 PM by Tarheel »
Even with the finest pellet rifle in the world, shooting the most accurate pellet in that particular rifle, and sighting through a perfectly-adjusted scope with the world's finest optics, it all still boils down to the person holding the rifle . . . !

Crosman Nitro Venom .22 (Wood Stock)

180 BAR GAS RAM - HATSAN (Coming Soon )

Offline Tarheel

  • Raleigh, NC
  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1568
  • Real Name: Dave
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #9 on: January 30, 2012, 11:09:06 PM »
walther talon hunter all the way in 22cal.needs no trigger upgrade has a quattro,has a sas,and is dead nut accurate out of the box,mine was,and it was a spring gun then,now its a np,and its only 209,00 at air gun depot new,i would suggest you get one it 22cal.and use your phantom 177cal for plinking,i love mine.but the xl100 is imo a nice looking air gun,but i like thumb hole stock,si think the talon is more powerful,also you might want to consider a mike melick tuned b-28 or 25cal,he,s having a sale on the 25cal right now at flying dragon air guns,good luck choosing ;there are so many great options out there; ;D

Mick ( Supertech77 ) has a modified Talon Magnum that performs in the range I am looking for. It is a real "cannon", yet very accurate . . .

Dave
Even with the finest pellet rifle in the world, shooting the most accurate pellet in that particular rifle, and sighting through a perfectly-adjusted scope with the world's finest optics, it all still boils down to the person holding the rifle . . . !

Crosman Nitro Venom .22 (Wood Stock)

180 BAR GAS RAM - HATSAN (Coming Soon )

Offline Mpac

  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1635
    • My youtube channel
  • Real Name: Daniel
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #10 on: January 31, 2012, 09:21:21 AM »
http://www.airguntoys.com/NP-GRS-XL_files/NP-GRS-XL.htm here's a link that explains the kit.
  • Telferner ,Tx
Keep Air Guns In The Right Hands(YOURS)
RWS 350Panther/22cal. self-tuned 29+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS 460Mag/22cal. >.130 wire 26.0 FT.Lbs.
RWS 350 Wood/177 cal. .130 wire Kit 22+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS P5 Mag/177cal. 6+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS 34's 177classic/22cal.both Vortek Kits
Beeman GS1000 177cal. 16.5 + Ft.Lbs.
Hatsan 135/.25 Vortek Kit 33+ Ft. Lbs.
Beeman QT(gas ram) 21.0+ Ft.Lbs.
Benji XL1100/22Cal. 26.7Ft.Lbs.
Remington Express/.177-15.5+Ft.Lbs.

Offline JJ1514

  • Plinker
  • **
  • Posts: 102
  • yes
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #11 on: January 31, 2012, 01:52:21 PM »
So both guns would need that
  • Ridgefield,CT

Offline Mpac

  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1635
    • My youtube channel
  • Real Name: Daniel
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #12 on: January 31, 2012, 01:58:55 PM »
Just the np xl's as far as I know of it makes a world of difference on the shot cycle. Go on the search bar above and type in np xl1100 and read up on the gun .
  • Telferner ,Tx
Keep Air Guns In The Right Hands(YOURS)
RWS 350Panther/22cal. self-tuned 29+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS 460Mag/22cal. >.130 wire 26.0 FT.Lbs.
RWS 350 Wood/177 cal. .130 wire Kit 22+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS P5 Mag/177cal. 6+ Ft.Lbs.
RWS 34's 177classic/22cal.both Vortek Kits
Beeman GS1000 177cal. 16.5 + Ft.Lbs.
Hatsan 135/.25 Vortek Kit 33+ Ft. Lbs.
Beeman QT(gas ram) 21.0+ Ft.Lbs.
Benji XL1100/22Cal. 26.7Ft.Lbs.
Remington Express/.177-15.5+Ft.Lbs.

Offline JJ1514

  • Plinker
  • **
  • Posts: 102
  • yes
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #13 on: January 31, 2012, 03:35:09 PM »
I have read up on both, I have heard that the stock on the walther is hollow.I like the wooden stock on the benjamin, I have also heard that the benjamin had a lot of recoil. Does anyone know how the recoil its on the walthr does the sas make any difference
Thanks
  • Ridgefield,CT

Offline Nomadic Pirate

  • Hog Seeker
  • Old Timer
  • ******
  • Posts: 9325
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #14 on: January 31, 2012, 06:05:03 PM »
Recoil on The Talon is much less than the NP XL
  • North Shore Oahu Hawaii
WARP .25

Offline z28rod

  • Expert
  • *****
  • Posts: 1629
  • Deceased
  • Real Name: Brent
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #15 on: January 31, 2012, 06:24:24 PM »
Just fill the Talon stock with expandable foam, works great.
  • Hopewell Junction, NY
- Crosman Titan .22 Cal. W/3x9 Weaver and Leaper one piece mount and rings, tuna gold trigger. Under dime 25yrds. Cphp's.
- RWS 320m .177 4x RWS scope in mint condition.Getting tuned by dad the pro.
- B-28 .22 Cal. Fully Tuned by my dad the pro tuner. RWS 3x9 AO scope. BKL mount with magnum rings.
- Winchester 1000x .177 made by Hatsan, Turkish walnut stock.
- Beeman G1000 .177 mint.
- Hatsan 85 camo .22 Cal. w/4x Leapers scope.
- Crosman 760 in mint condition. Wood stocks. Oldie but goody.

Offline JJ1514

  • Plinker
  • **
  • Posts: 102
  • yes
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #16 on: January 31, 2012, 06:40:14 PM »
Thanks for the replies, right now i'm leaning towards the talon.
  • Ridgefield,CT

Offline codytwoeyes

  • Marksman
  • ***
  • Posts: 430
  • hillbilly
  • Real Name: Jack
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #17 on: January 31, 2012, 10:47:15 PM »
Question the kit. were do I order it from and how does it cost. I have a xl 22.
I did a mod on the trigger and its like a new gun. 98 cent bag of screws. replaced the short screw.
Wow what a change.
  • AL daphne
Pray hard
live well

Offline codytwoeyes

  • Marksman
  • ***
  • Posts: 430
  • hillbilly
  • Real Name: Jack
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #18 on: January 31, 2012, 10:51:03 PM »
expandable foam? how do you keep it out of the spring? I also have the hunter. Do not the hollow stock at all.
  • AL daphne
Pray hard
live well

Offline Bryan H.

  • Old Timer
  • ******
  • Posts: 3871
  • Real Name: Bryan
Re: Walther Talon Magnum w/ nitro piston vs Benjamin Trail np xl
« Reply #19 on: January 31, 2012, 11:42:27 PM »
in the talon magnum or falcon hunter, fill the buttstock with it.  it can't get into the spring from there.  the butt is hollow, fill it with something and it dampens vibration pretty good, plus it sounds much nicer when shot.  eliminates "hollow"noise.  i had a .25 talon mag that i filled with colorplace all purpose silicone sealant (actually about half the weight of regular caulk, but heavier than foam obviously).  turned out really well, balanced the gun much better for the artillery hold.  had to sel it though. 
.25 XS28M Flying Dragon Christmas Special

GTA - The best place for discussion about Air Guns.